(Poll) PG ''or'' PG-13?

[miraclefan]

Well what do you think? Will they give us a ''kid-friendly'' trek movie, or give us a PG-13 rating? From what weve seen from the trailers we will see the following. Birth scene, Giant ice monsters(Ooh scary for the kids!) Orion slave booty A lotta ''sci-fi action/violence'' and maybe a curse word or two. I say, PG-13! Well what do you think?

 

[Kelso]

Hard R.

 

[Lord Garth]

PG-13.

There are three types of PG-13: 1) A naturally PG-13 movie, 2) An otherwise PG movie with some extra goodies thrown in to amp it up, 3) An R-rated movie with the guts cut out of it, figuratively and/or literally.

I think it's probably PG-13 # 2.

 

[SalvorHardin]

Kirk says "man" in this movie...

That's enough to warrant an R or NC-17 or something for Trek fans.

 

[shapeshifter]

Based on previews I expect at least a PG13 and voted so, but I also see evidence of it being waved under the noses of kids younger than 13 so I am a little unsure of my choice.

They may hope the youngster's under 13 will tantrum their parents into taking them to see it.

 

[yakueb]

Rated R, for Robau.

 

[steveman]

PG-13. Take it to the bank.

 

[DeVario]

Kirk says "man" in this movie...

That's enough to warrant an R or NC-17 or something for Trek fans.

Ain't it the truth?

I say PG-13.

 

[miraclefan]

PG-13.

There are three types of PG-13: 1) A naturally PG-13 movie, 2) An otherwise PG movie with some extra goodies thrown in to amp it up, 3) An R-rated movie with the guts cut out of it, figuratively and/or literally.

I think it's probably PG-13 # 2.

Sorta, like the Dark Knight (PG-13,3) when that ''BAT-MAN'' was shown hanging at that window all cut-up and tortured, yet there's no ''BLOOD'' anywhere on him? Or when batman beats the ''CRAP'' out'a the joker in the police station, even raming his body up on that glass, yet there is no blood anywhere?

 

[kythe]

I'll be different and say I prefer PG, because most of the TV episodes would rate PG and it would be consistant. I don't really believe Star Trek is a kids show anyway, but I hope they don't feel they need to amp up the violence or sex appeal just for ratings. The story should be good enough for high ratings without any of the "extras".

 

[Kpnuts]

Doesn't Nero stab two Klingons in the chest?

PG13

 

[miraclefan]

Doesn't Nero stab two Klingons in the chest?

PG13

Is that a new ''scene''? I know in the Countdown comic he stabs the romulan ''praetor'' but I don't know if he stabs any klingon's?

 

[Kpnuts]

"Space is disease and danger, wrapped in darkness and silence"


At that point in trailer 2 you see Nero seem to stab two Klingons. Well looks like it anyway.

 

[dave_R_treker]

Kirk says "man" in this movie...

That's enough to warrant an R or NC-17 or something for Trek fans.

Ain't it the truth?

I say PG-13.

Definitly NC-17

 

[miraclefan]

I'll be different and say I prefer PG, because most of the TV episodes would rate PG and it would be consistant. I don't really believe Star Trek is a kids show anyway, but I hope they don't feel they need to amp up the violence or sex appeal just for ratings. The story should be good enough for high ratings without any of the "extras".

I don't know, a lot of modern trek ''enterprise'' were given ''TV-14'' ratings.

 

[MisterPL]

PG-13 statistically makes the most money. I'm betting Paramount was aiming for that rating all along.

 

[miraclefan]

^Your on the money!

 

[Aragorn]

NC-17 for the Rachel Nichols/Diora Baird girl-girl action scene.

 

[miraclefan]

NC-17 for the Rachel Nichols/Diora Baird girl-girl action scene.

Sorry to burst your bubble, but unless there both NAKED and doing HARDCORE lesbo things! what you mentiond would only warrent an ''R''

 

[Aragorn]

^ Actually, it's a lesbian scene that turns into a three-way. Chris Pine penis makes it NC-17.