• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Novels with Spock in command of the Enterprise?

That's not forgetfulness, that's just being lazy.

Well, it's not as if Tom Sutton and Ricardo Villagran were ever particularly consistent in the way they drew technology. You just sort of had to get used to it as part of their style. It wasn't like today where everyone has tons of Internet reference and DVDs at their beck and call. Photo references were fewer and farther between, and often the artists just chose to go from memory or imagination instead. It also took more time for art to be delivered (since it was physically mailed rather than e-mailed, and Villagran lives in Argentina), so there would've been less opportunity to make corrections. And the Surak showed up infrequently enough that it could kind of get lost in the clutter. In many of those issues I cited, it only appears in a few panels. (For instance, issue 26 is a Surak-focus story, but there are only two panels showing the ship's exterior, with all the rest of the story being set inside the ship or on the planet it's orbiting.)

And frankly, in the later DC issues that did become more dependent on photo reference, the result often looked stiff and collage-like. For all its inconsistencies, Sutton & Villagran's art had more energy and life to it.


And where was the editor during this stint?

Working on Star Trek and multiple other DC titles besides. Which is a lot of work. And ST probably wasn't anywhere near being DC's biggest seller, so Bob Greenberger (who edited all the listed issues except #16, which was co-edited by Mike Barr and Marv Wolfman) probably had to devote the bulk of his time and attention to other titles.
 
I don't think their Enterprise or Excelsior bridges had the same layout two issues in a row, either.

But I very much saw it as part of the comic's style. The only time I found it annoying was when they couldn't keep the past/present uniforms or ships straight in the Enterprise-meets-Excelsior time travel issue. In fact, it kinda ruined it.
 
And frankly, in the later DC issues that did become more dependent on photo reference, the result often looked stiff and collage-like. For all its inconsistencies, Sutton & Villagran's art had more energy and life to it.

Agree! And while I loved the switch to whiter paper, bolder colours, and no more half-tone shading in Series II, sometimes it was just too... densely coloured - and the over-reliance on familiar publicity shots of the cast became very distracting.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top