• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Contest: VOTE Nominees for the 1st Golden Gormaganders -- Part Two!

Lord Garth

Admiral
Admiral
Now for the second round of voting! Here's a link to Part One. This time, we'll be voting for the nominees of the following categories:
  • Behind the Scenes
  • Made for the Moment
  • Props, Costumes & Design

cn17hW6.gif


A special thanks to @Succubint and @Orac who helped me sort through everything! And a special thanks to everyone who helped to choose the nominees in the first place!

And another thanks to Succubint who designed the artwork for the Awards above!

Here are the Ground Rules:
1. You can only vote for ONE nominee per category.
2. You CANNOT edit your post once you've voted.
3. You don't need to vote for everything in the same post.

You have until Wednesday, August 22nd at 11:59pm EDT to vote! After that, we'll start the third and final part.

Behind the Scenes

17. Best Director
  • Jonathan Frakes
  • Olatunde Osusamni
  • Akiva Goldsman

18. Best Writer
  • Bo Yeon Kim & Erika Lippoldt
  • Ted Sullivan

Made for the Moment

19. Best Character Moment
  • Stamets confronts Tyler over Hugh's death
  • Burnham threatening another mutiny if Starfleet doesn't stop the genocide plan
  • Saru admits he's envious/jealous of Michael
  • Burnham finally accepts and watches Georgiou's last will and testament

20. Worst Character Moment
  • Burnham victory speech
  • Lorca is TEH EVIL!
  • Intro of Harry Mudd
  • Burnham mutinies on the Shenzhou

21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • USS Enterprise in distress Reveal
  • MU Georgiou and the Orion Rent a Slaves
  • Twisted bodies on the USS Glenn
  • Double Klingon dong

22. Best Ground Battle
  • Voq vs Ash
  • Tyler vs Saru
  • Lorca's vs Georgiou's forces phaser battle in "Vaulting Ambition"
  • Throne Room hand-to-hand fight in "What's Past is Prologue"

23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • "I still don't give a damn!"
  • Lorca deciding not to rescue Cornwell
  • Shipwide broadcast of Klingon attack in "Butcher's Knife"
  • Leaving Mudd in the Klingon cell
  • Killing the guard whose sister was betrayed/killed by Lorca

24. Best Plot Point
  • Mirror Universe jump
  • Sarek's disconnect with Spock explained in “Lethe”
  • Beginning Burnham's arc with a mutiny, and ending the arc on her threatening mutiny in order to save an entire race
  • Mirror Lorca reveal
  • Cornwell can't tell if Lorca is really him in "Lethe"

25. Best Tilly Moment
  • Gets high in WYTMH
  • "Hold your horses"
  • “Fucking cool”
  • "Did a Klingon just shush me?"
  • Tilly getting Burnham and Tyler to hook up

26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Klingon shush
  • First Black Alert on Discovery
  • Klingon double dong
  • Stamets walks away from his mirror, but reflection stays

Props, Costumes, & Design

27. Coolest Hair
  • Tilly
  • Killy
  • Detmer

28. Best Costume
  • Mirror uniform
  • Mirror Lorca
  • Mirror Captain uniform
  • Emperor Georgiou

29. Best Make-Up
  • Airiam
  • Saru
  • Clint Howard

30. Best New Design
  • Crossfield Class/Discovery Ship
  • Discovery bridge
  • USS Enterprise
  • Andorians
  • Phaser

31. Worst New Design
  • Klingon Ships
  • Kingon D7
  • Klingon Bird of Prey
  • Transporter room of Shenzhuou

32. Best Non-Hero Ship
  • Shepard Class
  • The Emperor's Palace ISS Charon
  • USS Gagarin
  • USS Buran
  • ISS Grimes
  • USS Shenzhou

33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Tilly
  • Gormagander
  • Ripper the Macro Tardigrade
 
Last edited:
18. Best Writer

  • Bo Yeon Kim

  • Erika Lippoldt
I don't understand this one. These two seem to have worked together on every episode their names are attached to. How is anyone supposed to be able to choose between them when we have no idea which of them is responsible for what?
 
Behind the Scenes
17. Best Director

  • Jonathan Frakes
Made for the Moment
19. Best Character Moment

  • Stamets confronts Tyler over Hugh's death
20. Worst Character Moment
  • Lorca is TEH EVIL!
21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • Twisted bodies on the USS Glenn
22. Best Ground Battle
  • Tyler vs Saru
23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • "I still don't give a damn!"
24. Best Plot Point
  • Sarek's disconnect with Spock explained in “Lethe”
25. Best Tilly Moment
  • “Fucking cool”
26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • First Black Alert on Discovery
Props, Costumes, & Design
27. Coolest Hair

  • Tilly
28. Best Costume
  • Mirror Captain uniform

29. Best Make-Up
  • Saru
30. Best New Design
  • Crossfield Class/Discovery Ship
31. Worst New Design
  • Kingon D7
32. Best Non-Hero Ship
  • USS Shenzhou
33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Ripper the Macro Tardigrade
 
I don't understand this one. These two seem to have worked together on every episode their names are attached to. How is anyone supposed to be able to choose between them when we have no idea which of them is responsible for what?

I'll merge them back together then.
 
cn17hW6.gif


And another thanks to Succubint who designed the artwork for the Awards above!
(Nice job @Succubint )

Behind the Scenes

17. Best Director
  • Akiva Goldsman
18. Best Writer
  • Ted Sullivan
Made for the Moment

20. Worst Character Moment
  • Burnham victory speech
21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • USS Enterprise in distress Reveal
23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • Lorca deciding not to rescue Cornwell
26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Stamets walks away from his mirror, but reflection stays
Props, Costumes, & Design

28. Best Costume
  • Mirror Lorca
29. Best Make-Up
  • Saru
30. Best New Design
  • Crossfield Class/Discovery Ship
33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Ripper the Macro Tardigrade
 
Behind the Scenes

17. Best Director
  • Olatunde Osusamni

18. Best Writer
  • Bo Yeon Kim & Erika Lippoldt
Made for the Moment

19. Best Character Moment
  • Stamets confronts Tyler over Hugh's death
20. Worst Character Moment
  • Lorca is TEH EVIL!
21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • USS Enterprise in distress Reveal

22. Best Ground Battle
  • Lorca's vs Georgiou's forces phaser battle in Vaulting Ambition
23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • Killing the guard whose sister was betrayed/killed by Lorca

24. Best Plot Point
  • Sarek's disconnect with Spock explained in “Lethe”
25. Best Tilly Moment
  • “Fucking cool”
26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Stamets walks away from his mirror, but reflection stays

Props, Costumes, & Design

27. Coolest Hair
  • Tilly
28. Best Costume
  • Emperor Georgiou

29. Best Make-Up
  • Saru
30. Best New Design
  • Phaser
31. Worst New Design
  • Kingon D7

32. Best Non-Hero Ship
  • USS Shenzhou

33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Gormagander
 
17. Best Director
  • Jonathan Frakes ('cause, hey, Star Trek)
19. Best Character Moment
  • Stamets confronts Tyler over Hugh's death
20. Worst Character Moment
  • Burnham victory speech
21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • USS Enterprise in distress Reveal
22. Best Ground Battle
  • Lorca's vs Georgiou's forces phaser battle in Vaulting Ambition
23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • "I still don't give a damn!"
24. Best Plot Point
  • Cornwell can't tell if Lorca is really him in Lethe
25. Best Tilly Moment
  • "Hold your horses"
26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Klingon shush
27. Coolest Hair
  • Killy
28. Best Costume
  • Mirror Captain uniform
29. Best Make-Up
  • Saru
30. Best New Design
  • Phaser
31. Worst New Design
  • Klingon Ships
 
Let's do this.

19. Best Character Moment --> Stamets confronts Tyler over Hugh's death

20. Worst Character Moment --> Burnham victory speech

21. Best Gratuitous Scene --> Double Klingon dong (If that's not gratuitous, I don't know what is. Sorry.)

22. Best Ground Battle -->
Lorca's vs Georgiou's forces phaser battle in "Vaulting Ambition"

23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment --> Lorca deciding not to rescue Cornwell (He can hide behind as many regulations as he likes. I know he wanted her to die.)

24. Best Plot Point --> Cornwell can't tell if Lorca is really him in "Lethe"

25. Best Tilly Moment --> "Hold your horses"

26. Best Weird-Out Moment --> First Black Alert on Discovery

27. Coolest Hair --> Detmer

28. Best Costume --> Emperor Georgiou

29. Best Make-Up --> Saru

30. Best New Design --> Crossfield Class/Discovery Ship (I've wanted to see this design used ever since I first saw it over 20 years ago)

31. Worst New Design --> D7 (not that I don't like the design but I wish it were called something else)

32. Best Non-Hero Ship --> USS Buran

33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform --> Gormagander (it's what we named the Awards after!)
 
17. Best Director
  • Jonathan Frakes
18. Best Writer
  • Bo Yeon Kim & Erika Lippoldt
19. Best Character Moment
  • Burnham threatening another mutiny if Starfleet doesn't stop the genocide plan
20. Worst Character Moment
  • Lorca is TEH EVIL!

21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • Double Klingon dong

22. Best Ground Battle
  • Lorca's vs Georgiou's forces phaser battle in "Vaulting Ambition"

23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • Killing the guard whose sister was betrayed/killed by Lorca

24. Best Plot Point
  • Beginning Burnham's arc with a mutiny, and ending the arc on her threatening mutiny in order to save an entire race

25. Best Tilly Moment
  • "Hold your horses"
26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Stamets walks away from his mirror, but reflection stays
27. Coolest Hair
  • Killy

28. Best Costume
  • Mirror uniform

29. Best Make-Up
  • Saru
30. Best New Design
  • Crossfield Class/Discovery Ship

31. Worst New Design
  • Klingon Ships

32. Best Non-Hero Ship
  • USS Shenzhou

33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Gormagander
 
Shame I missed Part One. Of the choices on offer:

Behind the Scenes

17. Best Director
  • Olatunde Osusamni

18. Best Writer
  • Ted Sullivan

Made for the Moment

19. Best Character Moment
  • Burnham threatening another mutiny if Starfleet doesn't stop the genocide plan

20. Worst Character Moment
  • (abstention)

21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • MU Georgiou and the Orion Rent a Slaves

22. Best Ground Battle
  • Throne Room hand-to-hand fight in "What's Past is Prologue"

23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • Lorca deciding not to rescue Cornwell

24. Best Plot Point
  • Mirror Lorca reveal

25. Best Tilly Moment
  • Gets high in WYTMH

26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Stamets walks away from his mirror, but reflection stays

Props, Costumes, & Design

27. Coolest Hair
  • Detmer

28. Best Costume
  • Mirror Captain uniform

29. Best Make-Up
  • Saru

30. Best New Design
  • Crossfield Class/Discovery Ship

31. Worst New Design
  • (abstention)

32. Best Non-Hero Ship
  • The Emperor's Palace ISS Charon

33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Tilly
 
17. Best Director

  • Olatunde Osusamni

18. Best Writer
  • Ted Sullivan

Made for the Moment

19. Best Character Moment
  • Burnham finally accepts and watches Georgiou's last will and testament

20. Worst Character Moment
  • Burnham mutinies on the Shenzhou

21. Best Gratuitous Scene
  • USS Enterprise in distress Reveal

22. Best Ground Battle
  • Throne Room hand-to-hand fight in "What's Past is Prologue"

23. Best Lorca Is a Prick Moment
  • Lorca deciding not to rescue Cornwell

24. Best Plot Point

  • Sarek's disconnect with Spock explained in “Lethe”

25. Best Tilly Moment
  • “Fucking cool”

26. Best Weird-Out Moment
  • Stamets walks away from his mirror, but reflection stays

Props, Costumes, & Design

27. Coolest Hair
  • Killy
28. Best Costume
  • Mirror Captain uniform

29. Best Make-Up

  • Saru

30. Best New Design
  • USS Enterprise

31. Worst New Design
  • Klingon Bird of Prey

32. Best Non-Hero Ship
  • The Emperor's Palace ISS Charon

33. Best Space-Faring Lifeform
  • Ripper the Macro Tardigrade
 
Voting for this round is closed.

I'll roll out the third and final part soon. Then we have the Awards Show!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top