• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

New Frontier - Characters don't look like described in the books

Srian

Ensign
Newbie
Hello all,

to attack my rapidly worsening withdrawal syndrome before the Typhoon Pact series I recently purchased the entire New Frontier line. Currently I'm reading "Dark Allies".

This was probably already discussed at the time, but one thing I find odd is that on the book covers Mackenzie Calhoun and Zak Kebron don't look at all like described in the text.

Calhoun looks different on every book. Sometimes he looks like Ken (Barbie's husband) or some other beau, sometimes like a funny little guy ("Once Burned"). The scar does not look so bad and he certainly has nothing whatsoever "savage" about him - not even a bad shave.

Zak does not look like a "walking landmass", more of normal build and one can easily imagine how he would nod. In the books there is constant referral to the fact that he does not have a neck and that his whole upper body moves when he attempts to nod.

Apart from this I really like the series. Peter David does seems to have a thing for planetwide desasters (Planet-Eating Borg, The Great Bird of the Galaxy, The Black Mass, The Doomsday Machine etc.) which for me sometimes goes a little bit over the top but on the whole I enjoy the stories, the twists and turns and the humor.

I could do without the brutality though.
 
Can't stand New Frontier, stopped reading a while ago, but I've always pictured Joe Flanigan from Stargate, or Alec Baldwin circa Hunt For Red October for Calhoun.
 
Last edited:
Just pretend they've been recast. Most books' descriptions of Doohan's Scotty wouldn't hold up against Simon Pegg's incarnation, or those of Kirstie Alley's Saavik against Robin Curtis - but they're still Scotty and Saavik.
 
...I've always pictured Joe Flanigan from Stargate...for Calhoun.

I've pictured Joe Flanigan as well. I've always thought, at least since I've known about Mr. Flanagan, that the cover to Once Burned's Calhoun looks a lot like him.
 
Can't stand New Frontier, stopped reading a while ago, but I've always pictured Joe Flanigan from Stargate, or Alec Baldwin circa Hunt For Red October for Calhoun.

I never watched Stargate and just looked up Joe Flanigan - I agree, he would make an excellent Calhoun - Thanks!
 
...I've always pictured Joe Flanigan from Stargate...for Calhoun.

I've pictured Joe Flanigan as well. I've always thought, at least since I've known about Mr. Flanagan, that the cover to Once Burned's Calhoun looks a lot like him.

Had to look that one up; didn't recall what it looked like. I would be extremely surprised if he wasn't the direct model for that cover.
 
The resemblance is pretty close, but the actual model for Calhoun was a neighbor of the original cover artist for the first few (most of the? All of the?) New Frontier books, Keith Birdsong. Flannigan's voice never felt right for Calhoun, though.
 
McHenry is all kinds of wrong on the cover for Being Human and even worse on Dark Allies. Yes, that's McHenry wearing the Exogenic Targeting Sensor on the cover!

if you want to know what they really look like, buy the Double Time comic.
 
^I'd say that for pretty much the whole cast at that point in the series. It has probably the most accurate representations of the characters. The second comic wasn't too bad, but I didn't like the art as much.
 
It's been a while since I looked through it, but doesn't Burgoyne's only appearance in Double Time consist of a single panel where we only see hir from the side? So Turnaround is pretty much the only real place we get a good image.

And yeah, McHenry on the covers look absolutely NOTHING like McHenry's description. Good God...
 
I agree there were some crappy covers as far as consistency goes. Personally, I always liked how some of the characters looked in Peter David's Starfleet Academy books. Soleta, McHenry, Kebron.

if you want to know what they really look like, buy the Double Time comic.
Do you know where I can find some example panels? I've tried to google it, but to no avail.
 
McHenry is all kinds of wrong on the cover for Being Human and even worse on Dark Allies. Yes, that's McHenry wearing the Exogenic Targeting Sensor on the cover!

I never would have thought that's McHenry!

if you want to know what they really look like, buy the Double Time comic.

Been thinking about that but for some reason even the second hand comics are VERY expensive here in the UK.

^i'll dig out and upload the panels i scanned for my old NF site...

That would be appreciated!:)
 
if you want to know what they really look like, buy the Double Time comic.

Correct. Peter David was able to work with the artist for WildStorm's "Double Time" graphic novel (also reprinted in the "Other Realities" omnibus, often easier and cheaper than the original) and is on record that those likenesses are definitive.

But yes, each novel cover painting of Calhoun has been different artists' interpretations of the same set of photographic stills taken by original NF novel cover artist, Keith Birdsong, who asked a ruggedly handsome neighbor to pose for pics as Calhoun.

I always reckoned he looked like a long-lost, purple-eyed Baldwin brother - or yeah, Joe Flanagan.
 
I think Peter David may have had Mel Gibson in mind when he created the character as McKenzie's story reminds me of Braveheart and even the character that McKenzie is patterned after , Quintin Stone from PAD's earlier Rock and a Hard Place seemed like Riggs from Lethal Weapon in many ways.
Though you may also not feel comfortable with Mel's face for Calhoun's.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top