Nero Alive !!!

[Nero's Shadow]

Just going 2 chuck this into the deep end but is there a slight and mean slight chance nero survived. Yes i know the neranda was smashed up like a grape but we only see nero for a brief moment closing his eyes and kissin his rommy ass goodbye. If prime spocks jellyfish ship could survive the black hole he could have escaped some how .? Anyway great film can,t wait 4 the 2nd one . !!!!

 

[gastrof]

No.

Like Nero's ship, Spock survived by going thru the black hole, using some trajectory method, according to rumor/insider info.

At the end Nero's ship had the black hole form INSIDE it.

He didn't go anywhere but SQUISH.

 

[Nero's Shadow]

I love conspiracy theory,s !!!

 

[Locutus of Bored]

Nah, he went to the great tattoo parlor in the sky I'm afraid.

 

[Vger]

The writers can always come up with a way but just because the jellyfish made it through the first black hole doesn't mean anything. They only used a specified amount of red matter when the first black hole was created and at the end of the movie all of the red matter was detonated. So I would imagine that black hole would be much stronger to allow anything to survive.

 

[Jeri]

I am a big fan of the Jellyfish; but fans are not in the mood for red herrings these days.

 

[Nero's Shadow]

LOL nice one i did like the tatts mean mo fo !!

 

[Nero's Shadow]

LOL nice one i did like the tatts mean mo fo Who is that pointed eared barstool !!!!

 

[Nero's Shadow]

Who is that pointed eared barstool !!!!

 

[blaXXer]

He's dead, Jim.

 

[Sharr Khan]

Nero lives (or will live) again at some point on the Alternate Romulus. He also must have had a younger counterpart walking around. Who by the way I feel sorry for since he's going to get the blame for Vulcan's demise...


Sharr

 

[gastrof]

Nero was considerably younger than Spock, so likely hadn't been born yet.

 

[Locutus of Bored]

Nero lives (or will live) again at some point on the Alternate Romulus. He also must have had a younger counterpart walking around. Who by the way I feel sorry for since he's going to get the blame for Vulcan's demise...

Not necessarily, on either count. This universe has been irrevocably changed by Nero's interference, and the dead parallel Romulus he loved would be drastically different from this one because of its altered relations with the Federation and Klingons (who will be none too happy about the loss of their 47 ships), or because the Romulans might seek reunification with their now almost extinct Vulcan brethren. Nero may never be born in this universe, unless you buy into the whole destiny/fate thing the movie suggests, and figure he's important enough in that to have him be reborn in basically the same form despite drastically different circumstances.

Plus, we don't know how old Nero was, but he clearly wasn't near old Spock's age, so I doubt there's a little Nero running around. Although, if there was, we could call the next film 'Finding Nero.'

 

[All Seeing Eye]

Just as the Nerada was to blow up in a final explosion Nero managed to find an escape pod which ended up jettisoning into the blackhole, this time the blackhole slung him into the future where he exited the blackhole in 2387

 

[Phily B]

I said before he could've been thrown into the future sometime, and still be alive. His ship is tough enough, and it wouldn't be too much of a stretch. I really liked Nero a lot though, he is the only Trek villain to have actually done anything and he was only a miner!

 

[Dac]

Ive been thinking, from a purely dramatic point of view, you could say that artificial black holes dont possess the power to spahghettify things, only compress and eject them (sort of like an external warp drive through time and space).

Forgive me for my shoddy science, but dont real lightning bolts possess thousands of times the power than that of which we are able to create artificially? I mean, for the purposes of testing housing and metal devices, artificial lightning is a good substitute, but it isnt the real thing. The same effect could go on with Black holes.

As for his ship, yes, it did get torn in two, and then blasted to many more pieces by the Enterprise - BUT, Canon be damned, the countdown comic's backstory that the Narada is infused with Borg tech MAKES SENSE. The ships interior looks like a Borg Cube, so It isnt a stretch to assume thats where the technology is from.

If it is filled with nanoprobes, it has the power to repair itself. So Nero might not have a single 5 mile long mothership, but after a while he might end up with 2 large ships and a few smaller ones which have "grown" propulsion systems.

 

[MadBaggins]

It certainly was intentionally left ambiguous. If he was FOR SURE dead they would have shown him dying with his skin melting. But we didn't actually see him die.

Maybe he'll be in the next movie all scarred and burned and will team up with The Borg or someone.

 

[Locutus of Bored]

Well, there was the whole thing with his ship imploding into nothingness with him inside it. So yeah, intentionally ambiguous.

 

[Nero's Shadow]

Wot about this nero survive,s and is found by the klingons know as KOR, KANG ,KOLOTH they hate kirk as much as tatt man nero. Revenge is a dish served cold and it,s very COLD in space !!!

 

[Jeyl]

Alright. Let me see what I can do with this one.

The Narada didn't implode. It was split into two separate sections. One section was the tentacle area that was facing the Enterprise, and the other was where everything crew related was located. Now since the red matter creates a black hole with two entry points on both sides, it's logical to suggest that Nero and his crew survived because the Enterprise was firing on the Tentacle areas that don't contain any sections where the Romulan Crew are. And since the black hole was well formed before the Enterprise open fired on the Narada, you can also speculate that none of the Enterprise's weapons hit the other side of the Narada where Nero and everyone else was located. You can see pieces coming off on the other end, but nothing as catastrophic as the tentacle area.

So that's my theory and I'm sticking to it. If you were to have a technical readout on the whole situation, you see that Nero and his crew did in fact survive the black hole. And since the ship is borgified, it's also logical to assume that it regenerated what it lost when it was split into two parts.

Didn't anyone pay attention to Star Trek ARG?