• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Most prophetic Star Trek episodes?

donovanQ

Cadet
Newbie
Hey... Yes, I'm a noob, please don't hate me.

I was wondering if you guys could help me out for a sec.

For a school assignment, I have to write a 500-word article listing/ranking things people may not know about — it has to be a unique topic about something I like.

The teacher OK'd my idea to write about five prophetic Star Trek episodes.

I may have to change my topic though unless I can think of more that will fit.

It's pretty general and broad — the teacher's a loose guy who doesn't really care; he just wanted it to be something we're passionate about.

What I'm looking for are any that were especially meaningful in their social or political themes or plotlines or allegory.

For instance, "Balance of Terror" would be a good one because of Kirk's comments about bigotry.

Anyway, I know that's kind of vague... any help would be appreciated. The instances can be specific or general, I suppose.

Thanks.
 
Well the DS9 2 part story Past Tense was pretty prophetic about societies treatment of the unemployed.
 
Yeah, they were actuallly talking about setting up those districts for the homeless in either San Fransisco or Los Angeles about the time the episode aired IIRC.

If you're just looking for bigotry stuff, TNG's Measure of a Man is a pretty good one for that.

Depending on how you look at it, the DS9 episode arc consisting of Homefront and Paradise Lost could be a pretty good allegory to the current situation in the US and its war on terror. There's also TNG's The Drumhead for that. not to mention DS9's Inquisition, and in a way, In the Pale Moonlight.
 
Not that helpful, but I believe in the Original Series episode Tomorrow is Yesterday, the Enterprise travels back in time to 1969, and when Uhura hooks into some local radio chatter, she hears a transmission from NASA saying the moon landing was scheduled for a Wednesday, and the actual moon landing happened on Wednesday, July 20, 1969.

The episode was made in 1966.

Not all helpful, or even prophetic! :D
 
DS9 Homefront/Paradise Lost - This episode dealt with how a society responds to terrorism. After 9/11, we've seen airport screenings that link well with the blood screenings. We've also seen the initial overreaction and eventual exaustion to that being played out today.
 
If you're open to other science fiction franchises, Babylon 5 had some good ones about a power-hungry president using a security crises to infringe on civil liberties and grab more power than he constitutionally should. Hmmmm. :borg:
 
If you're open to other science fiction franchises, Babylon 5 had some good ones about a power-hungry president using a security crises to infringe on civil liberties and grab more power than he constitutionally should. Hmmmm. :borg:
Was that President's initials GWB?:vulcan:
 
DS9 Homefront/Paradise Lost - This episode dealt with how a society responds to terrorism. After 9/11, we've seen airport screenings that link well with the blood screenings. We've also seen the initial overreaction and eventual exaustion to that being played out today.
Agreed! I love the line at the end of Paradise Lost by Sisko. "If they want to destroy paradise they will have to do it themselves, we are not going to help them." To me, speaking in a broad scope, we are destroying paradise ourselves today. With heightened security, air travel, public watch systems, economic woes, fuel, housing. IMO only, these things happened in part to how we as a country viewed or were told to view the events of Sept 2001. I know there were other factors also concerning each item brought up, however I do think that 9/11 had a lot to do with it. To me in a sense, the architect of that day probably knew that the events that would happen after the strike would be more detremental than the actual attack itself as far as the country is concerned. This is by no means taking anything away from the victims of that day, my heart goes out to them and their families. But with the way this country thinks, all it took was 1 attack to start the downhill process. I think we could use a little Sisko right now, or we will lose paradise.
 
I'm not sure exactly what you're looking for.

One or two off the top of my head -- cybernetics is growing pretty fast. In fact there's a professor in England who has an implant in his arm that can open doors. Also an experimental device allows a person to move a cursor with just his mind. I believe we've actually progressed to the point of having a monkey able to move a robotic arm just be thought. So the introduction of the Borg might count.

Secondly there are devices on TNG called isolinear chips -- they look and act pretty much like a thumb drive we use today. In the same way TOS trek had devices that looked very similar to 3.5 in. floppy disks that were in use up to recently.

I'm not sure whether Trek used Wormholes as a plot device prior to any scientific use, but you might want to check into that.

+++

In other sci fi's I'd point to:

Stranger in a Strange Land for a war the nobody cares about.

Dune mentions genetic manipulation and organ farming.

Brave New World mentions a society that's too busy being amused to notice that they live in a tyranny.
 
DS9 Homefront/Paradise Lost - This episode dealt with how a society responds to terrorism. After 9/11, we've seen airport screenings that link well with the blood screenings. We've also seen the initial overreaction and eventual exaustion to that being played out today.
Agreed! I love the line at the end of Paradise Lost by Sisko. "If they want to destroy paradise they will have to do it themselves, we are not going to help them." To me, speaking in a broad scope, we are destroying paradise ourselves today. With heightened security, air travel, public watch systems, economic woes, fuel, housing. IMO only, these things happened in part to how we as a country viewed or were told to view the events of Sept 2001. I know there were other factors also concerning each item brought up, however I do think that 9/11 had a lot to do with it. To me in a sense, the architect of that day probably knew that the events that would happen after the strike would be more detremental than the actual attack itself as far as the country is concerned. This is by no means taking anything away from the victims of that day, my heart goes out to them and their families. But with the way this country thinks, all it took was 1 attack to start the downhill process. I think we could use a little Sisko right now, or we will lose paradise.

I'm glad Im not the only one who noticed that!

I'll repeat what I said on another thread.

To me that episode was the exploration of the classic argument do you take to many steps in the name of security that you destroy what the security is designed to protect.

Fullerton saying "if the dominon saw you here whoring yourselves on Risa" is not a million miles away from the current "don't debate our forign policy or you'll embolden the enemy", in fact I think homefront and paradise lost was an excellent and erree precurser to the current hysteria over terrorism remember what the chengeling said to Sisko "..just four of us..on this entire planet...and look at the havoc we've wrought....we dont' fear you the way you fear us...in the end, it's your fear that will destroy you".


Clearly nobody in their right mind would describe the United States or the European Union, both of which have been victims of major terror attacks since 2001 as "paradise", but there is certanly plenty worth defending, but the point of that episode holds true, a bunch of isolated rag tags can't destroy it...but we can by overreacting to them.
Granted in reality there has been no military coup in the USA or EU but theres plenty of very dangerious steps in the direction of a more athoritarian stance like the patriot act, military commissions act, torture and imprisonment without trial.

They showd in the end they were able to destroy the dominion threat without sacrificing the very things they were fighting to protect, definitly a major lesson to be learned there.


Among other things ST predicted:
-Hyposprays now exist (called powderjects tho)
-Desktop computers
-Voice recognition and fast info retreval via computers
-Stealth Technology

I think Past Tense had an important message too, apart from the frightening fact that something similar to sanctuary districts was considerd in LA and I heard the idea broached even here, it shows that sweeping social deprevation under the rug like we do now with gettoisation and the welfare trap, quick fixes that don't solve the underlying problem, you end up making the situation worse and maybe even resulting in violent revolts.


Thankfully they did get two things majorly wrong though (so far!)
World War III (tho we came dangeriously close in the Cuban Missile Crises and with the Able Archer incident in the 1980s)
Eugenics, I don't know about the US but cloning of humans and genetic engering of humans is banned in the EU
 
Could I make a humble suggestion regarding your topic? Instead of five "episodes" which is rather difficult and esoteric anyway except for Star Trek fans, could I suggest you pick five general areas?

For example,

communications technology (which is very easy),

medicine (a little research would render this one easy as well),

terrorism/security/war (where you could point to some of the episodes here mentioned),

social perceptions (you could point to TOS having the first interracial kiss, now not all that controversial on tv, and to a lesser extent DS9's kiss involving Jadzia and that other girl),

and something else.


I'm sure your teacher would find this acceptable, and it would be a much easier and more fulfilling way to approach the topic, I think.
 
What I'm looking for are any that were especially meaningful in their social or political themes or plotlines or allegory.

I have two examples for the above. The TOS episode with the guys with the one side of their face black and the other side is white. (Can't remember the episode)

At one point in the episode one of the guys says "What is wrong with you, can't you see that he is black on the right side and white on the left, while I am black on the left side..." Indicating that he thinks his prejudice towards something so inane is meaningful. A good statement about the idiocracy of prejudice.

The other example is Nemesis from Voyager, Chakotay is conscripted into an alien war fighting on one side. After he is rescued, he returns back to Voyager but is still shaken up about everything. He then meets the ambassador from the aliens he was fighting against, and Chakotay kind of freaks out and has to leave the room. Outside the room someone asks him what is wrong. And Chakotay responds by says "I wish it were as easy to stop hating as it was to start."

I have always remembered that line ever since I first heard it. It makes alot of sense and it unfortunate that it resonates so closely to the way some people feel.

Good luck with your report!
 
Last edited:
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top