Most Liked/Disliked Fight Club...

[Farscape One]

The "THRESHOLD" thread on the VOYAGER forum... someone posted that "Code of Honor" and that one should get in the ring and fight for worst episode title.

I got to thinking... maybe we can do that for real. Perhaps take the 'winners' of the recent "Most Disliked Episode" for each series and pin them against each other... maybe even have the 5 top Most Disliked from each to make it more varied, and do a vote system similar to those contests.

And we can do the same for the Most Liked ones, too.

What do you all think?

 

[GreenDragonKnight]

Ah Threshold Threshold Threshold… yes yes yes yes yes, everyone says Threshold is the absolute worst VOY, and, indeed, probably the worst Star Trek episode ever made... no!!! Yes, it's corny and hokey and stupid and ridiculous; but it is not the worst Voyager episode. That's gotta be either the Fury or Mortal Coil. And the absolute worst Star Trek episode ever is Trip Dies in Riker's Holodeck.

 

[cosmic mouse]

The "THRESHOLD" thread on the VOYAGER forum... someone posted that "Code of Honor" and that one should get in the ring and fight for worst episode title.

I got to thinking... maybe we can do that for real. Perhaps take the 'winners' of the recent "Most Disliked Episode" for each series and pin them against each other... maybe even have the 5 top Most Disliked from each to make it more varied, and do a vote system similar to those contests.

And we can do the same for the Most Liked ones, too.

What do you all think?

I like this idea... I'm down with it.
I say take the most disliked ep from each season from each series and pit them against each other.

So, eg, the 7 most disliked eps from VOY go against each other and a grand supreme disliked ep from each series get matched against each other to determine one, overall ST turkey.

 

[Farscape One]

Well, the 'winners' and runner ups of those seasons are already on that thread, so we can simply get all the shows at once.

 

[cosmic mouse]

True, but it seems that, and this is not specific to this board, every time a contest runs the voting is slightly different or variable . It would be interesting to see a contest thread for each series and then a big throw down at the end for the Master of disliked eps.
But maybe the peeps here are all set with the 'dislike" threads ... you would know better than I would since I'm still a newbie of sorts.