Let us play by giving our beloved Star Trek captains with these RPG stats : Leadership, Ship Combat, Personal Combat, Tech. Expertise and Diplomacy. The score should be from A to E. Which A is the best, and E the worst. You can also give a score S, a perfect score, if you think that the captain is so overpowered or a Mary Sue level. But only 1 S per character. Charisma : The charisma of the Character. If this score is perfect (S), then he / she can found a Religion which is he / she proclaimed as the god. Because people will gather / flock into his / her cause and will help him / her unconditionally. Ship Combat : Self Explanatory. How the captain is excel in Ship Combat. The S Score means that he / she has no match in ship vs ship battle. Personal Combat : If this score is perfect, even Bruce Lee will bow and call him / her Sensei. Technical Expertise : This score include Science and Engineering. If this score is perfect, The captain can become a Star Trek Ethan Hunt. Because he / she can solve every technical issue without any help. Diplomacy : How good the captain solve the problem without shooting a phaser / Torpedoes. Rules : 1. This scoring only apply to the captain of a ship. Yes, that's mean Picard, Kirk, Sisko, Pike, Riker, Sulu, Lorca, Georgiou, Burnham, Saru, Archer, etc. 2. Please, if you think that it is not necessary, don't give them a perfect score (S). Because A is already so good. But if you must, you can only give one S score to one character. This is my Example : Jeanluc Picard : Charisma : S <= Look at him, when he said "Let's rebel!" All TNG casts will join his cause unconditionally. Tac. Combat : B <= His best performance was Picard Maneuver Per. Combat : C <= He was never a warrior to begin with. His movie version was him at steroid mode. Tech. Expert : B <= Picard always shout "Mr. Data!!!!" But at least he knows something, so he's not ignorant. Diplomacy : A <= He's a diplomat after all. Lorca : Charisma : D <= Even Burnham betray him, when he wanted to beat an evil queen in Mirror Universe. Tac. Combat : A <= No Captain can bring out Discovery full tactical capability like Lorca in Disco Season 1. Per. Combat : C <= He doesn't has anything special. Tech. Expert : B <= At least he can bring Discovery to the Mirror Universe. that's quite a feat. Diplomacy : D <= I never know Lorca wants to solve something peacefully. Captain Georgiou (the prime version) : Charisma : B <= At least she can make Burnham idolized her. Tac. Combat : D <= Are you kidding, I doubt that she knows how to win a ship battle. Per. Combat : B <= Well, at least she could beat some Klingons before she was killed. Tech. Expert : C <= She knows some technical, or, is she? Diplomacy : D <= She can't even prevent a losing war against Klingons, and died because of it. Captain Sisko : Charisma : A <= He's quite charismatic, although I doubt that DS9 crews will join him if he joined Marque rebellion. Tac. Combat : A <= Are you kidding me, he lead a fleet in a winning battle against Dominion Per. Combat : A <= Not everybody can beat Klingon in a fight, and he beats several of them. Tech. Expert : A <= He designed Defiant!!!! Diplomacy : B <= Well, he couldn't even prevent Dominion Wars to happen. But at least he's quite a diplomat.