• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Keli Lane found guilty of Tegan's murder

Miss Chicken

Little three legged cat with attitude
Admiral
The jury has reached a decision is what must be one of the most bizarre murder trials in Australian history.

Former water polo champion Keli Lane has been found guilty of murdering her baby.
Lane screamed "no", collapsed and fell off her seat on to the floor of the Sydney court as the verdict was read out. An ambulance was called.
Her mother also screamed "no" from the public gallery and burst into tears.
Lane, 35, had pleaded not guilty to murdering her daughter, Tegan, shortly after leaving Sydney's Auburn hospital in September 1996.
It took a week of deliberations for the NSW Supreme Court jury of six men and six women to reach a verdict following a four-month trial.
She was also convicted of three counts of making a false statement on oath in relation to documents dealing with her adopting out two other babies.
About ten minutes after the ambulance was called, Lane composed herself and sat in the dock with her lawyer.


Rest of story here


He is how the case was reported back in August

IF TEGAN LANE were alive today, she would be 13. Police have never found her body, but they believe they have finally gathered the evidence to prove her mother, Keli Lane, killed her soon after her birth in 1996.
It was one of three times Ms Lane, a national representative water polo player, gave birth without her partner, her family or her fellow athletes knowing.
Ms Lane, now 34, will face the Supreme Court in Sydney on December 4, charged with Tegan's murder, almost three years and nine months after a coroner concluded the missing girl was dead, but stopped short of calling it foul play....................................

Keli Lane was a 21-year-old water polo star when she gave birth to Tegan at Auburn Hospital on September 12, 1996.
Two days later, she left the hospital in a taxi at 2pm. Tegan has not been seen since
At the conclusion of an inquest in February 2006, Coroner John Abernethy described the case as surreal. Ms Lane chose not to give evidence. Her barrister, Peter Hamill, SC, insisted Ms Lane was innocent and suggested Tegan was still alive.
Ms Lane was two days shy of her 20th birthday when she had her first child, a girl, at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital in March 1995. She had cried when hospital staff brought her a cake.
On the hospital record she named the father as Duncan Gillies, a rugby player and her boyfriend at the time. But the inquest - starting nine years later - would hear he was not the father. Furthermore, he had no idea she had been pregnant.
Ms Lane gave up this girl for adoption and was soon back in the pool, training to represent Australia at the Junior Water Polo Championships in Canada.
Eighteen months later, she gave birth to Tegan. She was still with Mr Gillies. By now she had been spending four nights a week at his Gladesville home. Yet again, however, he did not notice she was pregnant, and he would tell the inquest this made him feel like a fool. They broke up in 1998, but he said he would never know if he was Tegan's father because Ms Lane had left hospital before DNA samples were taken.
It was not until May 1999 - with the arrival of Ms Lane's third child at Ryde Hospital - authorities started to ask questions. Where was Tegan?
Ms Lane had chosen to give up the third child. A Department of Community Services worker, processing this adoption, noted the hospital record of Tegan's birth, but no other paperwork.
Later, Ms Lane would tell Detective Senior Constable Richard Gaut that Tegan's father was Andrew Norris.
The first public appeal for Tegan came with the launch of the inquest in October 2004. As the close of the inquest in 2006, the coroner asked police to do more work on the case.
They had already checked school enrolments for all girls in Australia born on September 12, 1996. While they found a Tegan whose father was called Allen Norris, DNA tests proved she was not the one. Now police checked records for girls with different birthdays, but a similar age, in NSW. After the inquest the police's unsolved homicide unit went further and tried to find Tegan by checking records of all girls in Australia of her approximate age - close to 100,000.


Rest of story here


I have always thought she was guilty as there seemed to be no other reasonable explanation for Tegan's disappearance. However I wasn't certain that she would be convicted.
 
What surprised me was that when she was found guilty, she collapsed in shock. ReallY? What else did she expect?

Did she do it? I'm inclined to think so, but then I thought Lindy Chamberlain did it, I paid too much attention to mainstream media then. There is a slim chance Keli didn't do it, but the whole "I gave the baby to the daddy" thing, then being unable to find her, him, a birth certificate, or any other evidence at all, make it implausible she's alive.
 
I always thought that Lindy Chamberlain was innocent especially after hearing Tasmanian woman, Sally Lowe's, version of what happened that night. Sally says she heard the baby cry after Lindy was suppose to have murder her. Sally had no reason to lie to protect Lindy, she had only met Lindy that day.

Keli Lane never reported her child missing, and I think it is highly improbable that she handed him over to the man she claimed to be the father. Wouldn't the father had wanted DNA testing before taking the child especially as Keli claimed they only had a brief affair.

I honestly think Keli would have adopted the baby out except that would have meant that she would have had to stayed in hospital longer while it was arranged. Keli didn't want to stay in the hospital because she was expected at the wedding.
 
Wait, how can you convict in a case like this without any evidence whatsoever? There's not even any evidence that there had actually been a crime at all, let alone that this person committed it.
 
Of course there was evidence. She left the hospital with the baby and cannot account for what happened to the baby, It isn't as if the baby could have just decided to get up and walk away.

She left the hospital with the baby and turned up at the wedding less than 4 hours later without the baby. She has had 14 years to tell the world what became of the baby and has told 8 different stories. The police have investigated 100,000 girls Tegan's age in an effort to find her.

If it had been an older child (i.e. capable of walking off), a teenager or an adult that disappeared it would have been a different matter. It would have been a different matter if she had reported the child missing. This isn't the first time a person has been convicted of murder without a body ever being found.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top