Okay, let me start off by staying I enjoyed it. I know the show has a lot of hardcore fans to this day (and on this forum) and many friends have been encouraging me to watch it for a long time. Observations:
The relationships in Season One seem a bit forced or out of place. The crew reaches a kind of familial bond of renegades, but I don't really understand why or how... Its characters are a group of obvious stereotypes. In fact, the only character that has proven some real depth so far, surprisingly, is D'Argo, who I expected to be your typical Worf-clone yet ultimately has more feeling and past than all of the characters combined.
Crichton I can't help but like. He represents the human race well, has a full range of emotions, resourcefulness and skills, and manages to be a thoughtful, altruistic person in damn near every situation. Sometimes he strikes me as a bit of a caricature and is written similarly to how Enterprise writers would paint Jonathan Archer. The acting is good enough, however, that he pulls off the role beautifully and makes his consistent goodness a believable part of his personality. The scene where he confronts Crais in his cell on Moya is pure gold.
At the end of season one, I guess I wish I cared more. The "bad guys" are your typical nefarious mustache-twisting types (the worst actually named "Scorpius," --- may as well be "Dr. Evil" )---you've got the "bad girl," the blue Vulcan, the puppet, and your human searching for home. It's all fun, but unlike the DS9 and B5 predecessors I haven't gotten to a point where I forget that I'm watching a TV show and start caring about the characters and plot. I want to, so I'm forging ahead!
Ultimately, like I said I'm enjoying it-- just pointing out some concerns and things I hope they flush out a bit. The show is a blast, but I hope it takes on a little more depth in the latter seasons.
Any thoughts? Please avoid specific spoilers beyond the Season 1 finale and the season 2 opener, "Mind the baby."
The relationships in Season One seem a bit forced or out of place. The crew reaches a kind of familial bond of renegades, but I don't really understand why or how... Its characters are a group of obvious stereotypes. In fact, the only character that has proven some real depth so far, surprisingly, is D'Argo, who I expected to be your typical Worf-clone yet ultimately has more feeling and past than all of the characters combined.
Crichton I can't help but like. He represents the human race well, has a full range of emotions, resourcefulness and skills, and manages to be a thoughtful, altruistic person in damn near every situation. Sometimes he strikes me as a bit of a caricature and is written similarly to how Enterprise writers would paint Jonathan Archer. The acting is good enough, however, that he pulls off the role beautifully and makes his consistent goodness a believable part of his personality. The scene where he confronts Crais in his cell on Moya is pure gold.
At the end of season one, I guess I wish I cared more. The "bad guys" are your typical nefarious mustache-twisting types (the worst actually named "Scorpius," --- may as well be "Dr. Evil" )---you've got the "bad girl," the blue Vulcan, the puppet, and your human searching for home. It's all fun, but unlike the DS9 and B5 predecessors I haven't gotten to a point where I forget that I'm watching a TV show and start caring about the characters and plot. I want to, so I'm forging ahead!
Ultimately, like I said I'm enjoying it-- just pointing out some concerns and things I hope they flush out a bit. The show is a blast, but I hope it takes on a little more depth in the latter seasons.
Any thoughts? Please avoid specific spoilers beyond the Season 1 finale and the season 2 opener, "Mind the baby."
Last edited: