I applaud all of it. Can't wait to see the result.J.J. Abrams is making a unique Star Trek film, but is aware of Star Trek's vocal fans.
As reported by Los Angeles Daily News, Abrams, who admits to having been more of a Star Wars fan than a Star Trek fan, is adding action to Star Trek. "The movie we're making won't feel like any other 'Star Trek' you've ever seen," he said. "There hadn't been this kind of action in a 'Star Trek' movie before."
But he hastened to add that Star Trek XI won't deviate from what Gene Roddenberry had envisioned for Star Trek. " is being true to the vision of our abilities and of what Roddenberry started," said Abrams. "So it's this very interesting hybrid of honoring its origins and also being something completely brand new." Abrams wants to make a good movie with appeal to all, including the existing Star Trek fans. "As a director, my sole mission was to make a movie that was entertaining and emotional and funny and scary and all of the things that I know I want to see when I go to see a movie," he explained. "It's a huge adventure. But because we've done a lot of work leading up to it, it was already honoring 'Trek' for those very vocal fans."
The only probem I see with this approach is that i don't think it will work. You just can't make a hard-core Trekkie movie that will appeal to fans while making a fun light-hearted aci-fi action movie that appeals to people who don't like Star Trek.
Trekkies will insist that every minor inconsistancy be explained (like the length of the ship), that every move the engineers make to save the day be explained by Treknobabble and reversing the polarity and quantum doohickies
of doom. They'll complain endlessly about the uniforms, that Sulu is seem in spy pictures with a katana (allegedly, it looks like a kitchen knife to me), and other bovine fecal matter.
None of that matters to mainstreamers. They want a big adventure that isn't bogged down by all the details that Trekkies love. They don't know all the lore, don't give two shits about continuity, and most definately are going to get annoyed by all the blather about quantum this, shield integrity that, and recalabrating the replicators.
I'd dump the Trekkies and go for the mainstream. Mainstream is bigger, and they'll spend more money.
Dump the Trekkies!!
YEAH!!