• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is There any Science Left In Doctor Who's Science Fiction?

^ Indeed, soft science fiction and hard science fiction.

Doctor Who is soft sci-fi. It's "soft" because it doesn't presume to be able to explain what the hell is going on, just that SOMEONE in the story understands it, and that their understanding is that some sort of well-known scientific principle is at work even if they can't plausibly explain it to anyone else (least of all the audience, but most importantly, the other non-scientist characters and/or protagonists).

Star Trek is soft sci-fi too, even though it pretends not to be. There's not a whole lot of difference between not being able to explain the science and pretending that you can, except the latter sometimes gets pretentious if you let it go to far.

Soft science fiction is more common because it is usually more character oriented and has less to do with science than it does with how the characters use it and interact with it. We don't, for example, need to know what powers the TARDIS to understand the Doctor's relationship with it; we have no idea how a sonic screwdriver works, but we know the Doctor loves it and always keeps it handy and we also know that it's very VERY cool. Least of all do we understand how the TARDIS' dimensional/spatial thingie works, we just know that everyone who sees it for the first time gets a really weird look on their face and runs circles around the box gasping to themselves "It's bigger on the inside..."

That's science fiction for you. It's "soft" because we don't understand it. And that difference is really kind of unimportant, because if you're honest with yourself you realize that you don't really understand HARD science fiction either and it's all very much the same to most people.
 
The Doctor has previously been seen to be able to survive for brief periods in the vacuum of space. Nightmare of Eden and Four to Doomsday, for example. Yes, the science is still highly questionable at best but there are precedents.

You beat me to it, I had a vague memory that Time Lords could survive in space for brief periods of time. Though to be far for quite a few people the current run is the only DW they are familar with as either:

1.>They grew up in the wilderness years when DW wasn't in production (on TV at least)

2.>They aren't British and as such it aired a bit hit and miss in their country of residence.
 
Very little in DW these days stands up to reason. In series 5 we had a character - Amy Pond - still existing after both her parents had been retroactively erased from existence! How do we explain this? Answer: we can't. It's a trifle annoying, but it doesn't stop me from persevering with the show.

Actually, it is explained and quite clearly in the Night and the Doctor mini-episode included with the DVD release, which is a followup to the question Amy tries to ask but never gets around to in the Comic Relief mini-episode "Space".

Alex
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top