• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is an iPod Classic still a good buy?

S. Gomez

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Maybe this belongs in Science & Technology. Oh well. A mod would know better than me.

So the time has finally come for me to cave and buy an iPod. And by strange coincidence Apple has just unveiled some revamping of that particular product line. :) Now the question is (as always), which one to buy? (I've already cancelled the iPod Touch as an option, since the 16GB model is more than twice the cost of the same capacity Nano; not to mention I'm only using this for audio-on-the-go, so why would I pay for useless features?)

I don't have a huge music library at 10.34GB, but I would want something that could hold it all at one time (I'm one of those who likes to have everything at my fingertips just in case). At first glance, this would seem to be the higher-end iPod Nano with 16GB. But I'm going to be taking a trip next month and want to take a few audiobooks with me, which is going to increase my needed capacity by an unknown amount (maybe it would still be enough, but who knows?). The actual size of the Nano is also a concern, since I'd like something I can, y'know, actually handle and use.

So ideally I would want an iPod Classic, which is a *whole* lot more space--and room to grow--for only about $70 more (I'm in Canada, in case anyone's wondering about the prices). Unfortunately, it also looks like the iPod Classic may be retired soon, what with the fact that nothing's really been done to it other than cutting it down to a single 120GB model. Not necessarily a huge cause for alarm, as I've heard from others that these things tend to last a few years.

It sounds like I've talked myself into it already, haven't I? I dunno, would storing my music on an old-fashioned hard drive make me a fuddy-duddy? :D
 
Personally, I'd go with the 16GB Nano. The Classic is still based on a harddrive while the rest use flash RAM, which is less likely to have a failure. Which is one of the reasons I think they are being phased out. The only reason they're still around is the harddrives capacity compared to that of the flash RAMs.

Also, if you only have a 10.34GB music library then you still have a lot of room left. Depending on how fast you you're collecting digital music files that is. Once you get an iPod your library will probably begin to grow a lot faster. I know mine did. Though I wouldn't worry about those audio books taking up much room. Typically they are encoded at a far lower bit rate and so have a lot smaller file sizes then music ones.

The thing is also pretty small and can fit in your pocket easily.
Height:3.6 inches (90.7 mm)Width:1.5 inches (38.7 mm)Depth:0.24 inch (6.2 mm)
 
I have a 160 gig classic and it's got 90gigs of just music on it, before the video files.

If you've only got 10 gigs, the 16gig nano sounds like it will be plenty for you.
 
It kind of pisses me off that they dropped the 160GB Classic. I should have bought one while I had the chance. Mea culpa...
 
It kind of pisses me off that they dropped the 160GB Classic. I should have bought one while I had the chance. Mea culpa...

Buy a refurb on the online store. $249

As to the O.P., if you're just interested in Audio, I would suggest the Nano. The flash drives are more responsive (quicker) and why would you buy space you're not going to use?

That said, if you want the 120 GB of room and can find a use for the space, then the Classic works just fine. There's nothing wrong with it. All I'm saying is, the extra space is the only reason to buy it now. If you need it, get it. If not, get something else.
 
It kind of pisses me off that they dropped the 160GB Classic. I should have bought one while I had the chance. Mea culpa...

Buy a refurb on the online store. $249

Already on it. ;)

Also, I wonder if cases made for the previous iPod with Video can be used with a Classic. The reason I ask this is because I have a great case, made by iSkin, for my current 5G video iPod (which I'm about to replace). Unfortunately, the iSkin cases for the Classic all appear to suck. It'd be cool if I could use my old case...
 
Well, I had the iPod Classic for quite some time (two-three years). It didn't frizz on me until like a month or two ago but I also think that was partially my fault. So I definitely say that if you want a lot of open space for a lot of songs, videos and photos, that the iPod Classic is the way to go.

Also, on a side note: I had a 30GB storage capacity and I believe that held 25,000 songs. My new iPod Classic has like 80GB of storage, which is more than enough for me. I guess it depends on how much storage you want for your songs, video files, etc etc.
 
I have the 80GB video iPod. Love it! You can always take stuff off, and store it on iTunes, so the 80GB is really enough storage.
 
^They're useless for me. Don't need 'em, don't want 'em. Sorry if I sound a little harsh. :) But even more key is that the iPod Touch is stretching my price range a little more than I'd like.

I guess what's tipping me in the direction of the Classic is (as has been brought up) the idea that my library will grow. I just put a few CDs on iTunes and the amount went up more than I thought it would; there are going to be quite a few more for the trip. And on top of that I've been browsing on iTunes and found quite a bit that I would more than love to download. So 16GB is actually starting to look a little cramped at the moment, even though 120GB is also looking quite spacious. I wish Apple could have left the 80GB version, then I would snap it up without a second thought.
 
I wish Apple could have left the 80GB version, then I would snap it up without a second thought.


Well, the 120 GB costs the same as the 80 GB did last week. So really, they did keep the 80, and just threw in some more space for free.

But, as I said to the guy looking for the 160 GB, you can still get refurbished units.

They're in perfect condition and covered by the exact same warranty as brand new ones.

The 80 GB classic is going for $189 (CAN $) compared to $249 (CAN $) for the new 120 GB.

So you can save some money by going that way. The link is at the bottom of the store page on apple.com
 
I like the new Nano, I'd likely go for one if I were in the market for a new DAP, which I'm not.
 
The 16gb nano could get crowded fast, especially if you add a few videos. Audiobooks don't take up all that much space depending on how they are compressed though.

You won't get a full 16gb because of the operating system; likely closer to 14.5 gb
 
Yeah, I think it depends on how you plan on using your device and whether or not you care about having flash memory vs. a hard drive. It's expensive, but there's also the 32GB Touch now I guess.

I'm sure HDDs are better now, but I remember crashing my 4th Gen iPod's hard drive when I was walking too fast, so I stick with flash memory... even if the space is extremely limited.
To be honest, that's the real rub. Jobs/Apple is so obsessed with this idiotic streamlined design that they won't allow any room for expansion. Gack.
 
^What's so "idiotic" about it ? They've sold 150 million iPods of various flavours and they make an iPod for every market.

If you want a lot of storage space, buy an iPod Classic. I may sound like Bill Gates here, but I can't imagine why someone would desperately need to carry more than 160gb of music around with them unless they're such a purist that they store everything as uncompressed WAVs.
 
The 16gb nano could get crowded fast, especially if you add a few videos.

Fortunately the Nano is so limited in the range of video formats it accepts and the processes required to convert videos into that format so inscrutable that any concerns regarding its limited capacity are academic.
 
^The iPod supports the MP4 format which is rapidly becoming the industry standard. It is not Apple's fault (or Sony, Nintendo, Microsoft or anyone else who supports the format) that said format is not the choice of pirates everywhere.

Apple, and pretty much every other consumer electronics manufacturer, makes products for normal people. This is why they do not sell a 500gb portable video player with MAME support, readers for every different format of memory card and the ability to install all sorts of "homebrew" software.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top