Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 2

[Michael]

The Rules

• Each episode starts on 10 points.
• 1 Vote every calander day per member.
• On each vote you must both:
• Heal your favorite story + 1
• & Hurt your least favorite stoy -2
• (You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa)
• Once an episode reaches zero it's out
• Episodes are ranked in order of elimination
• Please indicate which episoes you have voted for

Here's the ranking of Season One:

1st: Duet
2nd: Emissary
3rd: In the Hands of the Prophets
4th: Captive Pursuit
5th: Progress
6th: Battle Lines
7th: Past Prologue
8th: Vortex
9th: Babel
10th: A Man Alone
11th: Dramatis Personae
12th: Dax
13th: The Forsaken
14th: The Storyteller
15th: The Passenger
16th: Q-Less
17th: If Wishes Were Horses
18th: The Nagus
19th: Move Along Home

______________________________________


Season Two

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 10
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 10
Sanctuary 10
Rivals 10
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 10
Shadowplay 10
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 10
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 10

 

[Michael]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 10
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 10
Sanctuary 8 -
Rivals 10
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11 +
Shadowplay 10
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 10
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 10

 

[Orac]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 8 -
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 10
Sanctuary 8
Rivals 10
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11 +
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 10
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 10

 

[boognish]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 8
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 10
Sanctuary 8
Rivals 8 -
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 10
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 11 +

 

[tomalak301]

The Homecoming 10 +
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 8
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 10
Sanctuary 6 -
Rivals 8
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 10
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 11

 

[BigFoot]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 6 -
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 10
Sanctuary 6
Rivals 8
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 10
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 12 +

 

[AdmiralGarak]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 6
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 8 -
Sanctuary 6
Rivals 8
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 11 +
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 12

 

[D'deridex]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 6
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 8
Sanctuary 4 -
Rivals 8
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 10
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 11
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 13 +

 

[Defcon]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 10
Cardassians 10
Melora 6
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 6 -
Sanctuary 4
Rivals 8
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 11 +
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 11
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 13

 

[erastus25]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8 -
Cardassians 10
Melora 6
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 6
Sanctuary 4
Rivals 8
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 11
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12 +
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 13

 

[Garth Rockett]

The Homecoming 10
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 6
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 6
Sanctuary 2 -
Rivals 9 +
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 11
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 13

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

The Homecoming 8 -
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 6
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 6
Sanctuary 2
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 11
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 14 +

 

[Orac]

The Homecoming 8
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 4 -
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 7 +
Sanctuary 2
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 11
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 14

 

[Defcon]

The Homecoming 8
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 4
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 5 -
Sanctuary 2
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 11
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12 +
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 14

 

[boognish]

The Homecoming 8
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 2 -
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 5
Sanctuary 2
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 12 +
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12
Blood Oath 10
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 14

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

The Homecoming 8
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 2
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 3-
Sanctuary 2
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 12
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12
Blood Oath 11+
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 14

 

[Michael]

The Homecoming 9 +
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 2
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 3
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 12
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12
Blood Oath 11
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 14

Eliminated:

26th: Sanctuary

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

The Homecoming 7 -
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 2
Rules of Acquisition 10
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 3
Rivals 9
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 12
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12
Blood Oath 11
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 15 +

Eliminated:

26th: Sanctuary

 

[naf9sd]

The Homecoming 7
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Melora 2
Rules of Acquisition 11 +
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 3
Rivals 7 -
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 12
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12
Blood Oath 11
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 12
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 15

Eliminated:

26th: Sanctuary

 

[BigFoot]

The Homecoming 7
The Circle 10
The Siege 10
Invasive Procedures 8
Cardassians 10
Rules of Acquisition 11
Necessary Evil 10
Second Sight 3
Rivals 7
The Alternate 10
Armageddon Game 10
Whispers 10
Paradise 11
Shadowplay 12
Playing God 10
Profit and Loss 12
Blood Oath 11
The Maquis, Part I 10
The Maquis, Part II 10
The Wire 13 +
Crossover 10
The Collaborator 10
Tribunal 10
The Jem'Hadar 15

Eliminated:

25th: Melora
26th: Sanctuary