• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Good Video-to-iPod/iPhone Software????

JediKnightButler

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
I've been looking recently for some good software, paid or free, that works well with converting DVD content into good looking iPod/iPhone suitable format. I've tried a few programs so far and have mostly been disappointed so far:

1.) 123 DVD2iPod: Although obviously specifically geared to the conversion of DVD to iPod format, the customer support sucked, the quality of videos were questionable (and didn't support the iPhone's screen resolution), and the program was very buggy and infrequently worked as advertised. I ended up just uninstalling it and got a refund.
2.) Media Coder: This was suggested to me by somebody on another board but it has been a nightmare to try to get work and I finally just gave up.
3.) GOM Encoder: Works well but requires a GOM watermark on the free version and there's absolutely no information anywhere where you can purchase the full version that does not force the watermark on you.
4.) Badaboom: Thought that this would work great but just found out my system is not compatible with it.:scream:

The only program (ironically a FREE one) that I've found works well for video conversion is Format Factory, however, despite the ease of use, as well as the much better quality of picture, I would like another program, paid or otherwise, that includes more customizable features, is compatible with the iPhone, is easy to use, and comes closest to emulating iTunes-quality videos (at least the non-HD ones). Oh, and I would like something that helps you find the content that you want to rip.

Anybody using anything that might match this description? Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!
 
Handbrake.

Handbrake.

Oh, did I mention Handbrake?

Be sure to toggle on the 'presets' window and just use those.

(Oh, and be sure to download the new VLC player too. It uses files from that to work properly. You don't need to use VLC, just have it installed.)
 
Very good informative thread. Thanks for the info guys. However, I'm getting conflicting stories on the legality of ripping DVDs for my own personal use. Does anyone know the definitive answer on that?
 
Very good informative thread. Thanks for the info guys. However, I'm getting conflicting stories on the legality of ripping DVDs for my own personal use. Does anyone know the definitive answer on that?

It's completely legal, under fair use doctrine, to make archival copies of media that you own for backup purposes.

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act, however, makes it illegal to circumvent copy protection. :lol:
 
So ultimately it's not technically legal to do it then. Oh well, as I said in another thread on the Science forum, I don't feel particularly inclined to obey the strict letter of the law in this case.

All of this is so silly. I can buy a DVD and watch it as many times as I want, including in various portable DVD devices, but if I "circumvent copy protection" so that I can put it on my Ipod, well then I'm breaking the law. :rolleyes:
 
The Videora converter is great, I've used it a bunch of times.

Yeah, it's the easiest.
My only problem with it is that it requires an internet connection - which makes absolutely no sense to me.

SUPER is good too, but it's very esoteric (because you can convert anything to anything with it).
 
For those of you who reccomended Handbrake, I installed it tonight and it's telling me it won't work for copy protected DVDs. Which I thought was the whole point of this thread. So I'm back to square one. Any suggestions on a way around this, or do I need to find another program?
 
Last edited:
Is it just a warning or will it not work?

It may just be a legal protection move by the distributor. I have never had any problem making copies of any DVD I have.
 
It will not work, period. Perhaps it's a Vista thing.

EDIT: Let me expand a little. When I select the DVD, a pop-up box comes up with a message that it's trying to scan the source DVD and may take a minute. After several minutes, then I get an error message that it can't scan the DVD because it's copy protected. I tried 2 different DVDs with the same results.
 
Rip it with DVDShrink first, select just the main movie, you don't need the rest of the fluff on the dvd. Select which audio track, select your compression and let it rip

Make a folder first on your desktop and set that as destination.

Then use handbrake to convert the files in that folder to the movie for you ipod/iphone.
 
Handbrake for PC is sort of ass. I have heard the Mac version is better. But simply put, Handbrake PC won't work with "Copy protected" DVDs, which makes it USELESS.

What you do is 2 step process.

1) use DVD DECRYPTER (or another decrypting program). This will make a local copy image of the DVD but strip the copy protection.

2) Use another program, such as aforementioned VIDEORA CONVERTER (or also try to search for IPODME Video Converter) to convert the LOCAL DVD IMAGE into an MP4 VIDEO FILE.
 
Rip it with DVDShrink first, select just the main movie, you don't need the rest of the fluff on the dvd. Select which audio track, select your compression and let it rip

Make a folder first on your desktop and set that as destination.

Then use handbrake to convert the files in that folder to the movie for you ipod/iphone.

Thanks. I'll try that.

Handbrake for PC is sort of ass. I have heard the Mac version is better. But simply put, Handbrake PC won't work with "Copy protected" DVDs, which makes it USELESS..

Yeah I figured that out last night. But I guess I can try what Jack Frost suggested. Seems like no matter how I go about it, it's going to be a two step process.

And this conversation leads me back to the conversation in the other thread on this forum which is about digital copies on DVDs. Frankly for the comptuer illiterate like myself, I welcome a premade digital copy.

EDIT TO ADD: I was just looking at the instructions for Handbrake and watching the little video. I can already see that for whatever reason, my version is not behaving the way it's listed in those instructions. I put the DVD in, then turned on Handbrake, and then I'm supposed to get a listing asking me where the DVD is. That does not happen with my version. Not sure why, and not sure if that's the source of my problem, but that's what's going on.

I just don't understand why Bloodwhiner is saying he's never had a problem but mine won't work "right out of the box" so to speak.

Don't misunderstand me, I'm not complaining about the advice, but this stuff just drives me crazy. It works for one person but not for me. Obviously I must have done something wrong in the install or something.
 
Last edited:
I encountered the same problem with Handbrake on my computer (Windows Vista). After doing a little research I discovered that the latest (Windows) version of Handbrake does NOT actually support (commercial) DVD decryption. Mac and Linux users, however, have a workaround that enables them to continue using Handbrake to rip DVDs.

I found a program, however, that seems to work fine in decrypting DVDs called DVD decrypter (suggested on the Handbrake Forum). You can download and use it for free at http://fileforum.betanews.com/detail/DVD_Decrypter/1011845169/1

I just downloaded it and tried it out and it seems to work fine (and fast!). Once you decrypt the files you can convert them using Handbrake.

I agree that it seems like a lot of work but until Digital Copies become a standard part of home video releases or until whatever desired title becomes available on iTunes, doing it ourselves for some titles may be the only option available unfortunately.
 
Just to follow up. I converted an episode of Transformers from DVD using DVD Decrypt in tandem with Handbrake and I must say that the results are IMPRESSIVE. Both the video and audio quality are superb, particularly when being viewed on my iPhone (which of course it's designed for)! Aside from the slight disappointment of not being able to rip my DVDs using Handbrake I am VERY impressed with it and I think that I've met my long term partner when it comes to video conversion software. Thanks Bloodwhiner!!!!! :techman:

BTW it's simply amazing how at least some of the best things in life are FREE!! The near $30 software I previously downloaded (DVD2iPod) SUCKED compared to Handbrake!!!!
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top