Finally — Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 1

[Michael]

The Rules

• Each episode starts on 10 points.
• 1 Vote every calander day per member.
• On each vote you must both:
• Heal your favorite story + 1
• & Hurt your least favorite stoy -2
• (You cannot hurt without healing or vice versa)
• Once an episode reaches zero it's out
• Episodes are ranked in order of elimination
• Please indicate which episoes you have voted for

Season One

Emissary 10
Past Prologue 10
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 10
Q-Less 10
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 10
The Nagus 10
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 10
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 10
In the Hands of the Prophets 10

 

[Defcon]

Emissary 10
Past Prologue 10
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 10
Q-Less 10
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 8 -
The Nagus 11 +
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 10
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 10
In the Hands of the Prophets 10

 

[Michael]

Emissary 10
Past Prologue 10
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 10
Q-Less 10
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 8
The Nagus 9 - (Sorry, Defcon )
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 10
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 11 +
In the Hands of the Prophets 10

 

[ZERO_of_ZERO]

Emissary 11 +
Past Prologue 8 -
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 10
Q-Less 10
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 8
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 10
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 11
In the Hands of the Prophets 10

 

[Bosch571]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 8
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 10
Q-Less 10
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 6 -
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 10
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 12 +
In the Hands of the Prophets 10

 

[Orac]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 8
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11 +
Q-Less 8 -
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 6
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 10
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 12
In the Hands of the Prophets 10

 

[Geck]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 8
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 10
Q-Less 10
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 6 -
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8 -
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 12
In the Hands of the Prophets 11 +

 

[boognish]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9 +
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 10
Move Along Home 4 -
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 12
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[AdmiralGarak]

Re: Finally — Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 1

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 8 -
Move Along Home 4
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 13 +
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[PKTrekGirl]

Re: Finally — Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 1

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 8
Move Along Home 2 -
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 10
If Wishes Were Horses 10
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 14 +
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[naf9sd]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 8
Move Along Home 2
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11 +
If Wishes Were Horses 8 -
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 14
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[Garth Rockett]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 6 -
Move Along Home 3 +
The Nagus 9
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 14
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[ZMistress]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 3
The Nagus 7 -
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 10
Duet 15 +
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[D'deridex]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 11
Q-Less 8
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 3
The Nagus 5 -
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 11 +
Duet 15
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[AdmiralGarak]

Re: Finally — Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 1

The Passenger 6 -
Move Along Home 3 +

I'm glad to see that I'm not the only one who thinks that Move Along Home doesn't deserve to get bumped off so quickly.

 

[Orac]

Re: Finally — Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 1

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 12 +
Q-Less 6 -
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 3
The Nagus 5
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 11
Duet 15
In the Hands of the Prophets 11

 

[erastus25]

DP is by far the worst episode of the season. And that's saying a lot considering what season we're talking about.

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 12
Q-Less 6
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 3
The Nagus 5
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 9 -
Duet 15
In the Hands of the Prophets 12 +

 

[KeepOnTrekking]

Re: Finally — Hurt/Heal Game: Best DS9 Episode: Season 1

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 12
Q-Less 6
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 3
The Nagus 3-
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 9
Duet 16+
In the Hands of the Prophets 12

 

[Defcon]

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 12
Q-Less 6
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 1 -
The Nagus 4 +
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 9
Duet 16
In the Hands of the Prophets 12

 

[Michael]

DP is by far the worst episode of the season. And that's saying a lot considering what season we're talking about.

No way.

Emissary 11
Past Prologue 9
A Man Alone 10
Babel 10
Captive Pursuit 12
Q-Less 6
Dax 10
The Passenger 6
Move Along Home 2 +
The Nagus 2 -
Vortex 10
Battle Lines 10
The Storyteller 8
Progress 11
If Wishes Were Horses 8
The Forsaken 10
Dramatis Personae 9
Duet 16
In the Hands of the Prophets 12