Here we go with round three. You get 10 picks this time. Just a note. Originally it was planned to go into the big run off poll in GTD with 20 episodes from each series. Because of other considerations, we will actually be going into that poll with 10 from each series instead. So pick your favorite 10. After we get the 10, we’ll have another poll or two just for fun taking the 10 to 5 and then to 1. Or maybe from 10 to 5 to 3 to 1. Let me know your thoughts on that. In TNG we did the 10 to 5 to 3 to 1 thing.
My picks. Arena Balance of Terror Mirror, Mirror Shore Leave The Cage The City on the Edge of Forever The Devil in the Dark The Doomsday Machine The Enterprise Incident Where No Man Has Gone Before
In no particular order: Balance of Terror Journey to Babel Mirror, Mirror The Cage The Corbomite Maneuver The Doomsday Machine The Enterprise Incident The Tholian Web The Trouble With Tribbles The Ultimate Computer
Now it does get a bit more difficult! My picks: Amok Time Arena Balance of Terror Journey to Babel Space Seed The Corbomite Maneuver The Devil In The Dark The Doomsday Machine The Enterprise Incident The Tholian Web. GM
Still don't need the full count: Arena Balance of Terror Shore Leave Space Seed The Cage The Corbomite Maneuver The Doomsday Machine The Enterprise Incident The Galileo Seven
Amok Time, Arena, Balance of Terror, Errand of Mercy, Journey to Babel, The Cage, The City on the Edge of Forever, The Corbomite Maneuver, The Doomsday Machine and Where No Man Has Gone Before. And I'd like to see the 10 to 5 to 3 to 1 format.
WOW!!! Both pilots are still alive...Good, I'm still voting for them Pilots (two episodes) The Cage Where No Man Has Gone Before Season One (five episodes) Balance of Terror Errand of Mercy The Corbomite Maneuver The Devil in the Dark The Galieo Seven Season Two (two episodes) Mirror, Mirror The Doomsday Machine Season Three (one episode) The Enterprise Incident
Balance of Terror Errand of Mercy Mirror, Mirror Space Seed The Cage The City on the Edge of Forever The Devil in the Dark The Doomsday Machine The Trouble With Tribbles Where No Man Has Gone Before BRG PS- I also favour the 10 - 5 - 3 - 1 voting format as used in the TNG poll. :thumbsup:
Some of my favorites have already been knocked out...but of the those remaining: Amok Time Journey to Babel The Enterprise Incident The Naked Time The Tholian Web Where No Man Has Gone Before The Devil in the Dark The City on the Edge of Forever The Doomsday Machine (my favorite) Balance of Terror
My 10 Picks ----------- Amok Time Arena Balance of Terror Journey to Babel The Corbomite Maneuver - Best Star Trek episode (imo) The Doomsday Machine The Naked Time The Tholian Web The Ultimate Computer Where No Man Has Gone Before
While Balance of Terror is still my unquestioned winner, I voted for: Amok Time, Arena, Balance of Terror, Errand of Mercy, Journey to Babel, Mirror Mirror, Space Seed, The Doomsday Machine, The Trouble With Tribbles, and Where No Man Has Gone Before.
For the life of me I do not recall "The Doomsday Machine" ever being a top fan favorite until it got a lot of PR with the re-mastered version (which I did not see, but understand that it disappointed a lot of people.) As far as I can recall, for years almost everyone agreed that COTEOD was THE fan favorite, with "Balance of Terror" and "The Naked Time" often cited as well. I guess the times, they are a changin...
BOT has ALWAYS been #1 with me. COTEOF was close AS was TDM. I'm realy surprised The Immunity Syndrome didn't make the cut and that The Baked Time is going down for the count as well.
^ I could do a lot with that line, but I'm not gonna. In any case, this poll closes in a few hours. Get your votes in now.
OK, this poll is over with as of this post. The final tab is below. since there is a tie for last place, we'll have to have a round to finalize 10th place. I'll get that up tonight. We can only take 10 episodes into the contest in GTD. edit to say: this can be unpinned now. Thanks. Balance of Terror 33 The Doomsday Machine 28 Amok Time 23 Journey to Babel 22 The City on the Edge of Forever 22 Where No Man Has Gone Before 21 The Devil in the Dark 19 Mirror, Mirror 18 The Cage 17 The Corbomite Maneuver 17 The Enterprise Incident 17 Arena 15 Space Seed 15 The Trouble with Tribbles 15 The Tholian Web 13 Errand of Mercy 11 The Naked Time 11 The Ultimate Computer 10 Shore Leave 9 The Galieo Seven 8