Enage AUTO-Pilot

[RobertScorpio]

How would you rank the pilots of each of the star trek shows (Including both TOS pilots THE CAGE and WHERE NO MAN HAS GONE BEFORE)

Here is how I rank them...

First place
DEEP SPACE NINE's pilot

Second place
Voyager's Pilot

Third Place
TOS--Where No Man Has Gone Before

Forth Place
TOS--The

Fifth Place
Broken Vow

Sixth Place
TNG's Encounter at snooze-point

How do you rank them?

 

[USS Triumphant]

Pilots in the series:

1. Hikaru Sulu
2. Tom Paris
3. Wesley Crusher
4. Ensign Nog
5. Travis Mayweather
6. Jadzia Dax
7. Tie - Demora Sulu and Lt. Hawk

Pilots for the series:

1. Encounter at Farpoint (TNG)
2. The Emissary (DS9)
3. Where No Man Has Gone Before (TOS)
4. In Harm's Way (ST:P2)
5. Broken Bow (ENT)
6. The Cage (TOS)
7. The Caretaker (VOY)

 

[Islander]

Pilots in the series:
4. In Harm's Way (ST:P2)

How the hell can you rate something that never aired? You gave it a levelled rating to state how everything below sucked?

Anyway, here's my pick

1. The Emissary (DS9) - Very nice setup of what was comming
2. Broken Bow (ENT) - Could have been first stand-alone but the season just went downhill too quickly
3. Where no man has gone before (TOS) - A classic
4. The Caretaker (VOY) - Too much expectations maybe
5. Encounter at farpoint (TNG) - Trying too much mix-matched things, TNG really started in Season 2
6. The cage (Universal pilot) - Overall the only true "pilot" which is intended to sell an idea, but... you know

 

[USS Triumphant]

How the hell can you rate something that never aired? You gave it a levelled rating to state how everything below sucked?

"Aired." How quaint. Welcome to the Information Age, my friend.

I put it on the list because it is the pilot of a Star Trek series, and I've seen it. Simple as that. Medium is irrelevant.

 

[Candlelight]

I put it on the list because it is the pilot of a Star Trek series, and I've seen it. Simple as that. Medium is irrelevant.

Do tell.

 

[Candlelight]

Seen:

The Caretaker (VOY)
The Emissary (DS9)
Where No Man Has Gone Before (TOS)
Encounter at Farpoint (TNG)
The Cage (TOS)
Broken Bow (ENT)

Not seen:

In Harm's Way (ST:P2)
Beyond the Farthest Star (TAS)

 

[Maurice]

Except "In Harm's Way" wasn't their pilot...it only looks like it because they yanked the "Come What May" ick-fest.

 

[RobertScorpio]

I put it on the list because it is the pilot of a Star Trek series, and I've seen it. Simple as that. Medium is irrelevant.

Do tell.

Is this the long-lost STAR TREK episode we have been hearing about for decades??

Rob