• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

E-book reader opinions (pilots especially)

Lindley

Moderator with a Soul
Premium Member
I've resisted the whole e-book phenomenon so far because I like having paper in my hands when I'm reading. And by extension, that means I don't know much about any of the e-book readers out there.

Well, I've found a good motivation to investigate them at last: Approach Plates. The papers describing instrument approaches into airports nationwide come in a 1-inch sheaf, and are only valid for a *very* short time (about 3 months). Then you have to re-buy the entire package, even if only a few (or none) of the approaches have changed in that time. They aren't expensive, but it is a pain, especially if you're flying a long distance and you need the plates for multiple regions onboard.

Each re-buy is only about $4, so it's not a huge deal, especially for those of us who only fly occasionally. For those who fly a lot more, Jeppeson provides a subscription service which only updates specific plates that have changed, but it's far more expensive.

Enter e-book readers. Several sources have started making approach plates available for e-book readers. This would allow you to store all of the approach and departure procedures for the entire nation on a single piece of hardware. Downside: some of them have smaller screens than the normal approach plate paper size.

The sites I've found so far are:

www.pdfplates.com, which offers plates for free (!), but I figure there must be some catch. Sure enough, they're having compatibility problems with some readers, but partially support a wide variety.

www.readerplates.com, which offers a subscription service for $10/month (not bad), but only promises to support Sony's reader and the Kindle DX.

www.eflybook.com, which is not actually an ebook reader, but essentially the same concept. The hardware is much more expensive, as is the subscription plan, but it includes more information (sectionals and en-route charts in addition to the approaches, and probably more).

So I'd like any opinions of the various readers out there, so that I can make an informed decision about whether any of these services are right for me. And who knows, I may end up reading some actual books on the thing too.....
 
I have an iLiad, which is made by iRex. It's pretty good. I can read pdf files, and it also supports mobi files and I think html as well. It's more expensive than a Kindle, but I bought it used. My favorite feature is that it comes with a stylus that can annotate the books. (Underline, margin notes, etc.) I really like that feature because I got the iLiad to use as a replacement for textbooks.
 
Go to your local SonyStyle shop and have a look at the PRS-900 & the PRS-600. Both are very good readers. The 900 is really nice. It's what I would get if I was getting a new reader and had the money.
 
I have a Nook and so far really like it. The system is more open than the Kindle, and with a few 'edits' to the SD memory card inside that everything runs off of you can pretty much do anything you want with it. It is sturdy and has a bit of heft to it, that I like, and the interface is the best of all the ones I tried.

Also has the largest library, which is one of the key selling points.
 
I worked at a company once, where we had to convert books to e-books, so people could read them on an e-book reader. The job was alright, but I'm not a fan of those e-book readers. It still takes a few seoconds to flip a page on an e-book reader and there is usually something not quite right with the lighting, especially whilst turning the page. It gets very bright for a few seconds before it gets back to normal. I will probably stick to the old fashioned paper books.
 
I worked at a company once, where we had to convert books to e-books, so people could read them on an e-book reader. The job was alright, but I'm not a fan of those e-book readers. It still takes a few seoconds to flip a page on an e-book reader and there is usually something not quite right with the lighting, especially whilst turning the page. It gets very bright for a few seconds before it gets back to normal. I will probably stick to the old fashioned paper books.

A few seconds? Hardly.

I have a Kindle DX and can't say that I'm going to miss 'real' books.
 
Indeed, the page-flipping on both the Kindle and Nook (which use the exact same screen as far as I recall) is about half a second now, quicker than actually turning a page most of the time.
 
I was given the original Sony reader (PRS 500) as a gift a few years ago. The geek and "greenie" in me liked the concept, but I'd always liked paper, as well. However, I got used to the ebook very quickly and really came to appreciate the portability, especially for plane trips (as a passenger not a pilot) and on vacations: it's great to be able to take 80 different things (if you choose), including books, Trek FanFic, audio books, MP3 files, etc., all on one slim device.

I recently upgraded to the new Sony PRS 600, which is touch screen and can be used in either landscape or portrait orientation, and I love it. The 600 also has offers a note function that allows you to type notes inline with a touch screen keyboard or hand write them anywhere on a page using the included stylus.

I can highly recommend this reader, from personal experience, though confess that I have not used the Nook or iLiad. I have used the Kindle and, personally, didn't like the size or all the buttons/keys, though the over-the-air upload function is nice. Still, the Sony interface works essentially just like iTunes, and I find it intuitive and simple.

One final thought/question to the OP: do your Approach Plates include maps or diagrams? I ask because, to my eye, graphics are one failing of the e-readers that use "e-ink" technology (including the Sony, Nook and Kindle).

Also, while I find them a bit small for reading text of any length, you might also consider a PDA and/or smart phone, as most of these also offer e-reading capability. Just trying to make sure you have all the options available to you. ;)

Good luck! :techman:
 
One final thought/question to the OP: do your Approach Plates include maps or diagrams? I ask because, to my eye, graphics are one failing of the e-readers that use "e-ink" technology (including the Sony, Nook and Kindle).

Here's what an approach plate looks like:
http://204.108.4.16/d-tpp/1001/05100ILD12.PDF

On paper, they're somewhere between the size of a MMPB and a TPB.

Also, while I find them a bit small for reading text of any length, you might also consider a PDA and/or smart phone, as most of these also offer e-reading capability. Just trying to make sure you have all the options available to you. ;)

Good luck! :techman:
One of the concerns is battery life. You don't want any chance of the thing dying on you when you need it. The longer life offered with the e-ink thing rather than a typical screen is interesting, at the least.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, the page-flipping on both the Kindle and Nook (which use the exact same screen as far as I recall) is about half a second now, quicker than actually turning a page most of the time.

Well, that's good to hear. The e-book readers have improved then. But around summer last year it took the device definitely a few seconds before the next page showed up in the display. Though I doubt e-book readers will be the right thing for me to have, I'm glad to see that so many people are pleased with them. Saves the forests ;).
 
I actually just bought a Sony pocket edition yesterday. It's a 5" screen that will literally sit in my back pocket, holds around 350 books, and is only $200. I'm loving it so far.
 
One final thought/question to the OP: do your Approach Plates include maps or diagrams? I ask because, to my eye, graphics are one failing of the e-readers that use "e-ink" technology (including the Sony, Nook and Kindle).

Here's what an approach plate looks like:
http://204.108.4.16/d-tpp/1001/05100ILD12.PDF

On paper, they're somewhere between the size of a MMPB and a TPB.

Also, while I find them a bit small for reading text of any length, you might also consider a PDA and/or smart phone, as most of these also offer e-reading capability. Just trying to make sure you have all the options available to you. ;)

Good luck! :techman:
One of the concerns is battery life. You don't want any chance of the thing dying on you when you need it. The longer life offered with the e-ink thing rather than a typical screen is interesting, at the least.

You can get external battery powered chargers just in case.

I'll put the PDF on my 505 and show you how it looks.
 
Thanks, that'd be helpful. Maybe put something in the picture for scale, too.
 
I've been working on reformatting US approach plates for E Book readers(as well as PDF) And honestly, the 6" screen is a bit small. Here's a photo set of the older PRS-505: http://www.sdwphotography.com/gallery/v/flying/chartblob/

Sorry there's not really a good size reference in those. I have a nook and when I get time I'm going to try and do a video to show the speed and size of the display, maybe this weekend.

If you're looking for the actual files, EPUB or PDF format, they're at my other website at http://www.chartbundle.com

Personally, I'm thinking of getting something with an 8" or 9" screen to try out instead. The Sony Daily Edition(PRS-900) has a larger screen, but because it's mostly taller I don't think it will work that much better, so I'm on the hunt for some of the devices announced at CES but not shipping yet.
 
Interesting, thanks for the pictures. Screen size is a big concern for me as well.
 
Yes, I've been leaning towards the Kindle DX for a while now. Be nice to see it in person before buying, though.....
 
And as a follow-up to my previous post, I now have video of both the Nook and the Sony PRS-505 on YouTube, just search for chartbundle.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top