• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Does Trek EU has the same problem as SW EU...

I've skimmed a few things set thousands of year in Star Wars past but the tech always (beyond a few superficial changes) seems the same as the 'modern' day???
Yep, isn't trek techs the same besides minor changes?

I can't say I've seen much to suggest it's getting any less silly with the Empire and Republic merging and splitting and whatever else again
I actually like the Vong books, were you only complaining about LOTF and FOTJ or the Legacy comics too?
 
Last edited:
I've skimmed a few things set thousands of year in Star Wars past but the tech always (beyond a few superficial changes) seems the same as the 'modern' day???

Technological progress isn't a constant. In real history there have been long periods of stability and slow progress punctuated by bursts of rapid advancement; we just happen to be in one of the latter, so we expect it to be the norm.

I just assume the Galaxy Far, Far Away reached a plateau level of technology thousands of years BBY. If they were already as advanced as they could feasibly get, there wouldn't be much change from then on, except socially. Or there could've been a Dark Age, a period where they lost technology for a time, followed by a recovery to their earlier level.
 
I actually like the Vong books, were you only complaining about LTF and FOTJ or the Legacy comics too?

That's your privilege to enjoy them. I'm typically not going to buy a comic book, SW, Trek or otherwise these days. For whatever reason they just don't set the atmosphere for me that well anymore.

I got four or five novels into the Vong books before I gave up on them. I just wasn't enjoying them or the concept. My subsequent "checking up" on the timeline to see if it had improved just involved a very occasional skimming of Wookiepedia. I've moved on from the SW EU, plenty of other scifi/fantasy material out there.
 
I've skimmed a few things set thousands of year in Star Wars past but the tech always (beyond a few superficial changes) seems the same as the 'modern' day???
I dunno, the Star Wars EU lost me as a fan when they started the Yuuzhan Vong nonsense. Checking on the timeline now and again, I can't say I've seen much to suggest it's getting any less silly with the Empire and Republic merging and splitting and whatever else again.

Hopefully the Trek EU will stay coherent and not introduce a universe changing plot element of silliness.

Thankfully Trek is mainly much more concise time-period wise. There have been a few ventures into far past / futures but no ongoing series thousands of years in the past.

That's not to say there couldn't be...
 
I've skimmed a few things set thousands of year in Star Wars past but the tech always (beyond a few superficial changes) seems the same as the 'modern' day???
The tech tends to play such a small role in the SW stories, that it honestly never bothered me.
 
The bigger mystery is why technology in the Trek novels hasn't plateaued, what with all those hundreds of UFP member cultures having finished bringing their own unique knowledge into the mix decades ago. Instead of "synergy", the true state of such multicultural RD effort after the initial mixing might be one of "chaos", reducing the speed not only to the level of a single culture, but actually below that.

The Borg are a mixture of sources, too, but they seem to be stable enough...

Timo Saloniemi
 
^Really? I don't remember anything in any of the shows or books that showed that was something they were capable of or even interested in.
 
Wasn't there a bioship in one of the Leah Brahms episode or even in Tin Man?, Also considering that the Federation is like the UN why wouldn't be a special training academy in San Fransisco where species with an affinity toward bioships would be able to specialise.
 
Not quite a bioship, but the old Star Trek Spaceflight Chronology postulated future Federation starships which used "variable magnetic matrix sheathing" instead of a traditional metallic alloy hull to reconfigure the shape of the vessel as per mission requirements.

Basically, ships that change shape.
 
Wasn't there a bioship in one of the Leah Brahms episode or even in Tin Man?, Also considering that the Federation is like the UN why wouldn't be a special training academy in San Fransisco where species with an affinity toward bioships would be able to specialise.
Would ships that use bio-neural gel packs be considered bioships?
 
If we look at let's say the list of US presidents wery few of them come from Washington or New York compared to these leaders.

To be entirely fair, about 10% of US presidents came from New York; almost a sixth of them if you use home state instead of birth state. And for some reason, over a third of US presidents were born in either Ohio or Virginia. :p
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top