• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Documentary Station - Reviews, Recommendations, etc

Hugo Rune

Vice Admiral
Admiral
I've become somewhat obsessed with Documentaries of recent. A large proportion of my downtime (travel to-from work, time without my partner) are now dedicated to tracking down, watching and, almost more important to me, reading around the documentaries and their subject matter.

So, I'd love to hear some good recommendations of Docs you've seen recently. It doesn't matter what the subject matter is, I've been exposing myself to as many different styles and content-types and thus far have found surprisingly fascinating or emotionally satisfying material in the most obscure of places.

This weekend I have watched the following:

Nanking - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0893356/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1 - Both an horrific story about 200,000 Chinese men, women and children killed by Japanese soldiers in 1939, and the 250,000 people saved by a group of American/European missionaries that attempted to create a safe zone for the city's residents. This was a fascinating piece of history told in a more innovative way than typically seen on documentaries, where the deceased parties were played by actors, reading from notes/letters left behind by them, adding performance into the mix. Still, the most emotional parts are those survivors recounting their survival of the genocide, plus some rather surprising interviews with surviving Japanese soldiers also.

The Internet's Own Boy - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3268458/?ref_=nv_sr_1 - I'll happily admit to having never heard of Aaron Swartz prior to watching the Doc, but even through simple news clips and poorly shot phone recordings of his talks, I became quickly wrapped up in his passion and intelligence. Anyone interested in Freedom of Speech on the internet, the access to public domain materials, or simply finding and pursuing a passion, should give this a watch.

Last Days in Vietnam - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3279124/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1 - One of the reasons I am pushing myself to watch as many different types of doc with as many different topics as possible is my general ignorance of history outside of Europe. My knowledge about Vietnam is almost completely limited to Hollywood films, so the Paris Peace Accords, the evacuation of South Vietnam and the further invasion by the North, were completely new pieces of information for me. The Doc interviews those who escaped, those who didn't and those who used every resource to hand (typically without authority) to evacuate 170,000 Vietnamese saving them from the incoming North. I found this to be a politically fascinating piece, coupled with a real emotional punch. This doc has pushed me to do some significant reading around the whole war, which frankly, to this Englishman, has always sat in the back of my mind mostly as "that war the Americans regret a lot".

Edit - forgot one:

The King of Kong - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0923752/?ref_=nv_sr_1 - Both very funny and fascinating David vs Goliath tale of the (oddly) close-knit and almost reductive group of hard core 1980's arcade gamers. One utterly unknown man tries to break into the group and challenge its apocryphal leader to a head to head for the crown of Donkey Kong champion. The doc never mocks or attempts to undermine the clique that has developed around these games (All white northern Americans, which is interesting), rather simply lets their personalities come through, whilst the underdog simply plucks away at attempting to achieve something for himself. Weird, uplifting and interesting look at video arcade aficionados that challenges what is "authenticity" and the pressure of being "number 1".

Hugo - Next up: Hoop Dreams. Looking forward to it.
 
Last edited:
Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father
I'd avoid all spoilers about this documentary. But the basics are that a man was murdered by his ex-girlfriend. The filmmaker was the childhood friend of the man and went around the world interviewing the man's friends and family before the memories fade. The documentary then takes a turn when it's discovered that the ex-girlfriend is pregnant with the man's child, so the filmmaker decides to make it a letter to the child so he'll know who his family is. There are some more turns over the course of the documentary. It's one of the more emotionally moving documentaries you'll ever see and becomes both heartbreaking and inspiration as the focus becomes the man's parents.
 
Dear Zachary is already on the list. Trepidatiously looking forward to it.

I loaded up Catfish last night as 90 mins as more feasible than the 180 of Hoop Dreams.

A very strange tale about the pitfalls of Internet ID, persona and dating. A part of me didn't completely buy into the "quest for the truth" of the "lead" male and there was something oddly disingenuous about it, but the narrative did draw me in and the reveal of the "leading lady" and her life felt infinitely more emotional and real than the betrayal.

The fact that many people, including multiple documentarians, believe that some, if not all, of it was fabricated adds to the piece. Is it just judicious/creative editing, are their re-enacted pieces being passed off for "real time", is it all a hoax? No idea, but it still has a fascinating story at its core, regardless of how I feel about its makers or the central "lead"

Hugo - will get to Hoop Dreams soon
 
I recently watched "Atari: Game Over", and really enjoyed it. It was about the rise and fall of Atari, with the excavation of ET game cartridges buried in Alamogordo as the hook.
 
Tapped: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1344784/

Examines the role of the bottled water industry and its effects on our health, climate change, pollution, and our reliance on oil.

I found this doc fascinating and a little scary. It really made me think about the wisdom of allowing the private ownership of water.
 
TAPPED sounds right up my alley. Going to have to find someone in the UK distributing it.

Hoop Dreams was beautiful. I started watching it at 11pm last night with the intention of just watching the first hour, but by 2am I was still up, on the interests reading around the pair of players it followed. A remarkably insightful and subdued doc that does what any great doc should do... let the events play and leave the audience to make up its own mind. So many social and political issues are thrown up, without letting them drown out what is,in the end, the story of two kids, one dream and a v e th broken road to reach it. Impressive film making from a pair of directors who initially just wanted to make a 30 min P.B.S. doc about park basketball. Magic and worthy of anyone's time, basketball lover or no.

I am now currently 40 minutes into Cartel Land about the two sets of citizens, on either side of the USA/Mexico border, who attempt to take the "war" to the Cartels. Interesting stuff, but at the 40min Mark, oh-is my-word does it take a dark turn. I can see the tension ratcheting quicker than the superb drama Scicario did in 2015...

Hugo - just wants to go down state
 
The Death of "Superman Lives": What Happened? Directed by John Schnepp. A look at the Superman movie starring Nicholas Cage that almost got inflicted on us poor suckers. Includes interviews with Kevin Smith, Tim Burton and others.
 
I recently watched "Atari: Game Over", and really enjoyed it. It was about the rise and fall of Atari, with the excavation of ET game cartridges buried in Alamogordo as the hook.
With all the "heavy" documentaries I have been exploring, it was lovely to watch a more hopeful and amusing piece, like this. Though there is a dark lining to the piece, namely that the designer of the game had a sense of responsibility to the ending of Atari, and the industry as a whole, it was very cathartic to see him there at the end, at the dig site, surrounded by his fans. Couple that with the uber-fan (and waste disposal expert) who had spent much of his adult life examining evidence and petitioning local government to allow him to try to excavate the "buried ET treasure" site, it was a nice balance of history and humanism. That poor designer tried to perform the impossible, and apparently actually succeeded, but his game was launched at a time when Atari was already crumbling. The fact that his game was so demonised and mythologised must have been incredibly tough on a man who then spent 20-30 years trying to right himself.

Lovely documentary about something I know NOTHING about, having never played a video game outside of the occasional dabble in GOLDENEYE at university 18 years ago.

This was made by Zak Penn, who frankly, outside of the passable TV show Alphas has been at the forefront of poor mainstream SF/F film screenwriting (X-Men Last Stand, Elektra, The Incredible Hulk, Inspector Gadget). I was a touch wary to begin with, but his passion for the piece came through and, more importantly like some first time doc-creators, he didn't let the journey be about him and his fan-journey, rather the redemptive and story of the cursed creator.

Up next are:

The Green Prince - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2304915/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1 - The son of a West Bank Hamas leader joins the Israeli intelligence service

and

Jodorowski's Dune - http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1935156/?ref_=nv_sr_1 - One crazy man's vision of another crazy man's vision

Hugo - OK, maybe a bit of Mario Kart too..
 
TAPPED sounds right up my alley. Going to have to find someone in the UK distributing it.

Tapped is on iTunes and Netflix. I don't know if either one is an option for you. http://www.tappedthemovie.com/

If that is your speed, you might also check out Bag It.

An average guy makes a resolution to stop using plastic bags at the grocery store. Little does he know that this simple decision will change his life completely.

This link has country viewing search on it: http://www.bagitmovie.com/
 
All of the ones I'm referring to are available on Netflix (Canadian version at least).

Living On One Dollar: Four friends go to Guatemala, where they attempt to live on a dollar a day for two months. Quite inspiring to see how the people there manage with what so little they have.

Happy: A look at what makes people happy all around the world. Some of this ties into the first one.

180° South: A band of surfers/mountain climbers go on a journey to Patagonia. On the way, they stop at Easter Island. Beautiful scenery.
 
Tapped is sadly not currently available in the UK that I can find, but I will keep it in the back of my mind given the streaming services I watch do update regularly.

I'll have a look for Bag It as I like the low-key idea of it.

Living on One Dollar and Happy are on UK Netflix and already in the queue, but thank you. 180 I will start looking for.

So The Green Prince. Anyone interested in the Palastinian/Israeli conflict should give this a gander. Due to an ex girlfriend who was a lapsed Jewish girl who became a devout Zionist, I had watched and read quite a bit about the area and the conflict, but the story here had completely eluded me. One man, an intelligence handler for the Shin Bet (Israeli version of CIA and then some) manages to convince the son of a prominent West Bank Hamas leader to supply them with intelligence on Hamas and its activities. The story plays out as a two header, being told from the side of the Handler and from the Subject, the remarkable feat they pulled off and the amazing relationship they built up. It focuses less on the politics of the region, the scope of the conflict, and rather focusses on how their relationship developed amidst the insanity. It certainly glosses over the shadier aspects of the Shin Bet and only bulletpoints the tactics of Hamas, but that's not the point of it all. It runs like a mini thriller with a young man running around his father, somehow also protecting him whilst undermining out Hamas, which is wholly antithetical to his own moral code. It's also a beautiful story of friendship which really moved me. Highly recommended. Find it.

Meanwhile, I forgot about Cartel Land. Anyone who saw Sicario last year and enjoyed the push and pull of the Cartels on Mexico/USA should give this serious consideration. Two men, on both sides of the border, create their own militias (they prefer to call themselves Vigilantes) to deal with the ever present threat of the Mexican drug cartels. The American creates a miniature paramilitary organisation to deter and disrupt the creation and distribution of Crystal Meth in his part of the US. The Mexican creates an ad-hoc force of farmers, mechanics and medical staff, armed to the teeth and begins sweeping out the Cartels from the towns in his province. I will say no more given I was horrified (and, yet, sadly predictably saddened) how one of these men push their activities too far and the tendrils of corruption start to drag him down. Utterly fascinating and shocking piece of work by a single documentarian with a camera. Anyone interested in the "war on drugs" should give this 100 minutes. Find it also

Hugo - rather enjoying his 2.5 hour a day commute these days
 
All of the ones I'm referring to are available on Netflix (Canadian version at least).

Living On One Dollar: Four friends go to Guatemala, where they attempt to live on a dollar a day for two months. Quite inspiring to see how the people there manage with what so little they have.
There is a very potent idea here in this documentary, yet it barely scratched the surface of its bigger themes (community, resilience, government control, disease). It's 58 minute running time didn't help, but frankly neither did its American subjects. Given what the duo (and their mini film crew) wanted to experience and achieve, I found their approach to be rather distasteful and fractured. The entire thing appears to have been a "drunken discussion" that they some how followed through on. But with no research, no obvious preparedness or scientific basis (it appears that the duo went with some form of thesis in mind) I found I could not link in with their journey or what they were wanting to actually achieve. Case in point. They have limited funds that will be dolled out randomly to try to achieve a more realistic experience of day to day life, yet have decided to not even crack a library book on how to farm or on what the drinking water will be like. If it were not for their obvious intelligence upbringing it would have felt like a frat boy declaration of "$1 a day, I'm a warrior, I can do that for 8 weeks".

There were some beautiful stories hidden in there - the bank that actually gives people a chance to better themselves; the cloth weaver who is studying to be a nurse; the "rich" man who puts his community before himself when it needs it. Amazingly resourceful people. But they were all too fleeting. One of the most interesting part was almost completely glossed over - the fact that the two sets of students (Economists and Film Makers) were clearly falling out over the fact that the Economists were not fully sharing the experience because of the Film Makers language barrier. Not every documentary needs tension or internal conflict, but it was an interesting germ of an idea never explored.

I'm going to chalk all of the above up to the fact that they were all 21, but the fact that this came across like a "merry jaunt" at times really frustrated me. There is a brilliant notion in this doc, but I don't think either (a) its creators had the experience or talent to convey it, or (b) they went in with a VERY limited viewpoint and missed the more salient experiences.

Interesting to watch though and thank you for the recommendation

Hugo - 20 Feet from Stardom next - the untold story of the backup singer...
 
Wow, I had a totally different experience watching that. I found it fresh, and the fact that they were going in without research meant that they would experience it as the natives would with road bumps, whereas going in prepared would have made them a bit too comfortable. I do agree though that it could have been longer to flesh out the themes and get more data out of it. Maybe it needed to be a miniseries.

I think we both agree that it's an interesting idea to explore, and I personally think it deserves to be expanded on, maybe with a sequel? I think this was likely done as a film project or as part of a thesis, so maybe while they didn't quite hit the mark in some places, I think they did reasonably well with the resources they had.
 
So next up was 20 Feet From Stardom

Wow. Oh my, what a beautiful piece of work. Following many generations of back-up/background singers from the music industry from the 60's right up til now, this is an electrifying doc about the joy, the pain, the determination and the horrors of the music industry.

I will admit that, more than the quality of an instrumentalist, even the arrangement of the music, it is the voice in front of it that, well, sings to me when I listen to an artist or a band. Yet, my knowledge, or frankly even my wherewithal about those amazing singers who perform background vocals on albums of, say, The Rolling Stones, Sting, Michael Jackson, was nil. So this was not only a fascinating piece of music history that had flown over my head, but it opened my ears to HOW I listen to music.

Some of the artists covered in this piece are, frankly, amazing But one, Lisa Fischer, has the ability to do so much with her voice, I was just boggled and in awe of her. And, unlike the rest of them, she was probably the only one who was comfortable being a background artist, and never pushed and pushed to try to get to the front.

The doc is mostly about those women who tried to get to the front and the walls they faced. It is also about the beauty of the voice as an instrument and how so many of the songs you love would be shells of their current greatness without these women. Amazing work. Find it on Netflix.

This morning I watched Slingshot about The Segway Guy. Or, more importantly, the single most driven engineer I have ever come across. Dean Kamen,

He lives alone. He flies a helicopter to work sometimes. In his spare time (what there is of it) he builds clocks. He has a wall of painting of his favourite scientists. He never seems to stop working and thinking about how his inventions could help more people. And he desperately wants to help build a time machine.

But right now, he wants to help bring potable water to everyone on the planet and drive out 50% of all disease in the world. So he started making a machine.

This is a lovely little doc, following a lovely BIG man. There is no doubt that the doc captures only his softer edges. A man this driven, this focussed, does not get done what he wants to get done by being a softly spoken wise-cracker all day long. Plus his ambition is so big, his hope so vast, that when he gives a direction, you can see the fear on his employees faces when they realise what is ahead of them. But, he is a leader, and his people follow because everything he does is aimed to make the world an easier place to live in, especially if you are ill, or are prone to illness because of your environment.

Just look at a few of his inventions - Drug Infusion Pumps; Portable Dialysis machines for home use; the all-terrain wheelchair; and the Vapour Compression Distiller - the main focus of the the doc.

But there is a real sense of aloneness to him. I am not sure his is lonely; his work, his passion gives him too much forward momentum for this. But, for all of his giving back to the world, to kids especially, he seems to do it all solo. When told he needed a business partner 20 years ago to get his company working properly, he went and bought a 6ft tall teddy, put a denim tie on it and sat it in the corner of his office. I'm not sure if the doc focusses solely on him and his work, because it is big enough to do that. Or if (outside of his parents) they struggled to find people to talk about him as a person, outside of his work.

Very interesting doc about a quirky and unique man and his passions. Again, on Netflix.

Hugo - People take the longest possible paths, digress to numerous dead ends, and make all kinds of mistakes. Then historians come along and write summaries of this messy, nonlinear process and make it appear like a simple, straight line.
 
I recently watched You've Been Trumped on Pivot. It's about Trump's plans to build golf courses in Scotland. It's pretty heavy handed, but very interesting.
 
All of the ones I'm referring to are available on Netflix (Canadian version at least).

180° South: A band of surfers/mountain climbers go on a journey to Patagonia. On the way, they stop at Easter Island. Beautiful scenery.
This was lovely. I have read quite a bit about Doug Tompkins and his wife's work in buying up and conserving land in Patagonia and Chile in general. So to find out that the doc was in part about this was an immediate boost. It's a nice travelogue, with beautiful scenery, and like the best of them, the questions raised and the answers posed come out of the unexpected, unplanned parts of the journey (e.g. the detour to Rapa Nui). A very nice detour from the more heady docs I've been subsuming myself in of recent.

Speaking of which: The Seven Five (Precinct 75). I'm a police officer, so anything crime related naturally draws me in (The Thin Blue Line / The Memphis 3 / How to Make a Murderer), but docs and real life pieces about how the police works, and more importantly fails to work, fascinate me. If you have seen, or heard of, Serpico, you can glean what this doc is about. What sets it apart is it follows the villain(s) of the piece and not the hero. One cop (and cohorts) perform in excess of 200 crimes (from extortion, drug distribution, kidnapping, burglary, all the way to the edge of murder) during the mid 80's to early 90's in the toughest neighbourhood in Brooklyn NY. Boggling. Overwrought in its production (the music is a huge problem) but some fascinating real life crime and a snapshot into the most corrupt era in US policing. Find it

Hugo - The word 'adventure' has just gotten overused. For me, adventure is when everything goes wrong. That's when the adventure starts
 
This was lovely. I have read quite a bit about Doug Tompkins and his wife's work in buying up and conserving land in Patagonia and Chile in general. So to find out that the doc was in part about this was an immediate boost. It's a nice travelogue, with beautiful scenery, and like the best of them, the questions raised and the answers posed come out of the unexpected, unplanned parts of the journey (e.g. the detour to Rapa Nui). A very nice detour from the more heady docs I've been subsuming myself in of recent.


Glad you enjoyed it! Unlike you, I didn't know anything about anyone in it, but I do actually have Patagonia clothing, which I thought was rather neat, and so I felt a connection to the story. This may be one of my favourite documentaries, and the message at the end saddened me, in that they've even had to do oppose the government. I know it's been awhile since it came out, and I hope the situation has improved since its release. Would be nice for an update on that.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top