• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Disabled Trek...

2 of 10

Captain
Captain
Medical science must really be something in the 24th century. In Trek you really don't see many disabled people. You have Geordi being blind and needing the Visors, and you have Barclay with a stammer, besides them I can't think of any other character with some sort of disability. Were there any others??
 
There's Melora, which was one of the worst episodes of Trek ever, featuring one of the most annoying characters ever.

They were originally gonna have Melora be a regular main cast member of DS9. Great thing they only wasted one episode on her instead of the whole series, otherwise DS9 would have instantly went from the best Trek series to the very worst.

I have no problem with disabled persons, it's just that Melora was inherently annoying person. Not because she was disabled. It would have been fine to feature some non-annoying disabled persons; but if they were only gonna make them annoying like Melora was, it's much better that they didn't have any. It would have painted disabled persons in a very unfair, negative light and made the show unwatchable.
 
Travis Mayweather lacked the power of speech.









Oh, dear, that was mean.



Miranda whatshername in "Is There in Truth No Beauty?" was blind.
Sarek had a heart condition (Journey to Babel)
 
^LOL! :guffaw: Poor Travis.

Nog had a false leg in DS9. Picard has a synthetic heart. Dukat was blinded briefly by the Pah-Wraiths. Emory Erickson in Enterprise's "Daedalus" is in a wheelchair.

I can't really think of any more, but Starfleet is definitely an Equal Opportunities Employer.
 
The characters we see in Star Trek aren't a random sample of their society. Almost all of them are ship crews. It would only make sense not to put disabled people in jobs they're not physically capable of doing.
 
And given the progress made in some areas, its logical to assume that there will be fewer disabled in the 24th C- especially if such things are free...
 
Medical science must really be something in the 24th century. In Trek you really don't see many disabled people. You have Geordi being blind and needing the Visors, and you have Barclay with a stammer, besides them I can't think of any other character with some sort of disability. Were there any others??

I have noticed that, of those diseases that are shown to be incurable, quite a number of them (I can't speak to the proportion) seem to be neurological in origin, which suggests to me that's probably one of the areas that 24th-century medicine still has not fully tamed.

It is mentioned (though we're never shown this) that irreversible nerve damage can result from being stunned with a phaser too many times. At least in my own writing, I have expanded upon this and made "stun-shock" (one of my names for it) an iconic malady of 24th-century warfare much as trench-foot was for the soldiers of WWI and WWII.

We have also seen other incurable neurological disorders in several species, such as Irumodic Syndrome, Bendii Syndrome, and Yarim Fel Syndrome (the last of which involves the central nervous system among other things--I personally place my bets on this being an autoimmune disorder). It is interesting to note that at least in humans, we have not had mention of Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, or other well-known neurological disorders of our time. This suggests to me that either new problems are being encountered as the human lifespan increases, or that the conditions of space travel and general 24th-century living bring with them a different set of risks than those to which we are exposed. (For instance, could there be effects of warp travel? Unproven, I know, but just a random example.)
 
Riva was deaf and did not speak, using a chorus to speak for him in negotiations. (The actor who played the role is also deaf and the episode in which he appeared came about as a result of his petition to the show's producers.)
 
I can't remember the character's name, but there was a blind woman in 'Is There In Truth No Beauty?' who wore a dress studded with a sensor network that replaced her sight.

Are Geordi's eyes now artificial, or just fancy contacts?
 
Seeing as how things like third-degree burns can be sured with little more than waving a 'magic wand' in Trek, I don't think a lack of disabled people is all that surprising... lets not forget that the show is mostly about Starfleet, which I would imagine has certain requirements like armed forces today.
 
otherwise DS9 would have instantly went from the worst Trek series to the very best.

fixed.


anyway, wasn't melora just from a light gravity planet so she can't walk in our gravity intensity. she's not actually disabled. at least that's what i thought.
 
What about Bashir? With the way they described him pre-enhancements it seemed as if he had some form or learning difficulty.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top