Compare equivalent episodes across all Treks! (FUN!)

[You_Will_Fail]

I thought it would be fun to have a thread where someone compares all a specific episode of a specific season across all the shows.

So for example, comparing all season 4 episode 21 (picked randomly) shows across all the Trek shows.

TNG vs DS9 vs VOY vs ENT

"The Drumhead" vs "The Muse" vs "The Omega Directive" vs "Terra Prime"

1. "The Drumhead" is the best of these episodes imo. Its kind of exciting and unnerving to see so much suspicion brought on the crew and even the Captain, and the acting here is superb
2. "Terra Prime" is the second best among these. I loved the Trip/T'Pol relationship and that "Terra Prime" was forcing these two together was great. It should have been the damned finale!
3. "The Omega Directive". The idea of some sort of Borg religion was kind of weird but interesting. I was a little disturbed the Voyager crew just left that planet developing the Omega particles with no future though. They were just like "Yep, you're screwed, BAII!!!"
4. "The Muse". Ugh, its unusual to find many bad episodes of DS9 around this mark but this one was a stinker - mainly because it focused on Jake Sisko who I never liked. The fact that Deanna now has a baby brother who is like 40 years younger is kind of disturbing now.

So at the end of each evaluation, pick a season and episode for the next person to do.

Season 3 episode 6!

 

[cblmc1296]

^^^ This is an interesting idea, for sure. I don't know DS9 and ENT well enough to participate but I do like your concept. Is TOS not listed because it didn't have a season 4?

 

[BillJ]

^^^ This is an interesting idea, for sure. I don't know DS9 and ENT well enough to participate but I do like your concept. Is TOS not listed because it didn't have a season 4?

But that should disqualify Enterprise since it doesn't have a seasons 5,6 or 7.

 

[You_Will_Fail]

Well it depends, obviously all are included if its seasons 1-3, TOS isn't if its season 4-7 and ENT isn't included if its seasons 5-7.

 

[Nerys Myk]

You could always use the 21st episode of TAS.

 

[You_Will_Fail]

LOL this isn't working out very well, too much work is involved I guess, haha

 

[The Wormhole]

So at the end of each evaluation, pick a season and episode for the next person to do.

Season 3 episode 6!

Spectre of the Gun, Booby Trap, The Abandoned, Remember, Exile.

Not really a winning group of episodes, is it?

Booby Trap - Well, it is some nice character work for Geordi, and finding an alien shipwreck is kind of cool.
The Abandoned - It is one of the first episodes to develop the Jem'Hadar, and they are among my favourite Star Trek races.
Exile - Honestly, this doesn't have anything going for it, but...
Remember - Is pretty boring.
Spectre of the Gun - I can't remember much about this since I think I've only watched this episode twice, so that's saying something. It definately made no impression if I don't want to rewatch it.

Up next, Season 2, episode 16.