• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Comic Stories/Runs you'd like to see in trade

byron lomax

Commander
Red Shirt
It seems that every story arc released nowadays, for big-name characters at least, gets collected in trade - regardless of whether it deserves to or not. But what about stories from previous decades and eras that can still only be found in the back issue bins? What do you think deserves its own collection? Here's some things I'd like to see:

Alan Grant and Norm Breyfogle's late 80s/early 90s run on Detective Comics (issues 583-594, 601-611) and Batman (455-466 and a few scattered issues after). The Grant/Breyfogle run on Tec is indesputably one of the greatest runs on the character, which brought in a host of new villains, from Scarface and the Corrosive Man to Anarky, as well as kickstarting Tim Drake's career in a brilliant Scarecrow story.

Peter Milligan's "Dark Knight, Dark City" story with Kieron Dwyer (Batman 452-454) and short run on Detective with Jim Aparo (629-633, 638-643) - brilliant, imaginative stories with an element of the supernatural.

Also, I'd love to see a number of stories brought back into print - Ten Nights of the Beast, Joker: Devil's Advocate, a lot of the early Legends of the Dark Knight stories and John Ostrander's uncollected "Demon Within" storyline (Tec 622-624). The late 80s/early 90s were great years for the Bat, they should not be overlooked.

Speaking of Peter Milligan, I'd love to see the brilliant miniseries and one-shots he wrote for Vertigo throughout the 90s - including Face, The Eaters, The Extremist and Girl - get collected in some format. Great, twisted stories from a sorely underrated writer. Enigma is in bad need of a reprint, too.

John Ostrander, too - his excellent Spectre series from the 90s with Tom Mandrake, especially the first twenty issues or so. It proves the character can have his own onrunning series when written well enough. Also, his long-running 80s Suicide Squad book, with great characters and labyrinthine plots. DC keep promising to trade it, then keep holding back - get a move on guys!

I'm not much a Superman fan, but I suspect the story for him is similar to Batman - lots of good 70s, 80s and early 90s material that's still waiting to be traded.
 
"Battle For Metropolis/Fall of Metropolis" from the mid 90s Superman comics. It is this epic story that ties up many of the plot threads since the the Crisis Reboot started. It was never collected. I eventually tracked down the storyline in single issue form last summer at the Chicago Comic Con.

I wouldn't mind as well the Superman Red/Superman Blue story arc traded. I know it wasn't that popular, but, as the title of this thread says, it's what I would like to see. :p

Oh, I'd also like to see the story arc where Superman goes to that pocket universe and is forced to kill Zod and his followers (we also meet Matrix-Supergirl for the first time) and then has a mental breakdown over his actions.
 
Isn't the Red/Blue storyline in the "Superman: Transformed!" trade? I think I used to own that. I'm guessing the kill Zod story is in the John Byrne "Superman: Man of Steel" run of trades?
 
Here's a pipe dream: Marvel's Micronauts series. Unfortunately Marvel doesn't have the rights to most of the characters anymore but I wish they could get a one-time reprint license like they had for the Godzilla Essential they put out a few years ago.

Also I wish they would commit to releasing Paul Levitz's LSH and stop teasing us. And more of the Wally West Flash series than John's run and a smattering of Waid.

It's a crime that the Ostrander/Mandrake Spectre series hasn't been traded.
 
John Ostrander, too - his excellent Spectre series from the 90s with Tom Mandrake, especially the first twenty issues or so. It proves the character can have his own onrunning series when written well enough. Also, his long-running 80s Suicide Squad book, with great characters and labyrinthine plots. DC keep promising to trade it, then keep holding back - get a move on guys!

Seconded, thirded, and fourthed. That Spectre series is one of my favorite comics of all time, and since I only got to read some of Ostrander's Suicide Squad stories back in the day, a complete set of those in trade paperback would be at the top of my list, too. (And it's not a DC title, but while I'm praising Ostrander, it would be great if IDW would collect the rest of the original run of GrimJack, too.)

I'm guessing the kill Zod story is in the John Byrne "Superman: Man of Steel" run of trades?

Sadly, no. The most recent of those trades only goes up to Superman # 12, and the "kill Zod" story was in issue # 22.

Also I wish they would commit to releasing Paul Levitz's LSH and stop teasing us. And more of the Wally West Flash series than John's run and a smattering of Waid.

Yes, please, on both of those counts. There's a deluxe collection of Levitz's The Great Darkness Saga listed on Amazon right now, but (a) that's been reprinted before, and (b) they need to do his whole run! And I'd love the Bill Messner-Loebs Flash stuff, along with the rest of Waid's work on the title.

It's a crime that the Ostrander/Mandrake Spectre series hasn't been traded.

It really is.

Miracleman.

Since reprinting those books would basically be a license to print money, it's a safe bet that Marvel will get to this as soon as the legal issues that still surround the original material are resolved.

And as for me, I'd like to see the following get reprinted:

  • All-Star Squadron: an absolute classic, even if it did get a bit dodgy towards the end.
  • The Power of Shazam!: I loved this series so much, and still miss the real Captain Marvel.
  • Firestorm/The Fury of Firestorm: I haven't read these books for years, but this was one of my favorite titles back in the day.
  • The Shadow: all of the DC versions of the character, especially the Kaluta/O'Neil one and the Gerard Jones/Eduardo Barreto one.
  • Batman and the Outsiders: I know there's a Showcase Volume 1 of this, but I want more (and in color). :)
 
1. Spider-Man: The Death of Jean DeWolff by Peter David - one of the two biggest classic 80s Spider-Man stories ("Kraven's Last Hunt" being the other), this actually was traded several years ago, but it's long out of print.

2. Denny O'Neil's Iron Man - series of trades or an omnibus. Marvel recently released an eight-issue collection of the climax of the "Iron Monger" arc, but that whole run is so interconnected that it really needs to all be available.

3. Alan Moore and Neil Gaiman's Marvelman - Marvel is at least working to make this a reality, so there's a good chance we'll see this in the next few years.
 
Here's a pipe dream: Marvel's Micronauts series. Unfortunately Marvel doesn't have the rights to most of the characters anymore but I wish they could get a one-time reprint license like they had for the Godzilla Essential they put out a few years ago.

Ditto to this. Would love to see these collected/re-printed. A tthe very least, the first twelve issues illustrated by Michael Golden. Great stuff which i remember fondly.

Also need to be a trade reprint of John Byrne's Superman-Batman Generations III. Have the first two in TPB, would really like to be able to complete the set.
 
Here's a pipe dream: Marvel's Micronauts series. Unfortunately Marvel doesn't have the rights to most of the characters anymore but I wish they could get a one-time reprint license like they had for the Godzilla Essential they put out a few years ago.

Ditto to this. Would love to see these collected/re-printed. A tthe very least, the first twelve issues illustrated by Michael Golden. Great stuff which i remember fondly.

Thirded. Golden's early work on Micronauts is my favorite comic book art, period. About twenty years ago, I owned the first eleven issues or so reprinted into three volumes. On mando paper, the art and color was spectacular. I'd love to see these collected into one volume on high quality paper.
 
I think the Micronauts issues have been settled, as all of the characters have recently appeared in Realm of Kings: Son of Hulk, and Bug is even a member of the Guardians of the Galaxy.

I haven't seen them, but I'd love a trade of the early Claremont/Davis Excalibur run.
 
I haven't seen them, but I'd love a trade of the early Claremont/Davis Excalibur run.

Maybe the first 100 issues? i loved Excalibur in the day and have them but wouldn't mind a trade, too.

Also, I'd like a trade that gathered all of the Claremont-inspired, Days of Future Past-influenced stories from the X titles of the era-all of the issues from the various series(including the 4 issue FF books) that play upon the "doomed future" of the Xmen. But they'd have to include a heck of a lot of Excalibur because of Rachel. It would be a pretty big book, though...
 
John Ostrander, too - his excellent Spectre series from the 90s with Tom Mandrake, especially the first twenty issues or so. It proves the character can have his own onrunning series when written well enough. Also, his long-running 80s Suicide Squad book, with great characters and labyrinthine plots. DC keep promising to trade it, then keep holding back - get a move on guys!

Ha, I am fortunate enough to own the entire Suicide Squad series and most of the Spectre series. :techman:

I am not fortunate enough to own the last dozen issues or so of the Spectre, since I had to stop collecting right about then. :( I'd love a TPB of that part of the series, at least.

I think the Micronauts issues have been settled, as all of the characters have recently appeared in Realm of Kings: Son of Hulk, and Bug is even a member of the Guardians of the Galaxy.

I think they can use Bug with impunity. He wasn't based on a toy.
 
I haven't seen them, but I'd love a trade of the early Claremont/Davis Excalibur run.
Aren't those in the Excalibur Classic trades?

Recently I've been reading a lot of Green Arrow, and since I've very nearly read every trade out there, I want a collected edition of the vol. 2 series, with Mike Grell and Chuck Dixon's runs. Almost none of it is collected, aside from some scattered issues. Maybe a couple of nice omnibi after DC finally finishes up Starman?
 
I'd like a reprinting of "Superman: President Lex" one of my favorite Superman arcs and I second wanting a trade of the Zod storyline from the pocket universe. I had just started reading Action and Superman near that time and recently read the "Superman: Exiled" trade that follows it.
 
Oh yes I'm dying to see the entire circa 2000 Superman run with Ed McGuinness and Joe Kelly and Jeph Loeb. Those damn things are going for like 50 used each! The only bits in print are Our Worlds At War and I think Emperor Joker is out of print as well now!
 
For me it would be the Batman storylines

- Knight's Quest: The Crusade
- Knight's Quest: The Search
- Aftershock
- Road to No Man's Land
 
I'm probably the only person who wants this, but I'd like to see the Loeb/Sale Catwoman: When In Rome miniseries that was an offshoot of The Long Halloween/Dark Victory. I like what they did with Selina/Catwoman's character in those stories. Has anyone read When In Rome? Are these worth my time to try and track down loose?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top