Gilligan’s Island was always absurd and the series was stupid enough to support the format change. The concept of celebrities on the Island was nothing knew, it was just that the execution was, well, ghastly. And, from what I understand, Gilligan's Island wasn't a failure. It's ratings were okay in its final year and a fourth season was planned. But Gunsmoke was cancelled and CBS president William Paley's wife was upset (Gunsmoke was apparently her favorite show). They needed another half hour on the schedule to fit in the hour long western, so Gilligan got the axe (Paley reportedly hated the series anyway). Gunsmoke went on to ratings success and lasted a full 20 years.
Almost nobody seemed to know how to approach reunion movies, especially when done by people uninvolved in the production side of the original shows. They always seemed to be intended as pilots for revivals instead of existing on their own. So, quite often we had to suffer through older versions of the characters with kids we never heard of and maybe a return of one of the antagonists in the series making trouble. That always sucks.
Well, almost always…
But seriously, The Six Million Dollar Man/Bionic Woman, I Spy, I Dream of Jeannie, The Wild Wild West and a plethora of others…they just couldn’t capture the magic of the shows which spawned them.
Almost nobody seemed to know how to approach reunion movies, especially when done by people uninvolved in the production side of the original shows. They always seemed to be intended as pilots for revivals instead of existing on their own. So, quite often we had to suffer through older versions of the characters with kids we never heard of and maybe a return of one of the antagonists in the series making trouble. That always sucks.
Well, almost always…
But seriously, The Six Million Dollar Man/Bionic Woman, I Spy, I Dream of Jeannie, The Wild Wild West and a plethora of others…they just couldn’t capture the magic of the shows which spawned them.