"Capt. Kirk Alive" Quote

[bionicbob]

In both the Fan Made BRING BACK KIRK TRAILER
and the online fan series PHASE II pilot "Come What May",
you can hear the dialogue line,
"Captain Kirk is alive!".

Does anyone know what episode this is audio is lifted from???

 

[GSchnitzer]

In both the Fan Made BRING BACK KIRK TRAILER
and the online fan series PHASE II pilot "Come What May",
you can hear the dialogue line,
"Captain Kirk is alive!".

Does anyone know what episode this is audio is lifted from???

In the Star Trek New Voyages/Phase II episode "Come What May," the dialog "Gentlemen, Captain Kirk is alive" was recorded for our episode by our own Mister Spock, Jeff Quinn. I can't speak informedly on what the "Bring Back Kirk" folks used (except to say that it's not a reuse of our audio). (Perhaps it's audio from the audiobook version of one of the Shatnerverse novels.)

 

[Duncan MacLeod]

I believe it was lifted from The Tholian Web.

 

[KirkPicard]

I believe you are correct. Spock states in that episode:

SPOCK: A few hours ago, the Captain elected to remain on board the Defiant so that three members of this crew would have the best chance of returning safely to the Enterprise. His concern was not only for them, but for all the members of the crew of this ship. You all know the sequence of events. We were fired upon by the Tholian ship. At that time, Captain Kirk may have been alive. I deemed it necessary to return the Tholian fire for the safety of the Enterprise. The Tholian ship has been disabled. But as a result of the battle, we must accept the fact that Captain Kirk is no longer alive.