• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Can Chris Pine talk a computer to death?

Magickthise

Lieutenant Commander
Red Shirt
Like back in the "too cerebral" Star Trek? Or rip his shirt in every fight? He didn't rip his shirt once that I remember, or kill even one computer by talking to it. What crap! I want cerebral!
 
I like my Spock cerebral too...and I feel we are losing that essense with this on ship romance that's occuring....!
 
well yes considering some of the stuff prime kirk spouted at those computers sounded like what pike told the young bad boy kirk.

;)
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.
 
Like back in the "too cerebral" Star Trek? Or rip his shirt in every fight? He didn't rip his shirt once that I remember, or kill even one computer by talking to it. What crap! I want cerebral!

Because of the Altered Timeline Starfleet uniforms are more durable. As a result Kirks enemies could no longer use their tactic of removing Kirks shirt so he would die of hypothermia. Instead they had to resort to the less subtle option of simply choking him every five minutes.
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

pine's kirk was described as being genuis level and who finished
the academy in three years.

:)
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

pine's kirk was described as being genuis level and who finished
the academy in three years.

:)

No matter....Kirk Jr. hardly came off as being a genius...I know he graduated in 3yrs...had the nohow and really the connections to beat the test...but I still didn't get genius...absolutely not.
 
Like back in the "too cerebral" Star Trek? Or rip his shirt in every fight? He didn't rip his shirt once that I remember, or kill even one computer by talking to it. What crap! I want cerebral!
And how exactly is ripping his shirt off cerebral?
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

pine's kirk was described as being genuis level and who finished
the academy in three years.

:)

No matter....Kirk Jr. hardly came off as being a genius...I know he graduated in 3yrs...had the nohow and really the connections to beat the test...but I still didn't get genius...absolutely not.

Just because you don't act like a genius doesn't mean you weren't one. Kirk had an incredible sense of timing. Note during the sky-diving sequence that he was roughly figuring the decent time by eye. Or his command ability to use all of his crew rather than simply issue orders to them (like Spock often does). Or the plan to take Spock Prime's ship, or to find that third option between a suicidal attack or retreating to meet the rest of the fleet.
 
I like my Spock cerebral too...and I feel we are losing that essense with this on ship romance that's occuring....!

Romance is compatible with cerebral. In fact, they are orthogonal qualities. They have no relationship with each other, unless you stereotype Spock as the "nerdy geek who gets none." Spock certainly was cerebral as well. He reasoned courses of action (even though they might not have been the best courses of action, they were still based on sound logic).
 
Like back in the "too cerebral" Star Trek? Or rip his shirt in every fight? He didn't rip his shirt once that I remember, or kill even one computer by talking to it. What crap! I want cerebral!
And how exactly is ripping his shirt off cerebral?

I don' know, but since (as I'm told) this movie is just action and adventure, and TOS was thoughtful, well written art, I was just assuming.

I wonder how Pine's Kirk will deal with all the other well written and thoughtful stuff that made TOS so much better, like the space hippies, Abraham Lincoln, Alice's white rabbit, or any of the several parallel Earths.
 
Like back in the "too cerebral" Star Trek? Or rip his shirt in every fight? He didn't rip his shirt once that I remember, or kill even one computer by talking to it. What crap! I want cerebral!

he certainly talked Spock to his own (well, almost) demise :p
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

do we know for sure that Kirk Prime was all those things you say BEFORE he became Kirk Prime? if so, please cite canon, not fanon. ;)
 
I wonder how Pine's Kirk will deal with all the other well written and thoughtful stuff that made TOS so much better, like the space hippies, Abraham Lincoln, Alice's white rabbit, or any of the several parallel Earths.
However the writters tell him too... :)
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

pine's kirk was described as being genuis level and who finished
the academy in three years.

:)

Captain Pike: "You must the only genius-level repeat offender around here..."

Yep. genius.

Pike said it.

who are WE to refute?
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

pine's kirk was described as being genuis level and who finished
the academy in three years.

:)

No matter....Kirk Jr. hardly came off as being a genius...I know he graduated in 3yrs...had the nohow and really the connections to beat the test...but I still didn't get genius...absolutely not.
My good friend and next-door neighbor growing up was an official "genius" (ne has an IQ of somewhere around 150 to 160 IIRC). However, there were times as a teenager that you would barely guess that this kid was a genius, let alone someone who would succeed in life. He didn't start fights at bars like young Kirk did, but he (we) did some pretty stupid things as teenagers.

He has long since matured and is now a tenured math professor at a major university and has published papers on advanced mathmatics that are respected by his peers (which I have read online and have no idea what the hell he is talking about :)).

So if Pike says Kirk is a genius, then it is established that Kirk is a genius...I don't need to see proof (although the rest of the film establishes that Kirk's intelligence is very high).
 
kirk prime was a genious and master of warfare. kirk jr. Is more of a genious slacker & underachiever that went to frat parties during enrollment. Different childhood & upbringing.

pine's kirk was described as being genuis level and who finished
the academy in three years.

:)

Captain Pike: "You must the only genius-level repeat offender around here..."

Yep. genius.

Pike said it.

who are WE to refute?

He must have been popped like 30 percocet and about a liter of vodka before talking to Kirk.

I didn't buy Anakin being a genius or special, and I'm not buying nuKirk either.
 
Like back in the "too cerebral" Star Trek? Or rip his shirt in every fight? He didn't rip his shirt once that I remember, or kill even one computer by talking to it. What crap! I want cerebral!

It depends on how bad the computer programmers in the New Timeline are. Because in the Prime, they were shite.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top