• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Burke and Samno - names reused?

Sisko_is_my_captain

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
Burke and Samno were murdered in Star Trek VI. I have been re-watching ER lately and in season nine episode four, Walk Like a Man, two soldiers are named Burke and Sammo. Surely that can't be a coincidence. What is the link between the episode in the movie?
 
Surely that can't be a coincidence.

Of course it can. Coincidences happen all the time. Contrary to popular belief, it's extremely common for writers to come up with ideas that are accidentally similar to stuff other people have come up with. It's hard to avoid. TV shows and movies have legal departments that check character names to see if they infringe on something or are too similar to the name of a real person in the same profession as the character, and it's pretty common for character names to get changed because of such coincidental similarities (e.g. Enterprise's Jonathan Archer needed a name change from Jackson Archer for that reason, and the TV version of The Dresden Files changed Chicago cop Karrin Murphy's name to Connie Murphy because it turned out there was a real Chicago cop named Karen Murphy). Creators generally try not to copy things, so contrary to popular belief, that kind of similarity is generally evidence that the creators didn't know they were echoing something similar.

Okay, sometimes there are deliberate homages, sure. If they were named, say, Bert and Ernie, then you could safely reckon it was an homage to It's a Wonderful Life or to Sesame Street. But Burke and Samno? They're so minor that I doubt anyone would care enough about them to bother with such an homage. Burke is a very common name, so it's bound to crop up all over. And the other name is just similar to Samno, not identical. So I'd say it's more likely to be a coincidence.
 
Fleetingly, on my first viewing of ST IV, I thought the naming of humpback whales George and Gracie was a homage to George Takei and Grace Lee Whitney. Then - "d'oh!" - George Burns and Gracie Allen entered my brain before I said anything dumb aloud. Coincidentally (or not?), Susan Sackett was then-writing a George & Gracie biography, published in 1986.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top