• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

"BSG"-style reboot

Joey Danger

Cadet
Newbie
More on this as it develops, but I am working on a few story ideas for a new series which, of course, is completely fictional. That said, I am going to start by posting my cast list. I will add explanations for why I believe in these actors in a couple of days, but here is the bare bones list. I welcome all praise, concerns, suggestions, and bitching, so have at it. Again, I will be adding summaries for all of my choices soon, so for now, think about these actors:

Matt Damon as Kirk
Zachary Quinto as Spock
Gary Sinise as McCoy
Alan Cumming as Scottie
Beyonce Knowles as Uhura
Kelvin Yu as Sulu
Trevor Fehrman as Chekov
Tricia Helfer as Chapel
Hayden Panettiere as Rand
Ben Browder as Pike
Christopher Eccleston as Sarek
Nestor Carbonell as Kahn
Ricky Gervais as Mudd
Jack Black as Cyrano Jones
Chow Yun Fat as Koloth
Denise Richards as Carol Marcus

(That's about it for now. I still need choices for Kor, Sybok, Amanda Grayson, and a few others, so any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.)
 
Given this is fan fiction, who is portraying the character is not that important. I'll be more interested to see how you change the characters and their place within the Star Trek universe and how you change the universe around the characters.
 
Joey D:

Your first mistake was calling it a "BSG-style" reboot, because most people that frequent this BBS have no idea what that actually means and therefore make assumptions based on what they don't like about nuBSG, and more often than not they'll reject it out of hand.

Second, rofeta is correct. You're making the same mistake most anti-Abrams trekkers are making about Trek XI - that a recast constitutes a reboot. Who you want to play the parts means almost nothing without some information about the characters to go with the names. Also, rofeta's interests reflect those of nearly everybody who frequents the fanfiction forum. We like to knock around ideas and we love to see stories, and you haven't included either.

Also, personally, I'd like to know why you're doing a reboot in the first place. It's not that I'm against the idea. It's just that a lot of people lately have been bitten by the reboot bug and I feel that one's reasons for taking the plunge affect the type of stories we'll get from them.
 
^ Admiral2 said it much clearer then I did.

The reboot of TOS pre-Star Trek XI is interesting, personally I wouldn't go there until after the movie came out to see just what effect it had on the "timeline".
 
I had loads of ideas for a TOS Reboot which I posted in a thread elsewhere, if you're interested I can copy them here.
 
Okay, here's the thing: I only had time to list the cast the other day, so I will now add some log-lines and summaries of the new cast and why I cast them in this particular story. First, I will proceed with the cast, and then I will list episode ideas. Again, I welcome any and all episode ideas.

Matt Damon as Kirk:
The actor who plays Kirk must possess some very specific qualities. He has to be young, (mid-30's) in great physical condition, and have the gravitas and intelligence to command a ship with of over 400 men and women. Damon's got that in spades!

Zachary Quinto as Spock:
What can be said about this one that hasn't already been said? Facially, he does bear a striking resemblance to a young Leonard Nimoy; but more importantly, he is extremely convincing as a mysterious outsider with powers beyond those around him. As the mysterious Sylar, he has a sense of strangeness about him which translates well to a sense of otherworldiness needed to play Spock. In a word, it's... Logical.

Gary Sinise as McCoy:
McCoy, being older and wiser than Kirk and Spock, has a passion for life that seems to be an innate quality in Mr. Sinise. He was also damned convincing as an astronaut, southerner, and military veteran. Plus, he looks cool in a lab coat! how many people can say that?

Alan Cumming as Scottie:
This one is so perfect, it's hard to summarize in a few sentences. Not only does he look a hell of a lot like Doohan, he also has a Scottish accent that is STRIKINGLY similar to the one James doohan used in the original show and subsequent movies, he's about the same age as Scottie was in '66, and most importantly, he's the same kind of actor as Doohan was. These are often referred to as "character actors." They are able to pull off almost anything; including limps, accents, masks, prosthetics, etc. Cumming is one such actor. Whether he's in X2, Tin Man, Cabaret, or the many other films and plays under his belt; He blends in seamlessly. He fits this part like a glove.

Beyonce Knowles as Uhura:
Like James Doohan, Nichelle Nichols is a very special actress. She can sing, dance, and act. Whether she's on stage, on TV, or in film; she works it, and good! Ms. Knowles is a logical successor for her comparability in these talents, as well as looking a bit like Miss Nichols. She can more than hold her own among a talented ensemble as seen in DreamGirls, with a presence that is both distinctive and consistent. The very same thing can be said about Nichols. What more could anyone ask?

Kelvin Yu as Sulu:
Perhaps the thinnest character on paper, this should be the easiest one to cast. Sulu has precious few character-defining moments, so several candidates could probably carry this one off. Kelvin Yu is my choice because he, like several members of my dream cast, can hold his own in an ensemble cast, (Grandma's Boy) as well as being comfortable with special effects. (Cloverfield) And as an added bonus, he does look a bit like a young George Takei.

Trevor Fehrman as Chekov:
Here is another character actor who has a lot of big things ahead of him. I have no doubt he can do a Russian accent, as well as being a great person for the kids to relate to. Our young chekov never had much screen time, so Fehrman is a good choice for layering and deepening the character.

Tricia Helfer as Chapel:
Who better to play Dr. McCoy's tall, sexy, blonde, leggy assistant than a tall, sexy, blonde, leggy chick whom we know is well-versed in the mechanics of making a science fiction show? Besides, with McCoy's gruff bedside manner, with Helfer in the sick bay, crewmen might actually show up for thier physicals!

Hayden Panettiere as Rand:
In the original, Rand was actually older than Kirk, but I want to give Chekov another young person to play off of, and maybe even provide some romantic sparks. Like others in this cast, she's good in science fiction, and blends into an amazing ensemble cast; both elements definitely necessary for the part of everybody's favorite yeoman.

Ben Browder as Pike:
There are 12 Constellation-class starships in the fleet, so the captains of those ships would probably be pretty well known. As someone familiar to fans of this genre, it's not a stretch to see Browder as a starship captain.

Christopher Eccleston as Sarek:
As the Vulcan ambassador to the Federation, Sarek would be familiar to the citizens of the Federation, and by extension, the viewer. Eccleston fits the bill, having some pretty impressive scifi credits under his belt. It doesn't hurt that he looks like Mark Lenard in the original series, either. Put the ears on him, and he would be instantly recognizable. It's logical.

Nestor Carbonell as Kahn:
I always wondered why an Indian Sikh warrior was played by Ricardo Montalban, but hey; that's how it happened, so... Anyway, Carbonell plays a great villain in Lost, which is yet another science fiction show with an ensemble cast. This one seems simple enough.

Ricky Gervais as Harry Mudd:
His over-the-top energy is perfect to play everyone's favorite con man. He counterpoints the dramatic nature of the show quite nicely. If he can consistently do an American "accent," he's got it!

Jack Black as Cyrano Jones:
With his bombastic personality, he's the perfect choice to visit the horror of the tribbles onto the Enterprise.

Chow Yun-Fat as Koloth:
Since Pirates 3: At World's End, I have been convinced Chow Yun-Fat would make a damn convincing Klingon while adding some much-needed gravitas to the Klingon Empire.


And now for the episodes:

1: An explosion in the engine room kills and injures several of Scottie's men. If repairs are not affected in time, the ship will be destroyed. Scottie and a few unqualified crewmen must win a race against time; meanwhile, McCoy and Chapel switch into triage-mode to save several of the ship's most experienced and valuable officers.

2: (two-parter) pt.1: Balance of Terror.
pt.2: Mr. Spock becomes the target of a witch-hunt and is accused of being a Romulan Spy. A special tribunal is convened and evidence is presented which is obviously fabricated. Kirk must prove the evidence is falsified and clear Spock's name lest he be convicted of treason.

3: The Enterprise docks at a starbase to pick up a load of quadrotriticale for delivery to a Federation colony. While there, a group of Klingons are granted shore leave on the base. Amid the chaos, a con man called Cyrano Jones introduces the crew to the Tribbles. The Tribbles overrun the ship and eat the entire load of grain... Then people start to disappear.

4: The Enterprise is ordered to execute a recon mission when Federation intelligenge reports indicate the Klingons are conducting genetic experiments on a secret base. They discover that the experiments are being conducted in a Mangala-esque lab and that the Klingons are experimenting with eugenics. Kirk must disable the base's defenses, destroy the base, and make it back in one piece.

5: The Klingons sign a non-agression pact with the Romulans and the two empires begin to share technology. With War loomin just over the horizon, The combined forces target a starbase which contains a classified piece of technology. The Enterprise is docked at that starbase undergoing a routine computer refit. The station is taken by surprise and boarded with a compliment of Klingon and Romulan troops. With systems down on the ship and reinforcements 12 hours away, the Federation personell and our valiant crew must hold off the enemy force until backup can arrive.

6: The Enterprise is called in to transport a medical team to a Federation colony where a highly-virulent plague has broken out. The team is headed by Dr. McCoy's father, David. The Dr. and his father have not spoken since McCoy's mother's death a decade ago. The two must put aside thier diferences when the team fails to synthesize an adequate vaccine and McCoy's expertise in exotic viruses is needed.
(*NOTE: McCoy blames his father for his mother's death. David "pulled the plug" on his wife, a decision which McCoy strongly opposed. After the two work things out, McCoy promises to change his convictions if his father wished it so.*)

MORE TO COME
 
Okay, here's the thing: I only had time to list the cast the other day, so I will now add some log-lines and summaries of the new cast and why I cast them in this particular story. First, I will proceed with the cast, and then I will list episode ideas. Again, I welcome any and all episode ideas.

Matt Damon as Kirk:
The actor who plays Kirk must possess some very specific qualities. He has to be young, (mid-30's) in great physical condition, and have the gravitas and intelligence to command a ship with of over 400 men and women. Damon's got that in spades!

Zachary Quinto as Spock:
What can be said about this one that hasn't already been said? Facially, he does bear a striking resemblance to a young Leonard Nimoy; but more importantly, he is extremely convincing as a mysterious outsider with powers beyond those around him. As the mysterious Sylar, he has a sense of strangeness about him which translates well to a sense of otherworldiness needed to play Spock. In a word, it's... Logical.

Gary Sinise as McCoy:
McCoy, being older and wiser than Kirk and Spock, has a passion for life that seems to be an innate quality in Mr. Sinise. He was also damned convincing as an astronaut, southerner, and military veteran. Plus, he looks cool in a lab coat! how many people can say that?

Alan Cumming as Scottie:
This one is so perfect, it's hard to summarize in a few sentences. Not only does he look a hell of a lot like Doohan, he also has a Scottish accent that is STRIKINGLY similar to the one James doohan used in the original show and subsequent movies, he's about the same age as Scottie was in '66, and most importantly, he's the same kind of actor as Doohan was. These are often referred to as "character actors." They are able to pull off almost anything; including limps, accents, masks, prosthetics, etc. Cumming is one such actor. Whether he's in X2, Tin Man, Cabaret, or the many other films and plays under his belt; He blends in seamlessly. He fits this part like a glove.

Beyonce Knowles as Uhura:
Like James Doohan, Nichelle Nichols is a very special actress. She can sing, dance, and act. Whether she's on stage, on TV, or in film; she works it, and good! Ms. Knowles is a logical successor for her comparability in these talents, as well as looking a bit like Miss Nichols. She can more than hold her own among a talented ensemble as seen in DreamGirls, with a presence that is both distinctive and consistent. The very same thing can be said about Nichols. What more could anyone ask?

Kelvin Yu as Sulu:
Perhaps the thinnest character on paper, this should be the easiest one to cast. Sulu has precious few character-defining moments, so several candidates could probably carry this one off. Kelvin Yu is my choice because he, like several members of my dream cast, can hold his own in an ensemble cast, (Grandma's Boy) as well as being comfortable with special effects. (Cloverfield) And as an added bonus, he does look a bit like a young George Takei.

Trevor Fehrman as Chekov:
Here is another character actor who has a lot of big things ahead of him. I have no doubt he can do a Russian accent, as well as being a great person for the kids to relate to. Our young chekov never had much screen time, so Fehrman is a good choice for layering and deepening the character.

Tricia Helfer as Chapel:
Who better to play Dr. McCoy's tall, sexy, blonde, leggy assistant than a tall, sexy, blonde, leggy chick whom we know is well-versed in the mechanics of making a science fiction show? Besides, with McCoy's gruff bedside manner, with Helfer in the sick bay, crewmen might actually show up for thier physicals!

Hayden Panettiere as Rand:
In the original, Rand was actually older than Kirk, but I want to give Chekov another young person to play off of, and maybe even provide some romantic sparks. Like others in this cast, she's good in science fiction, and blends into an amazing ensemble cast; both elements definitely necessary for the part of everybody's favorite yeoman.

Ben Browder as Pike:
There are 12 Constellation-class starships in the fleet, so the captains of those ships would probably be pretty well known. As someone familiar to fans of this genre, it's not a stretch to see Browder as a starship captain.

Christopher Eccleston as Sarek:
As the Vulcan ambassador to the Federation, Sarek would be familiar to the citizens of the Federation, and by extension, the viewer. Eccleston fits the bill, having some pretty impressive scifi credits under his belt. It doesn't hurt that he looks like Mark Lenard in the original series, either. Put the ears on him, and he would be instantly recognizable. It's logical.

Nestor Carbonell as Kahn:
I always wondered why an Indian Sikh warrior was played by Ricardo Montalban, but hey; that's how it happened, so... Anyway, Carbonell plays a great villain in Lost, which is yet another science fiction show with an ensemble cast. This one seems simple enough.

Ricky Gervais as Harry Mudd:
His over-the-top energy is perfect to play everyone's favorite con man. He counterpoints the dramatic nature of the show quite nicely. If he can consistently do an American "accent," he's got it!

Jack Black as Cyrano Jones:
With his bombastic personality, he's the perfect choice to visit the horror of the tribbles onto the Enterprise.

Chow Yun-Fat as Koloth:
Since Pirates 3: At World's End, I have been convinced Chow Yun-Fat would make a damn convincing Klingon while adding some much-needed gravitas to the Klingon Empire.


And now for the episodes:

1: An explosion in the engine room kills and injures several of Scottie's men. If repairs are not affected in time, the ship will be destroyed. Scottie and a few unqualified crewmen must win a race against time; meanwhile, McCoy and Chapel switch into triage-mode to save several of the ship's most experienced and valuable officers.

2: (two-parter) pt.1: Balance of Terror.
pt.2: Mr. Spock becomes the target of a witch-hunt and is accused of being a Romulan Spy. A special tribunal is convened and evidence is presented which is obviously fabricated. Kirk must prove the evidence is falsified and clear Spock's name lest he be convicted of treason.

3: The Enterprise docks at a starbase to pick up a load of quadrotriticale for delivery to a Federation colony. While there, a group of Klingons are granted shore leave on the base. Amid the chaos, a con man called Cyrano Jones introduces the crew to the Tribbles. The Tribbles overrun the ship and eat the entire load of grain... Then people start to disappear.

4: The Enterprise is ordered to execute a recon mission when Federation intelligenge reports indicate the Klingons are conducting genetic experiments on a secret base. They discover that the experiments are being conducted in a Mangala-esque lab and that the Klingons are experimenting with eugenics. Kirk must disable the base's defenses, destroy the base, and make it back in one piece.

5: The Klingons sign a non-agression pact with the Romulans and the two empires begin to share technology. With War loomin just over the horizon, The combined forces target a starbase which contains a classified piece of technology. The Enterprise is docked at that starbase undergoing a routine computer refit. The station is taken by surprise and boarded with a compliment of Klingon and Romulan troops. With systems down on the ship and reinforcements 12 hours away, the Federation personell and our valiant crew must hold off the enemy force until backup can arrive.

6: The Enterprise is called in to transport a medical team to a Federation colony where a highly-virulent plague has broken out. The team is headed by Dr. McCoy's father, David. The Dr. and his father have not spoken since McCoy's mother's death a decade ago. The two must put aside thier diferences when the team fails to synthesize an adequate vaccine and McCoy's expertise in exotic viruses is needed.
(*NOTE: McCoy blames his father for his mother's death. David "pulled the plug" on his wife, a decision which McCoy strongly opposed. After the two work things out, McCoy promises to change his convictions if his father wished it so.*)

MORE TO COME

I hate to say this, but if these are the stories you intend to tell and you're using characters we're already familiar with, you're not rebooting anything. You're just telling TOS continuing Trek with a new cast, exactly what JJ Abrams is already doing. You haven't made any kind of significant change in how the stories will be told, which is the purpose of a "BSG-style" reboot.
 
Here's the notes I mentioned:

ULTIMATE STAR TREK


It is some point in the future - far enough for space travel to be as common place to our heroes as sea travel and air travel are to us - and mankind has become part of an organisation known as the United Federation of Planets.

The Federation is analogous to the United Nations, a political entity but not a military one, with each member having their own space faring military forces.

Starfleet, the space faring military force of Earth, has launched a new ship, the USS Enterprise. It is massive, designed as a battlecruiser it has been retrofitted with extensive science facilities - which leads to friction between the scientists and the military personel who see each other as infringing on their mission.

In command of this ship is CAPTAIN JAMES T. KIRK (Dominic Cooper) who is given command in spite of, or perhaps because of, his cowboy nature and in charge of the massive ships new science department is a middle aged curmudgeon, DOCTOR LEONARD MCCOY (), who is - much to everyones relief - an old friend of Kirks so this makes the science/military friction a bit less openly hostile.

LT COMMANDER HIKARU SULU (John Cho) is the First Officer of the ship, a brilliant mathematician who also functions as ships Helm Officer and Senior Navigator, who fancies himself a cavalier swordsman. LT COMMANDER HEATHER SCOTT (Kate Walsh) is the fiery red headed Scottish Chief Engineer of the Enterprise who is fiercely protective of her engines and has a reputation as a miracle worker.

CADET JANICE RAND (Blake Lively) is only supposed to be on the Enterprise for six months but her eagerness and brilliance soon have Kirk requesting she remain - but is it just her brilliance he likes?

DR CHRISTINE CHAPEL (Freema Agyeman) is one of McCoy's medical personnel, LT JOHN KYLE (Tahmoh Penikett) is a transporter technician (and Lieutenant Commander Sulu's long term boyfriend) and DR CAROL MARCUS (Anna Tory) is a brilliant theortetical scientist working under McCoy.

As the Enterprise prepares for departure, a message arrives for Kirk that dispatches the Enterprise to the fringes of known space where a Federation science team has uncovered alien ruins that are suspected to be eons old. Enterprise will rendezvous with the VCS Shi'kar under COMMANDER SPOCK (Omid Abtahi) whilst they will also take onboard AMBASSADOR UHURA (Chandra Wilson) a renowned diplomat from the Earth government.

Spock is a Vulcan, a member of a race who believe in controlling emotions and are highly intelligent. Spock has always had trouble with controlling his emotions but cannot understand why - a reason which we will discover is the fault of his father.

AMBASSADOR SAREK (Oded Fehr), a Vulcan diplomat and Spocks father, is also a member of a secretive Vulcan cult known as the Romulans who believe in the teachings of a figure known as Romulus who believe that logic must be either forced upon those who do not posess it, or those who refuse it must be eliminated.

As the series begins, the Romulans have just been revealed to have been responsible for the deaths of thousands on an Earth space station. Some of the crew on the Enterprise can't see past the pointed ears and struggle to work with Spock - but he eventually wins their trust.

On the planet, Spock, Kirk and McCoy come to work together after Spock's ship is destroyed by a KLINGON VESSEL that has been stalking both the Enterprise and the Shi'kar. The Klingons are a formerly powerful Empire that has fractured - formerly a cohesive military power, the various houses that make up the Empire have fractured into smaller and constantly shifting alliances most of which view the United Federation of Planets as both a threat and the reason for their Empires collapse.

The alien civilisation threatens the Enterprise and the Klingons but they're able to recover a map of alien planets which may be the sites of further ancient ruins.

Starfleet want Enterprise to explore those planets on behalf of the whole Federation but the Enterprise must keep the database of those planets secret in case they fall into the hands of the Klingons or the secretive Tholians.

In the end, Kirk invites Spock to remain onboard the Enterprise as advisor and Spock accepts, something he is prompted to do by his mysterious father for reasons unknown.

As the pilot finishes, the Enterprise is assigned a five year mission to seek out new lifeforms, new civlisations and to boldly go where no human has gone before ...

Season 1

1.01 - To Boldly Go

As outlined above.

1.02 - TBC
1.03 - TBC

1.04 / 1.05 - The Cage / The Menagerie

Commodore Christopher Pike, Kirk's former Commanding Officer, arrives on the Enterprise in mysterious cirumstances with instructions that the Enterprise is to investigate the disappearance of the survey vessel Venture which is believed to have crashlanded on the fourth planet of the Talos system.

The crew of the Enterprise come to learn why Pike wants to find the Venture so much and Kirk comes to realise that the man he idolised isn't the figure that he thought he was.

And then there's the mysterious inhabitants of Talos IV who view mankind with curiosity.

1.06 - Space Seed

Two hundred years ago, mankind sent prison sleeper ships into the void that would make contact when they touched down on an habitable planet. The Enterprise comes across one of those sleeper ships, the Bounty, drifting in space and unwittingly wake the prisoners onboard - prisoners led by the famous and charismatic serial killer, Khan Noonien Singh.

Kirk ends up stranding the prisoners on an arid planetoid in a distant system.

1.07 - TBC
1.08 - TBC
1.09 - TBC
1.10 - TBC
1.11 - TBC

1.12 / 1.13 - Genesis / The Wrath of Khan

Khan and his fellow prisoners manage to overpower the crew of the Starfleet ship that has been sent to check on them, deliver supplies and equipment and set out to seek revenge on Captain Kirk and the crew of the Enterprise. Kirk and the Enterprise are at the Mutara Nebula where Doctor Marcus' team are preparing to testdrive their new terraforming device - the Genesis Probe.

It will be a hard battle for the Enterprise crew, and not everyone will come out of it alive, when Captain Kirk takes on Khan Noonien Singh.
 
Admiral2;1884744 I hate to say this said:
Actually, you could not be more off. The choice of a new cast and retelling familiar sories as well as new ones is exactly what a reboot is . As gor the BSG reference it indicates the tone of the show.
 
Admiral2;1884744 I hate to say this said:
Actually, you could not be more off. The choice of a new cast and retelling familiar sories as well as new ones is exactly what a reboot is . As gor the BSG reference it indicates the tone of the show.

So, you are one of those people who has no idea what RDM actually did with BSG.

Again, it wasn't just a recasting and rehashing of the old series. He changed the way Battlestar Galactica stories were told. nuBSG is not just oldBSG with new actors. What you've detailed here is just TOS Trek with new actors. tenmei's ideas demonstrate a much better understanding of the concept than yours do.
 
Actually, you could not be more off. The choice of a new cast and retelling familiar sories as well as new ones is exactly what a reboot is . As gor the BSG reference it indicates the tone of the show.

The problem is, your pitch so far shows no reason why it couldn't just be filmed and shown as Season 4 of TOS. Sure, it has a new cast, but there is absolutely nothing outside of that cast that makes it a reboot.
 
Given what we have so far I would agree that this at the moment appears to be more of a "remake" then a "reboot".

Maybe the OP has some information on how the characters (not the actors) will be changed? Or about how he plans to "re imagine" the Trek universe
 
I have been entertaining a Reboot idea myself, and have to agree... this isn't a reboot.

In my continuity, Kirk's adventure is set in the late 2800's, and is built on a significantly different history. There is no time travel, Mitchell is Kirk's XO, the ship is much smaller (at most, a crew of 200), it is Earth centric, with Spock being admitted to the crew on a technicality (his human mother). Warp drive works differently, no combat or communication when travelling in Hyperspace, no goofy transporter duplications (you either transport successfully or you die, you don't become happy Kirk and nasty Kirk), no universal translator for unknown languages, the Enterprise and her sister ships comprimise a "Great Grey Fleet" which, publically, is out there 'exploring'. But, unbeknownst to the public and even most of the crew, the ship has a secret mission, to find the thread that unites the many humanioid races of the galaxy.

There have been no Romulan Wars, for they haven't been encountered. A massive war against the Klingons has left Earth and her NATO-esque/G8-esque neighbors in a shambles that they are only now crawling out from under. Weapons of war (the Constitution class) have become vanguards of peace and exploration. Who knows what will be found on the Rim?

Some TOS stories will be recast if I move forward from this project - namely those that fit in with what I am trying to do. For example, Return to Tomorrow and The Paradise Syndrome really push some of the elements I am looking at (with Return to Tomorrow being the finale of the five-year mission).

I don't really care who is cast in what role, and I am considering doing this as an audio production as opposed to a written one, so that would make it matter even less.

Rob+
 
I have been entertaining a Reboot idea myself, and have to agree... this isn't a reboot.

In my continuity, Kirk's adventure is set in the late 2800's, and is built on a significantly different history. There is no time travel, Mitchell is Kirk's XO, the ship is much smaller (at most, a crew of 200), it is Earth centric, with Spock being admitted to the crew on a technicality (his human mother). Warp drive works differently, no combat or communication when travelling in Hyperspace, no goofy transporter duplications (you either transport successfully or you die, you don't become happy Kirk and nasty Kirk), no universal translator for unknown languages, the Enterprise and her sister ships comprimise a "Great Grey Fleet" which, publically, is out there 'exploring'. But, unbeknownst to the public and even most of the crew, the ship has a secret mission, to find the thread that unites the many humanioid races of the galaxy.

There have been no Romulan Wars, for they haven't been encountered. A massive war against the Klingons has left Earth and her NATO-esque/G8-esque neighbors in a shambles that they are only now crawling out from under. Weapons of war (the Constitution class) have become vanguards of peace and exploration. Who knows what will be found on the Rim?

Some TOS stories will be recast if I move forward from this project - namely those that fit in with what I am trying to do. For example, Return to Tomorrow and The Paradise Syndrome really push some of the elements I am looking at (with Return to Tomorrow being the finale of the five-year mission).

I don't really care who is cast in what role, and I am considering doing this as an audio production as opposed to a written one, so that would make it matter even less.

Rob+

That sounds very similar to what Admiral2 has done with his Star Trek: My Way series.
 
To the OP, it doesn't really matter who 'plays' your characters. If you want to do it for shits and giggles or whatever, that's fine. The much more important issue is your characters themselves. If they're all exactly the same as they were in TOS, then you haven't 'rebooted' a damned thing. Posting a paragraph on why actors (who will never be in this in the first place) are perfect for the role does nothing to help us understand what about your work is going to be compelling.

That said, though, I wish you luck. Tackling canon characters is a tough thing, and one that I went out of my way to avoid.
 
as a rule a I pay little attention to "reboots"-I prefer original stories although clever reworkings of stories already told(Like that one about the Phoenix getting hijacked that I read recently) are sometimes cool.

ed-it was called The Capture Of the Prometheus by Veers
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top