Better villain: Khan or Vader? ST/SW Quiz...

[holodeckmaster]

A twist on Star Trek vs Star Wars...

It's a survey with 11 questions such as:
1) Who is the best villain?
2) Who is your favorite heroine?
3) Which ship would you rather have?
etc...

Survey here: http://bit.ly/11eZY9

After you click "Submit", you'll see a link to everyone's results.

Discuss.

 

[sbk1234]

That's a fun survey. It's interesting that most of the popular answers were the same as mine. In that case, why aren't I more popular!?

 

[miraclefan]

In my opinion ''KAHHHNNNN''! was the better villian. At least he didn't try and ''REPENT'' for being (in mermaid man voice) EEEVVVVILLL! at the end like VADOR.

 

[donners22]

Vader was certainly a great villain against Mick Foley.


What do you mean it's not that Vader?

 

[holodeckmaster]

I've made the answers visible to everyone: http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pLLKf--MOs-rDJvs4PgIOcQ

You can check out everyone's answers.

 

[KimMH]

In my opinion ''KAHHHNNNN''! was the better villian. At least he didn't try and ''REPENT'' for being (in mermaid man voice) EEEVVVVILLL! at the end like VADOR.

but Vader had to repent - the whole series is the Rehabilitation of Annakin Skywalker. Everything leads to how he got evil and why we want him to repent - he started out so good it defies everything good in the universe for him not to repent.


If you've read Greg Cox's Eugenics War trilogy you get a great look at Khan - he too began his reign of terror in an effort to bring stability and peace to humanity - got a little sidetracked. okay - a LOT sidetracked.

EEEEEVIL Borg Queenie I like to think of being hatched evil and only getting eviler () as time goes on. No repenting here!

A really fun survey - notice many others also chose Jedi mind tricks - would use them on spouse and children and employer and friends and so on . . .

 

[RobertScorpio]

In my opinion ''KAHHHNNNN''! was the better villian. At least he didn't try and ''REPENT'' for being (in mermaid man voice) EEEVVVVILLL! at the end like VADOR.

but Vader had to repent - the whole series is the Rehabilitation of Annakin Skywalker. Everything leads to how he got evil and why we want him to repent - he started out so good it defies everything good in the universe for him not to repent.


If you've read Greg Cox's Eugenics War trilogy you get a great look at Khan - he too began his reign of terror in an effort to bring stability and peace to humanity - got a little sidetracked. okay - a LOT sidetracked.

EEEEEVIL Borg Queenie I like to think of being hatched evil and only getting eviler () as time goes on. No repenting here!

A really fun survey - notice many others also chose Jedi mind tricks - would use them on spouse and children and employer and friends and so on . . .

Glad you mentioned Greg's KHAN series. That guy can write and wow, he wove a great story there. And the book covers are really great too.

I went with Khan. Because am totally convinced that the moment Vader realized Luke was alive, all of his actions were done trying to save his son's life from going down the wrong path....and he was just 'pretending' to be bad...

Rob

 

[Temis the Vorta]

Darth Vader
Princess Leia
Luke Skywalker – the others don’t have magic Jedi powers!
Romulan BOP
Jedi mind tricks
Beaming to planets (holodecks can’t competing with knowing you’re seeing the real thing)
Vulcan
Chewbacca
Death Star
Equally fast
R2-D2

Damn I sound like a semi-disloyal Trekkie now!

 

[Cyke101]

That was a fun quiz, but I'm just glad that Seven of Nine came in second. I didn't think she'd do so well! I would've cheered if she had actually beaten Leia.

 

[USS Renegade]

Kahn vs. Vader? This is a question?