• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best Stargazer Novel(s)?

Odo

Commander
Red Shirt
I'm into the 'Lost Era' Era books (when will we see that Sisko/Tzetchinethi war book....) and was thus interested in Stargazer.

However, I heard the middle books (three, etc) lagged, and was wondering which of those books people considered the best, and which one is considered the best.

Any thoughts?
 
From what I understand, the Tzenkethi war book was just an idea tossed around, not a solid story, a couple of editors ago as one of the projects he was really attached to, but he was then let go from the company, and the idea pretty much died with him.

As for the Stargazer novels, although they can work as standalones, they really work best together, as there's an ongoing narrative. They they take place close enough together to basically serve more like a six or seven (if you want to count The Valiant as a Stargazer novel) part mini-series, as opposed to an ongoing series. I remember certain ongoing plots favorably, but individually, I don't think they really did a whole lot with the setting that couldn't have been done elsewhere. I think for me, each book had an A-plot and a B-plot, as well as touching on the ongoing plots, and either one or the other of the main plots didn't quite work right for me.

I think, though, that the series is short enough that you could easily try the whole thing out - they're short reads, with I think only The Valiant actually hitting over three hundred pages.
 
I suspect the remnants of that Tzenkethi war book idea became the flashbacks in Rough Beasts of Empire.

As for Stargazer, I've read "pilot" for the series, The Valiant, which was good. I've also read the first book in the series proper, Gauntlet, which was very bland and forgettable, except for the big continuity errors - the Stargazer doesn't have a navigational deflector! And it has a HUGE, four-deck-tall shuttlebay at the front, with other huge bays around the saucer rim, not the one tiny cramped shuttlebay described in the book. I felt the uniqueness of the Stargazer itself was totally wasted.
 
I'm pretty sure that the navigational deflector is considered a vital piece of starship design, that every ship needs one, something that deflects the various minute debris in space from striking the ship at warp speeds and punching holes through the hull. So the Stargazer would have to have a navigational deflector, even if there isn't a visibly obvious one on the ship's model.
 
I suspect the remnants of that Tzenkethi war book idea became the flashbacks in Rough Beasts of Empire.
I raised this question with DRG3 when RBoE first came out. He said that he knew no more about whatever the original Sisko-on-the-Okinawa-vs-the-Tzenkethi story might have been than we did - namely rumours and hearsay.

Consequently the appearance of those scenes in RBoE was more a function of being asked to include the Tzenkethi in the book alongside the Romulans, and needing to tie the Romulan story in with the Sisko story.

As for Stargazer, I've only read Reunion (kind of a backdoor pilot via TNG) and the short stories in Tales from the Captain's Table and Tales of the Dominion War. None of them blew up my skirt especially, so I haven't bothered with the rest.

.
 
The two shorts stories were enjoyable (Captain's Table & Tales of the Dominion War), and I remember enjoying the first book, continuity errors aside. I read the second, but never kept going after that. I figure I'll go back one day when I need me some old-school Picard. My favorite story involving Picard and the Stargazer was Christopher's Lost Era novel, The Buried Age. Not a Stargazer novel, but it does involve the ship and the battle of Maxia Zeta near the beginning..
 
None of them are fantastic to be honest. The only one I actually liked enough to reread was Progenitor.
 
The opening of The Buried Age is probably one of my favorite bits of Stargazer material, but Reunion is a lot of fun too.
 
Thanks for all the advice (warnings?)

I'm definitely going to read the Buried Age, and I may give the Valiant or Reunion a shot, whenever I have the time, but I'll probably skip the series proper.

Nice to know the Tzenkethi War is featured in RBoE - I haven't began the Typhoon Pact series yet, but was going to start soon. (Always excited for a DRGIII novel)
 
Typhoon sounds cooler.

Also makes it sound like they made a pact to buy a load of eurofighters.
 
Typhoon sounds cooler.

A typhoon is a mature tropical cyclone in the northwestern Pacific (i.e. a hurricane by its Asian name). Typhon was the father of nearly all the monsters of Greek mythology, and was vast dragon that lived underground and was the cause of all earthquakes and volcanoes. I'd say a humongous volcano dragon/monster daddy sounds cooler than a big rainstorm. (At least for non-literal values of "cool.")
 
There used to be a very detailed Stargazer novel info site maintained by Michael Schuster. I'm not sure if it's still around, though.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top