• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Best Stand-Alone Episodes in Enterprise?

Danoz

Rear Admiral
Rear Admiral
Hey guys! I don't frequent this forum a lot because Enterprise, of all the treks, was my most "fragmented" viewing experience and I've probably only seen half of the episodes (most early season and then several in season four). What are some of your favorite, most powerful/poignant "stand-alone" episodes, as in, not part of some mega-arch (temporal cold war, etc)-- or even your top five "must see" for ENT?

Thanks!

Daniel
 
Observer Effect
Silent Enemy
Shuttlepod One
Vox Sola
Fallen Hero
Bound
The Communicator
Singularity
Carbon Creek
Judgment
First Flight
Cogenitor
Similitude

Those are my favorite off the top of my head. Some are loved around here, some are hated but I enjoy them all the same.
 
Shuttlepod One
Carbon Creek
Minefield
Cogenitor
Judgment
Similitude
Twilight - if that one can be considered a standalone, but in that regard it is not so different from Similitude, is it - both are parts of the Xindi arc, but tell standalone self-contained stories
 
S1
The Andorian Incident
Silent Enemy
Shadows of P'Jem
Shuttlepod One
Vox Sola
Desert Crossing

S2
Dead Stop
Singularity
The Catwalk
Stigma
Cease Fire
Future Tense
Cogenitor
First Flight
The Expanse

S3
Anomaly
Impulse
Twilight
Similitude
Proving Ground
Stratagem

S4
Observer Effect
 
My top five "must see" episodes are....

1.) United
2.) The Forge
3.) In A Mirror, Darkly (both parts)
4.) Babel One
5.) Kir'Shara

Of course, those are all parts of arcs or two-parters.

So, my favorite stand-alone ones are....

1.) The Andorian Incident
2.) Shadows of P'Jem
3.) Carbon Creek
4.) Minefield
5.) Bounty

and....

Precious Cargo

*runs for cover* ;)
 
^ Why would you need to run for cover about "Precious Cargo"? Now if you had said "Terra Nova" I would have gotten out the torch and rang the villagers. :rommie:

My favorite "stand-alone" episodes... in season order...

Unexpected
The Andorian Incident
Shuttlepod One
Minefield
Deadstop
The Catwalk
Regeneration
Similitude
Observer Effect
Bound
In a Mirror Darkly, Parts 1 & 2


Azati Prime and the Vulcan Arc at the beginning of the fourth season are my all time favorites but they are not stand alone episodes. Actually I just loved season four. It was fresh and exciting.
 
Shuttlepod One
Minefield
The Shadows of P'Jem
Desert Crossing
Stratagem
Kir'Shara
In a Mirror Darkly

Not quite a stand-alone, but almost: Carpenter Street. My favorite time-travel ep of them all.
 
^ Why would you need to run for cover about "Precious Cargo"?
Because it's atrocious?

I thought it was supposed to be about the best standalones, not the best episodes? There are quite a few of those mentioned that I would not by any means consider standalones: The Andorian Incident, The Shadows of P'Jem, Cease Fire, Future Tense [the OP specifically said not part of some mega-arch (temporal cold war, etc)], The Anomaly, Impulse, Proving Ground, Kir'Shara (not just a part of the overall Vulcan arc, but also a part of the Vulcan trilogy in season 4)... If those are all standalones, I'm curious to know what is considered a part of an arc?

OTOH, I forgot about In A Mirror, Darkly - this one really is a standalone, although a two-parter.
 
^ Why would you need to run for cover about "Precious Cargo"?
Because it's atrocious?

I thought it was supposed to be about the best standalones, not the best episodes? There are quite a few of those mentioned that I would not by any means consider standalones: The Andorian Incident, The Shadows of P'Jem, Cease Fire, Future Tense [the OP specifically said not part of some mega-arch (temporal cold war, etc)], The Anomaly, Impulse, Proving Ground, Kir'Shara (not just a part of the overall Vulcan arc, but also a part of the Vulcan trilogy in season 4)... If those are all standalones, I'm curious to know what is considered a part of an arc?

Doesn't need to be a complete stand-alone, but I wouldn't want to throw in an episode that's an integral part of a storyline that I know nothing about. For instance, I wouldn't recommend that somebody watch "The Siege of AR-558" for DS9 if they weren't that familiar with the show (despite it being a great episode).
 
^ Why would you need to run for cover about "Precious Cargo"?
Because it's atrocious?

I thought it was supposed to be about the best standalones, not the best episodes? There are quite a few of those mentioned that I would not by any means consider standalones: The Andorian Incident, The Shadows of P'Jem, Cease Fire, Future Tense [the OP specifically said not part of some mega-arch (temporal cold war, etc)], The Anomaly, Impulse, Proving Ground, Kir'Shara (not just a part of the overall Vulcan arc, but also a part of the Vulcan trilogy in season 4)... If those are all standalones, I'm curious to know what is considered a part of an arc?

Doesn't need to be a complete stand-alone, but I wouldn't want to throw in an episode that's an integral part of a storyline that I know nothing about. For instance, I wouldn't recommend that somebody watch "The Siege of AR-558" for DS9 if they weren't that familiar with the show (despite it being a great episode).
None of the above qualify - and I should also cross Similitude and Twilight of my list.

The Andorian Incident can be safely watched, but only because it is a beginning of an arc. The Shadows of P'Jem and Cease Fire are sequels to The Andorian Incident.

Future Tense is a part of the Temporal Cold War arc.

Kir'shara is the conclusion to the Vulcan three-parter in season 4, how anyone could call it a standalone is beyond me.

The Expanse, The Anomaly, Impulse, Proving Ground, Stratagem, Similitude and Twilight are all parts of the Xindi arc. Some of them (like Similitude or Twilight) focus on a self-contained story, but they're impossible to understand without the context of the Xindi arc. Actually, to make this simple: every episode of season 3, plus the season 2 finale, is a part of the Xindi mega-arc.
 
The Andorian Incident can be safely watched, but only because it is a beginning of an arc. The Shadows of P'Jem and Cease Fire are sequels to The Andorian Incident.
I think "standalone" refers to a single episode that can be comprehended as a self-contained story -- i.e., beginning, middle and end, protagonist and opponent, our hero/heroine working toward a goal but running up against obstacles, final climactic confrontation -- without the need to know previously established information that is critical to understanding the plot.

One of the ongoing challenges of a series is to be able to subtly "re-up" the theme and overall goals of the show, as well as provide context for a "follow-up" episode, in order to ground a viewer who may have missed earlier shows. If that context can be established in an early scene or two, with a few key lines of dialogue, then the viewer will likely be able to follow along with the episode. Sure, one will miss nuances and passing references to previous episodes, but hey, that's a reason to watch the entire series. :)

The Expanse, The Anomaly, Impulse, Proving Ground, Stratagem, Similitude and Twilight are all parts of the Xindi arc. Some of them (like Similitude or Twilight) focus on a self-contained story, but they're impossible to understand without the context of the Xindi arc.
Impossible? Not necessarily.

Since "The Expanse" is the episode that sets up the Xindi arc, it can be viewed as a standalone. Key scenes such as the Archer/Trip drinking scene and the T'Pol/Soval scene re-up the ship, the crew, the relationships between the characters.

For the rest of Season 3, one can usually pick up the basics -- we're in an unknown region of space, it's dangerous, we're at war and Earth is depending on our crew -- in the opening minutes, as the episode's plot gets underway. "Similitude" is about Trip being gravely injured and extreme measures being taken to save him. "Impulse" is about being trapped on a derelict ship with a crew that has gone mad. "North Star" is about unexpectedly finding descendents of long-lost humans on a faraway world. "Extinction" is about some of our crew being infected with a unique virus, and becoming targets of another race determined to stamp that virus out at all costs. "Doctors Orders" is about Phlox being left in charge and virtually alone on the ship.

Interesting that many folks consider the two-part "In a Mirror Darkly" to be one episode, but the three-part Vulcan arc to be three episodes...
 
Interesting that many folks consider the two-part "In a Mirror Darkly" to be one episode, but the three-part Vulcan arc to be three episodes...
Well, "Kir'Shara" has been suggested as a standalone, which is the same as suggesting just part 2 of ITMD as a standalone.
 
^ Why would you need to run for cover about "Precious Cargo"?
Because it's atrocious?

I was just trying to be funny.

I actually like Precious Cargo. It's not be favorite, not by a long shot. However, I still liked it.

I was being funny too. :(

As for IAMD being two parts, there are many episodes of Trek that are two parts but are considered one episode. "Dark Frontier" from Voyager and "Way of the Warrior" from DS-9 springs to mind. Either way, IAMD is not to be missed!

And if we are being that rigid about stand alone episodes than most television shows would have very little to offer in the way of "stand alones". Entire series, like Farscape, BSG and Heroes, would have to be left out. In my opinion, if the episode's main story, even if it does further the plot of an arc, can stand on its own I think can and should be included. "Similitude" is a perfect example of this.
 
Last edited:
IMO, an episode is a two-parter if it originally aired in two parts. Therefore, episodes like In a Mirror, Darkly, Part I and In A Mirror, Darkly, Part II are two-parters. Other examples would be Gambit, Part I and Gambit, Part II, as well as In Purgatory's Shadow and By Inferno's Light.

Episodes like Dark Frontier and The Way of the Warrior, however, are one episode. At first they aired as two-hour episodes. They were split apart after they first aired so that they could fit into one hour television timeslots.
 
Twilight - if that one can be considered a standalone, but in that regard it is not so different from Similitude, is it - both are parts of the Xindi arc, but tell standalone self-contained stories

I'm scratching my head trying to figure out what makes it like Similitude. One is about a cloned human who has a distinct set of feelings and personality. The other is about the end of humanity, which in my opinion makes it wildly more interesting.

My favorite stand-alones are:
* Andorian Incident
* Shuttlepod One
* Observer Effect
* Singularity
* Twilight
* The Forge (you don't need to see the rest of the arc)
 
Another vote for Carbon Creek. It was a very charming, human story, and with some nice bits of humor. I think it's one of the all-time best Trek episodes from any series.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top