• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Are "James Bond" Movies Racist?

Are "James Bond" Movies Racist?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1 1.9%
  • No

    Votes: 35 66.0%
  • It Depends on the Film (Again)

    Votes: 17 32.1%

  • Total voters
    53
Bond is sexist, but it is an overall male fantasy, so this is to be expected. The racist aspects of Fleming's novels are carried over to an extent in the portrayal of Asian characters, with the British colonial attitude in the form of Bond coming through. "Live and Let Die" is interesting though when looked at closely. This is one of the few Fleming novels I have not read yet, so I don't know his take on race in the book. The film, as has been pointed out, was made to take advantage of the "blaxploitation" craze in the early '70s, and hoped to get Roger Moore established as Bond. The black villains, including the great Yaphet Kotto as Kananga/Mr. Big, are portrayed as Bond's equals, and get the better of him in a number of situations. The other black characters are portrayed responsibly (unusual for a racist Hollywood, especially at that time), from the CIA agent that rescues Bond in Harlem ("White face in Harlem, Bond? Not a great disguise") to the double agent female. At first I thought "yea, the black chick is the traitor, of course", but many white Bond women have been turncoats, so that's a non issue. The southern white lawmen are portrayed as buffoons and the black characters run roughshod over them. The only problematic issues are the somewhat stereotypical character of "Mr. Big" shown as the "black pimp" persona, and the black villian with the white heroine, that has to be "won back" by the white hero. However, once again, in other instances Bond has stolen the villian's "babe", so this can't really be looked at as a stereotypical action. The "voodoo" implications could also be racist, but once again this is diffused by the fact that the "voodoo" leaders are aware that this is a cover for the criminal operation. I went back and watched this film ready to scream "Hollywood racism" (which would hurt because I'm a big Bond fan), but I really couldn't put that tag on it. It's just another Bond male fantasy, the skin color of the characters notwithstanding.
 
^It's also noteworthy for the time that Bond was depicted as having had sex with a black woman...a Bond first that was frequently referenced in the publicity for A View to a Kill 12 years later.
 
in Live and Let Die (the one most often criticized as racist) M has this to say: "the negro races are just beginning to throw up geniuses in all the professions — scientists, doctors, writers ... They've got plenty of brains and ability and guts."

Not exactly the words of a raving racist, it seems to me.
Hmm, as I suspected, my recollections of the book are pretty spotty, as I don't remember the one above. However, that is a very condescendingly racist statement.
 
I don't think Die Another Day was anti-Korean at all, North Korea really is a totalitarian hellhole that is more a menace to Koreans than Americans, while South Korean soldiers were shown as fighting on the side of the 'good guys'. But then again the Korea, like Japan, has the reputation of having psycho nationalists.
 
Racism and Sexism are in the eye of the beholder. I don't consider the 007 films to be racist or sexist.

I totally agree. I hate when there are 'black' bad guys in a movie or TV show and racism is charged...is it quite possible that there are, duh, bad black guys in the world??? Ummm....yes. Just like there are bad white guys and asians and hispanics...

What would be wrong with a James Bond movie that had nothing but bad black guys in it? NOTHING. How many James Bond movies have only bad white guys???

Rob
Scorpio
 
The only problematic issues are the somewhat stereotypical character of "Mr. Big" shown as the "black pimp" persona, and the black villian with the white heroine, that has to be "won back" by the white hero. However, once again, in other instances Bond has stolen the villian's "babe", so this can't really be looked at as a stereotypical action. The "voodoo" implications could also be racist, but once again this is diffused by the fact that the "voodoo" leaders are aware that this is a cover for the criminal operation. I went back and watched this film ready to scream "Hollywood racism" (which would hurt because I'm a big Bond fan), but I really couldn't put that tag on it. It's just another Bond male fantasy, the skin color of the characters notwithstanding.
Some blacks may have considered it "more racist" had James Bond stolen away a black girlfriend of the main villain, rather than a white one.
 
^True, kind of the same idea in reverse, with the white male being the heroic "superior choice" for the female,white or black. But, like I said, there are a number of stories where Bond gets the villian's girl, so this can be chalked up to storyline, not skin color, or so it would seem. If there are any posters of African heritage on the board, I would be interested in hearing their thoughts on this film.
 
^True, kind of the same idea in reverse, with the white male being the heroic "superior choice" for the female,white or black. But, like I said, there are a number of stories where Bond gets the villian's girl, so this can be chalked up to storyline, not skin color, or so it would seem. If there are any posters of African heritage on the board, I would be interested in hearing their thoughts on this film.

I didn't think a thing about it when ABC first got the rights and showed the movie on TV in 197X. Don't think a thing about it now.
 
^So to you it's just a Bond movie, with no other social implications (other than trying to cash in on the "blaxploitation" craze)?
 
^So to you it's just a Bond movie, with no other social implications (other than trying to cash in on the 'blaxploitation' craze)?

I was to young to see those blaxploitation movies. It was just a movie. I heard of Shaft or Superfly but I only heard the soundtracks to the movie's.
 
Just for the record, I have never seen The Fast and the Furious and 2 Fast 2 Furious. I was at Best Buy last night, came across those 2 films in the DVD aisles, held 'em in my hands, and said "Nah..."
I bought the 2 films on DVD this week.

I plan to watch them tonight and throughout this weekend. :cool:

P.S. - I can't hardly wait until Fast and Furious comes out in 2009, which reunites actor Sung Kang (Han) with director Justin Lin. Also, along for the ride: Paul Walker and Vin Diesel.
:techman:
 
Just for the record, I have never seen The Fast and the Furious and 2 Fast 2 Furious. I was at Best Buy last night, came across those 2 films in the DVD aisles, held 'em in my hands, and said "Nah..."
I bought the 2 films on DVD this week.

I plan to watch them tonight and throughout this weekend. :cool:
So, I have now seen it...

And, all I have to say is that the original The Fast and the Furious portrayal of Johnny Tran (Rick Yune) and his motorcycle gang was blatantly racist, and the videogame Asian American nerd before the first race while all the other white, black, latino guys were grabbing tit and ass throughout the film was downright blatantly discriminatory and offensive, too. Rob Cohen, you did a wonderful job directing Dragon: The Bruce Lee Story which dispelled so many of the racist Asian/Asian American stereotypes in Hollywood, but with this one what were you thinking? :wtf:

Since I've heard that 2 Fast 2 Furious is more of the same, I plan to get rid of that one too after watching it.

Here is hoping that Justin Lin's 4 Fast 4 Furious makes up for them! :cool:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top