• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Americentrism: Except Picard in France....

I know made by Americans for Americans first and foremost but still

That sort of thing goes back to TOS and "Charlie X," where Kirk says "It's Thanksgiving on Earth." Riiight, because that's a global celebration...


Anyway, the fact that Sadie Hawkins dances even became a tradition in the US is a testament to how culturally influential newspaper comic strips such as Li'l Abner used to be.
 
That sort of thing goes back to TOS and "Charlie X," where Kirk says "It's Thanksgiving on Earth." Riiight, because that's a global celebration...
At least TNG also tried every now and then like when Data mentioned Diwali.
Anyway, the fact that Sadie Hawkins dances even became a tradition in the US is a testament to how culturally influential newspaper comic strips such as Li'l Abner used to be.
That is certainly an unusual cultural quirk. Like if we had a James Bond dance or something.
 
That is certainly an unusual cultural quirk. Like if we had a James Bond dance or something.

That doesn't really work as an analogy, since the idea of Sadie Hawkins dances relates to the nature of Sadie Hawkins Day in the comic strip, the inversion of the culture's usual courtship rules so that the girls chase the boys. Having a day where girls can invite boys to a dance is a logical outgrowth of that. In fact, there were events like that before Li'l Abner existed, so the strip didn't introduce the custom, just provided a name for it. A better British analogy would be something like Boxing Day, where employers are expected to do nice things for their workers or servants instead of the reverse.

It's always been the case that popular cultural works have an impact on society. There's an International Sherlock Holmes Day (Doyle's birthday), and British pop culture is surely full of references to Bond, Doctor Who, Eastenders, and so forth. It's just that for a time, newspaper comic strips were as big and influential as TV shows are today. They had songs written about them ("Barney Google, with the goo-goo-googly eyes"), they inspired cultural memes ("Dick Tracy 2-way wrist radio"), and so forth.
 
I've been watching a lot of TNG lately and it was mentioned Starfleet Academy holds an annual Sadie Hawkins dance which I'd never heard of and it turned out to be some bizarre American thing that I think is okay to retcon out. On top of being exclusively a reference for the American audience the idea behind it is a bit outdated.

It was already dying out by the time TNG was on the air. A decade later, I don't think any of the high schools in my county had one (though my girlfriend's did, in a different part of the same metro area).
 
It was already dying out by the time TNG was on the air. A decade later, I don't think any of the high schools in my county had one (though my girlfriend's did, in a different part of the same metro area).
Is that because it had become as normal for girls to ask guys out as the other way round?


dJE
 
That sort of thing goes back to TOS and "Charlie X," where Kirk says "It's Thanksgiving on Earth." Riiight, because that's a global celebration...
Black Friday is becoming a global event, even countries which don't celebrate Thanksgiving or have their Thanksgiving at a different time of the year (like Canada having their Thanksgiving in October) now recognize the Friday after the American Thanksgiving as Black Friday and have huge sales in their stores. With that in mind, it's not that much of a stretch to think American Thanksgiving might someday become worldwide.
 
Maybe the term's meaning has changed (at least at the Academy). Data doesn't elaborate on what made it awkward for him; we're only left to assume it means the same thing it does to us, but what happened for Data there? Nobody asked him to go? Everybody asked him? He wound up caught unwittingly in a love triangle when the girl who asked him had a jealous boyfriend? Some girl asked him as a prank? He disappointed someone by saying no?

  • DATA: I also found social gatherings difficult. There was one event, an Academy tradition, the Sadie Hawkins Dance?
  • WESLEY: They still hold it, every year.
  • DATA: A notably awkward experience.  
  • WESLEY: I know what you mean. I can't even dance.
 
The pronunciation of "transparent aluminum" stands out in this respect.

Not only is Federation Standard the English language. It seems to use the American spelling and pronunciation instead of "aluminium" (al-i-min-yum) which is used by the rest of the English speaking world and IUPAC (the global authority for chemistry standards).

I've mentioned this in the personal head canon thread before .. But I've wondered if maybe Starfleet predates United Earth and was originally an American agency that was absorbed into United Earth when the United States or a successor state of the U.S. became a member.

It would explain Starfleet being based in San Francisco, the "USS" moniker on Starfleet's ships as being a vestige of when Starfleet used USS to designate them as American ships, and why Starfleet mainly uses the customs and traditions of the U.S. Navy. It would also explain an outsized American influence within United Earth which bled over into the Federation.
 
That was Roswell, New Mexico.

Quark's Treasure crashed in Roswell, but they were taken to a military base elsewhere. Denning references the "idiot in Roswell" who leaked the story, which is a phrasing he would not use if he and his listeners were in Roswell themselves. In UFO mythology, Area 51 is where the wreckage of the supposed crashed flying saucer in Roswell was taken for study, and since "Little Green Men" was based on the Roswell myth, it's a reasonable inference that the base in the episode was meant to be Area 51.
 
Maybe the term's meaning has changed (at least at the Academy). Data doesn't elaborate on what made it awkward for him; we're only left to assume it means the same thing it does to us, but what happened for Data there? Nobody asked him to go? Everybody asked him? He wound up caught unwittingly in a love triangle when the girl who asked him had a jealous boyfriend? Some girl asked him as a prank? He disappointed someone by saying no?
The son of the Dancing Doctor can't dance? :lol:
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top