• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

American Horror Story Discussion (Spoilers)

How Would You Grade The Episode?


  • Total voters
    24

Starbreaker

Fleet Admiral
Admiral
447px-American.horror.story.jpg


[yt]http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Dl2g1S6nk20[/yt]

1x01 Pilot
A therapist moves his wife and teenage daughter across the country to escape their troubled past. The Harmon family quickly discovers their new home comes with its own kind of baggage.


Directed by Ryan Murphy
Written by Ryan Murphy & Brad Falchuk

Cast:
Connie Britton as Vivien Harmon
Dylan McDermott as Ben Harmon
Evan Peters as Tate Langdon
Taissa Farmiga as Violet Harmon
Denis O'Hare as Larry
Jessica Lange as Constance
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

Looking forward to this one. The new shows have been pretty meh so far...
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

The television critics I like to read and often agree with (Alan Sepinwall, Daniel Fienberg, Maureen Ryan) have been pretty down on the episodes of this that they've seen, but I can't help but be interested anyway.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

This is on tonight? Geez, I thought we were still months away ... Gotta set the DVR!
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

October is when most of the new sf/f shows are debuting! And The Walking Dead returns as well. Good thing, I'm getting bored of teen vampires...

AHS doesn't have to be very good. I'll settle for sleazy fun.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

The television critics I like to read and often agree with (Alan Sepinwall, Daniel Fienberg, Maureen Ryan) have been pretty down on the episodes of this that they've seen, but I can't help but be interested anyway.

Yeah, the quotes they posted in the ad are pretty out of context. I haven't really seen any critics saying it's good. I think it's going to be a train wreck but that might be fun and since I love horror I'm going to check it out. I have really low expectations, though.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

LA Times review.

Covers some plot points of the premiere, so I just scanned it for the gist. Yes, it's a mess. Whether or not it's an entertaining mess probably depends on how much you like over-the-top insanity. :D
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I am so adding this show to my watch list.


half way through this and I all ready love it. what the show needs for fun is guest Horror writers. I would love to see stephen king do an episode this is so him.
 
Last edited:
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

Being that I am a big fan of horror and the haunted house genre, I thought that it was excellent. I've been waiting for something like this for a long time. Though my wife telling me how hot Dylan McDermott was during his nude scenes got a little annoying.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

It was bad but ambitious. I'll keep watching to see how it turns out.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I'm not sure how I feel about it. I think they had very little subtley when it came to the 'scares'. It felt over the top and not always in a good way. However, I think there's something there with the married couple and their marriage problems, and how that can play into the horror that's to come. I also thought the young version of the maid was pretty hot. I think at times American Horror is trying too hard and at other times not hard enough, from what I could tell from the pilot.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I'm not sure how I feel about it. I think they had very little subtley when it came to the 'scares'. It felt over the top and not always in a good way. However, I think there's something there with the married couple and their marriage problems, and how that can play into the horror that's to come. I also thought the young version of the maid was pretty hot. I think at times American Horror is trying too hard and at other times not hard enough, from what I could tell from the pilot.

I agree with this. The couple should not have resolved their problems so quickly. There was a lot of drama to get out of it but then they brushed over it too quickly and we got the "I'm pregnant!" reveal at the end which was :rolleyes:. Still, like I said above, it's ambitious and I love horror so I want to see where it ends up.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I really enjoyed it. There was a lot going on and it seemed to go by pretty quickly. I'm very interested to see what is going on with the maid. I hope somebody has already posted 25,000 screencaps too. There were lots of subliminal images throughout the whole episode.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I don't know what I just watched. A lot of things "happened" but I'm not so sure what the story actually is.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I don't know what I just watched. A lot of things "happened" but I'm not so sure what the story actually is.

This is pretty much how I felt. Like, it seemed to be a randomly strung together sequence of interesting ideas with not much cohesion. I don't have much hope any of it will really be explained, but I'll probably watch anyways. Because it was still somewhat interesting.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

from my understanding of the pilot:

the original owner of the house was the scared medical doctor who burned and murdered his family. then we have the gay couple who bought the house and ended up dead with murder suicide. and then we have the twins who I believe were the third victims of the house directly.


Now the woman who sold the house to the family is one of the spirts as is the maid and the fucked up kid who is hanging out with the daughter. the neighbors are really fucked up especially the little girl <(who I think is a rip off from the shining.) we all so have the spirt in the black sex gear who was fucking the wife.

now didi I miss any thing and whats not to get. this is going to be simmilar to the shining but more complex.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I don't think the doctor was the original owner. It seems to have been around far longer than him.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

They said the house was built in about 1920 or so by a Doctor. when did Dennis O'hare's (the burnt guy) character live in the house? i am assuming it was sometime right before the Gay couple.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I was watching this with a white friend and she asked me how come there wasn't any black people on this show and I told her black folks would have moved at the first sign of ghosts and the show would have ended.
 
Re: American Horror Story (FX) 1x01 Pilot (Grading/Discussion)

I was watching this with a white friend and she asked me how come there wasn't any black people on this show and I told her black folks would have moved at the first sign of ghosts and the show would have ended.

Co-Sign. I wouldn't have even had that crazy boy over at my house. I would have my office somewhere else. I think one of the things that will try my patience if I continue to watch this show is wonder when the heck they are going to wise up and leave. This series might work better as an anthology opposed to focusing on one family.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top