I think an issue that's still up in the air is how you do CAS in a hot fire zone. High-speed jets are terrible for CAS, since they fly past the hot zone too quickly to be of much use. On the plus side, they don't get shot up much. A-10s are better for the CAS role but, of course, they are going to take fire because it's pretty hard to suppress all ground fire. Apaches are even more vulnerable. F/A-18s are good for CAS in general but A-10 still has the edge against armor.
So, I guess my stance would be: A-10 if facing armor, F/A-18 if you just need CAS and you're not going up against armor.
So, I guess my stance would be: A-10 if facing armor, F/A-18 if you just need CAS and you're not going up against armor.