The Battle. One of the few times the Ferengi actually worked well as villains. Encounter at Farpoint The Naked Now Code of Honor Justice Hide and...
Then Spock's body would have been vaporized in the explosion, seeing how there wouldn't have been the time to safely remove it from the irradiated...
Proving Ground. As strong of an episode as it is, it doesn't quite pack the same punch as the other two. Damage - 1 Proving Ground - 2 United - 0
Did you mean to vote for Minefield? Because if you did, that would actually be the fourth vote for it, and would mean the episode is eliminated.
First Flight is out. Both it and Minefield are pretty good for Season 2, but still on the weaker side compared to the Season 3 and 4 episodes...
Putting the array in the monastery was tempting fate to ridiculous levels, no argument there. But I don’t get the impression Archer would have...
The Andorian Incident. It's a generally solid episode for the most part, but veers sharply downhill in the last five minutes with the ridiculously...
Desert Crossing. Above average for Season 1, weak compared to most of the other stuff here. The Andorian Incident - 0 Desert Crossing - 2...
Very hard decision, but in the end, The Forge and United are both more significant to Enterprise's story arc - and thanks to the production team...
Affliction. This storyline didn’t really need to be two episodes long, and it ends up feeling like two different stories clumsily pasted together....
Borderland. In most aspects it's a decent enough start to the Augments arc, but the Orion slave market eats up nearly half of the episode to...
Daedalus. It feels like a rejected Season 1 script that got hurriedly dusted off and produced for Season 4, suffers from awful pacing, and there's...
Bound. It's hard to even give props for the attempt to subvert the usual image of Orion slave girls when the execution is this abysmal. Storm...
Anomaly. Four very fine episodes still in, but Anomaly is the weakest by the tiniest of margins. The Shipment Proving Ground Damage
The Council. A solid enough episode, but it's one of those that you get every now and again in these long-form story arcs, where the episode...
Exile. There's far worse episodes even in this season, but it just feels very lethargically paced, and it kinda has the feel of a TOS S3 episode....
Extinction. Another example of Enterprise's bizarre obsession with doing vastly inferior remakes of episodes from the previous Trek shows,...
The Breach. Decent main plot, let down by a sub-plot that's... well, not terrible, but doesn't mesh too well with the main plot. Minefield Dead...
The Seventh. Nice attempt to do something a bit different with T'Pol, but the bad guy just feels under-developed, despite Bruce Davison's best...
Vanishing Point. The whole "we're a new Star Trek show, so it's okay for us to rip off past episodes wholesale" argument was already extremely...
Separate names with a comma.