• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Search results for query: * (refine your search)

  1. cgervasi

    Angel one S1E14

    I think that's exactly right where it was still TOS-like, and Riker was like Kirk. At the time, though, I didn't think of it as "TOS-like" because TOS was all there was, and I was thrilled to have new episodes. I was happy the Kirk-like figure was not the captain, to avoid any attempt to...
  2. cgervasi

    Worst tos episode

    In the 90s I used to hear people say, "well that was in the 60s. It was a completely different time." I thought, "Yeah, you can't compared anything modern with that ancient time period." But now I hear the same thing about the 90s being completely different. Many things look the same if...
  3. cgervasi

    Angel one S1E14

    I never thought of it this way. I always wonder why Riker's speech would have swayed them. I think this would have worked better if they had cast distinguished gray-haired slightly overweight old ladies as the ruling council, with men in the service roles consisting of tall muscle-men. I...
  4. cgervasi

    My battle startegy for Wolf 359

    I was always confused in Encounter at Farpoint how they meant for the saucer to escape. They were running away at maximum speed. I believe the main section has a faster maximum speed than the saucer section. They detonated torpedoes to blind the pursuer to the separation. For this strategy...
  5. cgervasi

    People say Insurrection would've made a great TNG 2-parter TV episode. I disagree.

    I never thought about that either. This is probably the movie of which my opinion decreased the most of any movie. I can't believe I saw it two or three times at age 23 and thought it was good. I guess I was jonesing badly for more TNG content. We know the Bak'u had technology that they...
  6. cgervasi

    People say Insurrection would've made a great TNG 2-parter TV episode. I disagree.

    When I saw in the theater I really missed TNG, so I saw it at least twice. I didn't notice the obvious flaws until later. I thought it was a good action episode/movie. When I think about the movie now, I don't understand how no one knew the Son'a were from the Ba'ku were the same. We see...
  7. cgervasi

    Could the OG Enterprise have been recovered and rebuilt at all after ST III?

    I remember reading that when the book was new. It made perfect sense to me. We know anti-matter explosions are huge. It makes sense that they would have have a less catastrophic self-destruct, one that destroys the ship without destroying everything nearby.
  8. cgervasi

    Did Starfleet Command Approve This, Kirk?

    I think it was supposed to be part of his point that his brand of warfare is so horrific that they never actually have to follow through.
  9. cgervasi

    Did Starfleet Command Approve This, Kirk?

    When Anan and Kirk are arguing that humanoids are inherently war-like, Anan shouts "Your general order 24!", suggesting it speaks for itself regarding Kirk's war-like nature. Even though Kirk has control of the Eminian capitol, he doesn't object and say it wasn't real. He calls Scotty and...
  10. cgervasi

    Did Starfleet Command Approve This, Kirk?

    Going there without permission seemed wrong, but Kirk was following orders under protest. Everything else that happened, except his threatening to destroy the entire planet, seemed like self-defense.
  11. cgervasi

    Disaster - Peak TNG

    I think there's a specific protocol in the service for this. I think a chief, like O'Brien, outranks an Ensign. I think a Lieutenant outranks a chief, but the chief often has more experience, so the Lieutenant has to be careful to listen to a chief's advice and give them respect but not let...
  12. cgervasi

    What kind of an impact has TNG had on your life?

    It's hard to imagine what it would be like without it. I was at just the right age. I had seen all the TOS reruns, and I was 12 when TNG began. I still like TNG Season One to this day, an uncommon opinion. I was just eager for new Trek content and at an age where I could accept things that...
  13. cgervasi

    Disaster - Peak TNG

    When I saw it at age 16, it all seemed serious and believable to me... that such accidents were bound to happen in space. I could not believe the plot with Troi being in command. There must be a system of staff officers who have rank because of their experience in a narrow field, like medicine...
  14. cgervasi

    What episode would you want to end season three?

    What about For the World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky? McCoy could have stayed on the generational asteroid ship to administer the treatment they discovered there, to review all the other medical knowledge stored in their archives, and to support the leader in transitioning to a free...
  15. cgervasi

    Episodes you once disliked and now love (or vice versa)

    As a child I thought this line was scary and he delivered it believably. "We mustn't sleep! They come in your dreams! That's the worst! They suffocate in your dreams!" At around age 42 I got obstructive sleep apnea, and in some ways it's more disturbing now. I don't know how I would live with...
  16. cgervasi

    Spock’s Command Decision In Galileo Seven

    I think Spock would have been one of them for these reasons: He sacrificed his life in Star Trek II: tWoK. He said they could lift off when he was trapped by the boulder. He says he's perfectly logical because his experiences growing up on Vulcan, but he later comes to think "logic is the...
  17. cgervasi

    Code Of Honor: What Do You Think?

    My understanding of the Prime Directive is they cannot interfere in another country's affairs. If the society is not aware of other planets, they have to hide that knowledge because that knowledge itself would be interference. If the society does not have warp drive, they cannot give them warp...
  18. cgervasi

    Past Tense - Date of the Episode is Approaching

    "Knowing what happens in that future allows us to change things now, so that some things never happen." - Riker in All Good Things
  19. cgervasi

    Why the hate towards "Rascals"?

    I was annoyed as a teenager by how easily the ship was taken over. I liked to think of the Enterprise-D as powerful and Riker as being good a combat maneuvers. I thought the ship would be nearly totally destroyed before they would surrender, if at all. If I saw it for the first time now...
  20. cgervasi

    Past Tense - Date of the Episode is Approaching

    My point is they take hostages and make demands. Their demands are modest: to stop jailing people who haven't committed any crimes and help them find jobs. That's a good point that Sisko may just be trying to play a role that he doesn't fully believe in so that history is maintained. There is...
Back
Top