Why can't it be both, and how are we supposed to know? Something being funny doesn't automatically mean that we're supposed to disregard it.
I loved the punk. But I was also confused by Guinan not remembering Picard, and I was hardly alone in this. And it was definitely party because...
It's not that we cannot come up with reasons for his behaviour. But it is still crappy storytelling. The intent clearly is to remind us of Spock...
But that would also wipe out the events that lead to restoring the timeline...
It's possible, but let's face it, this is cringey. It's like how in the reboot Trek they offered an 'explanation' to why a doctor was referred to...
I definitely noticed that she's ripped and it looks good. I really hope we see this Guinan putting those muscles in good use and kicking some ass....
I fully agree, and that's exactly to me the context of EW and it's relation to human history is more important, and I don't mind if the exact date...
Sure. But in tWoK, '23rd century' appears in caption and a bottle of Romulan ale bottled in 2283 is mentioned.
But you mentioned all the other contradiction you seemed to be fine with... So this is just crating one more. Why is is any more overwriting...
Right. So then you have no reason to complain if they at some point show EW happening in 2060s.
Right. But you don't care about continuity. Because if nothing can be 'dismissed' regarding continuity, then the continuity cannot exist, because,...
Sure. But wouldn't such a reset of pre April 15th 2024 events also erase the actions of Picard & Co in that era, including them them righting the...
Right. So you don't care about there being a continuity. I get it. But a lot of people care about it.
Continuity implies that some sort of vaguely logical sequence of events and history exists. This means that if there are contradictory elements,...
Right. So you think TOS happens in 2190s. Fair enough. This would mean original cast movies contradict it. And TNG contradicts it even more. If...
So how do you reconcile all the facts I presented? If canon shouldn't be ignored, how does that work? When you think TOS takes place? If it is in...
If you assume that TOS takes place in 2190s, then I guess. :shrug:But if you don't care whether TOS is in continuity with TNG or even with the...
Except all facts about Eugenics Wars already cannot be reconciled. It is canon that: 1) WWIII was in the mid 21st century. 2) Eugenics Wars were...
I have for a long time though that they should just make WWIII and Eugenics Wars the same conflict. There was some information that already imply...
In any case, I actually liked the episode overall. Going from the dystopian future to its origins in our present was pretty powerful, and given...
Separate names with a comma.