Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!
"Disengage" This is a fantastic episode. I'm not sure I have any complaints about it at all.
Et In Arcadia Ego, Part 1" - 0
"Broken Pieces" - 0
"Hide and Seek" - 0
"Mercy" - 1
"Dominion" - 0
"Disengage" - 3
Disengage first up.
It was a part of the excellent third season and needs saving.
Et In Arcadia Ego, Part 1" - 0
"Broken Pieces" - 0
"Hide and Seek" - 0
"Mercy" - 1
"Dominion" - 0
"Disengage" - 2
Mercy secures my first vote. Some great performances all round in this one.
"Et In Arcadia Ego, Part 1" - 0
"Broken Pieces" - 0
"Hide and Seek" - 0
"Mercy" - 1
"Dominion" - 0
"Disengage" - 1
Without question, season 3 is the best season. So which do I vote to save first?
"Disengage" is my first vote.
Worf beheading someone never gets old.
"Et In Arcadia Ego, Part 1" - 0
"Broken Pieces" - 0
"Hide and Seek" - 0
"Mercy" - 0
"Dominion" - 0
"Disengage" - 1
"Dominion" wins season 3.
In fact, the winner and runner up is exactly the same as the 2023 game.
Thank you all for playing! I wilk start the Finals very shortly. Hope to see you all there!
...could have showed up in the last DS9 episode. We could also have got some information about what the Enterprise was doimng during the Dominion War. Strange that no one has written a book about what the Enterprise was doing during the war.
I agree about all that.
It gave me a sort of "Soviet...
"Dominion" was slightly disappointing, in that the prior episode got me so excited for all TNG characters being back on the board, and then in this ep we are again missing Worf, Troi, and (real) Riker. So I'll save "Disengage" for not having that letdown aspect and make "Dominion" the winner...
...were certainly a bit of a nuisance, but at that time conflicts were isolated to the border regions of the two powers. The Borg and the Dominion were decades away. It would be only natural for Picard to hold that kind of conceit about the organization that he served (some might even say that...
...of the big-D is spectacular and fits in so beautifully with canonical references and thought behind the Prime Directive. The Borg takeover is highly effective. Not completely keen on the odd pairing of Dominion and Borg overall, but it doesn't not work...
What's left:
"Disengage"
"Dominion"
Saving "No Win Scenario".
Shaw's Wolf 359 survival story was damn good acting by Todd Stashwick. Haunting and excellent.
Plus, the nebula actually giving birth was such a STAR TREK thing. It was fantastic.
Another directing win for Frakes.
"Disengage"
"Dominion"
"Võx"
Odo did promise reforms, and indeed in Picard S3 we learn that Vadic and her followers left the Dominion in protest of those reforms. Therefore, it's not impossible that in 800 years those reforms have made it so the Jem'Hadar can reproduce naturally, or that the Jem'Hadar might get frisky with...
The founders only offered concessions to "the solids" because they were beaten during the Dominion war. It would be believable that they would splice a klingon/Jem hadar hybrid if the Dominion had become allies with the Federation and Klingon empire since that time.
But they were generally not...
The Next Generation is next.
I just loved seeing Jack Crusher for the first time, and loved the idea that Picard and Bev had a child.
"Disengage"
"No Win Scenario"
"Dominion"
"Surrender"
"Võx"
...going in the turbolift, was well done. Despite the fact Beverly looked really bad when she was explaining why she kept Jack's existence from him, that was still a great scene.
Great tension throughout the episode.
"The Next Generation"
"Disengage"
"No Win Scenario"
"Dominion"
"Surrender"
"Võx"
It's all so incredible! My favorite remaining is "The Bounty." The first ep to have all of the TNG characters back. That cliffhanger with Troi in captivity is such a gut punch!
The Next Generation"
"Disengage"
"Seventeen Seconds"
"No Win Scenario"
"Dominion"
"Surrender"
"Võx"
...Nemesis left a bit pf a osour taste as a TNG finale, bur this was just amazing.
I'll go with Imposters first as it was the suitably tense reintroduction of Michelle Forbes into Trek.
The Next Generation"
"Disengage"
"Seventeen Seconds"
"No Win Scenario"
"The Bounty"
"Dominion"
"Surrender"...
...I will make it a threesome." "Do you ever hear yourself?"), it was an ending that really fully stuck the landing... the only season of either DISCO or PICARD to do this.
"The Next Generation"
"Disengage"
"Seventeen Seconds"
"No Win Scenario"
"Imposters"
"The Bounty"
"Dominion"
"Surrender"...
...threaten your preferred episode's chance to win. Pretty simple. Enjoy!
Hall of Champions (or Failures?)
2023 - "Monsters"
2025 - "Mercy"
Season 3
"The Next Generation"
"Disengage"
"Seventeen Seconds"
"No Win Scenario"
"Imposters"
"The Bounty"
"Dominion"
"Surrender"
"Võx"
"The Last Generation"