Interesting theory about Guinan

Yeah, a theory is a tested explanation of known and observed facts.
A hypothesis is a supposition or proposed explanation made on the basis of limited evidence as a starting point for further investigation.

This is not quite either, and lives closer to the realm of the Wild Mass Guess.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/WMG/StarTrekTheNextGeneration

 

I like the bold font, IT'S EXCITING!

 

So which Time Lord was Martus Mazur?

 

Only because you lack imagination.

 

Q all but confirms her status as The Doctor.

 

Yeah, now you're just making shit up.

In before the lock.

 

I remember the good old days when we would scream "TITS!" in this situation.

TITS!

 

If Star Trek Discovery is TV-MA, TrekBBS should be too!

 

Guinan isn't the Doctor, but she is a Timelord, one who goes by the name the Bartender.

 

James Bond is likelier to be a Time Lord than Guinan. He's had how many faces now? Six? Seven? Obviously regenerates.

So, for that matter, is Neil Degrasse Tyson. (Has a machine that can go anywhere in time and space, is probably a regenerated Carl Sagan who crossed his own timeline, not afraid to pick on a whole planet [Pluto].)

 

Not a planet

(Those who read trek lit will know the Borg answered that question once and for all)

 

I dislike crossover sci-fi in general. In that this is fan-fic crossover just edges it closer to the abyss that is should-never-been-thought-of

 

The Scoundrel.

Guinan could be a Time Lord. For one thing, the lit isn't canon, so you could disregard all of that real quick. (or work it in)

Q outs her as something other than what she appears (more than a bartender and, we learn later, Picard's friend through time), and she takes on a defensive stance against the near-omnipotent.

Maybe her whole story about being an El-Aurian is a cover she took on. Or maybe she was hurt during a regeneration and was taken in by her "father." Maybe she and Q had dealings when she was The 28th Doctor, or in a different form as The Bartender, 50,000 years ago over Orion IV.

 

Trek/Who crossover, not only thought of, it's licensed.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek:_The_Next_Generation/Doctor_Who:_Assimilation2

 

See Not so far fetched after all Nail, meet hammer head.

 

Like in the last episode of Quantum Leap.

 

Sam from Cheers, every famous TV bartender