• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Is there a GOOD reason for an alien invasion

The requisite technology needed to traverse interstellar space is so insanely complex that anyone that masters it would have absolutely no interest in Earth. Period. Terraforming is nothing. Growing organs is nothing. Anything that a civilization does that can't do either of those two things is not militarily threatening.
 
Any race that acts as irrationally as us, or as much against their own interests as we do, will never make it here to invade.

Why not?

Given that our theoretical physicists are discovering or thinking about amazing things all the time, stuff that sounded like hard SF 50 years ago, i don't rule out the breakout discovery of FTL (if it's indeed possible).

There may also be a superpower on their world to pull it off financially and in a few decades they may have a warfleet that Earth can't do much against.

Best bet to me is habitable space.. depending on the biology of the aliens our planet may be to specs and if they are militaristic enough they may chose the war option instead of the Starfleet routine in which case we are pretty much fucked.. until our John Connor is born/comes of age that is :p
 
^Indeed. However, it takes less effort to send one small ship to acquire some DNA and clone/breed/blend what you want, like livestock.
 
perhaps they see what utter crap human civilization is made of so they wipe out established governments and those too fucked up to breed, and force humanity to form a more galactic friendly scociety or die
 
Its been more than a century since HG Wells introduced the world to the modern concept of the alien invasion. Yet, with all the invasion movies, books and TV shows that have come out since, its been rather frustrating that few writers/creators have been able to come up with a credible reason for aliens to actually invade.

The problem seems to be that usually the motivation is based largely on historical precedent in human history. The thing is that the technological hurdles necessary to cross vast interstellar distances, if overcome, would have no precedent in our history.

For instance...

Slaves: In the past, slaves were a perfectly valid reason for invaders from "advanced" civilizations to venture out into someone else's territory seize their lands, and then press some portion of the native population into servitude. After all, those "advanced" civilizations were dependent on large workforces to make their economies and societies function. Civilizations were built thanks to brute strength and access to muscle and man power. However, as has become increasingly obvious in most post industrial societies...the more advanced your technology gets, the fewer people you actually need to do the work. We have not even reached the level of an interstellar civilization and already we have the problem that we have more people than jobs. Who needs slaves when you can build machines to do most of the labor?

Procreation: This is possibly the least likely justification for an alien invasion. The idea that an alien species would turn to another alien species in order to stay viable is simply idiotic. It would be like humans turning to slugs to solve our fertility problems. At least human and slugs have common genetic material.

Water: Its everywhere...why start a costly war over a commonly available material?

Food: This is at least theoretically possible...or is it? I can't travel to certain parts of the world without some common delacacies making me sick. Would an alien with a totally different biology be able to consume ANY biological material from Earth safely?

Minerals: It seems to me that any minerals found on Earth could be just as easily found somewhere else without having to deal with crabby inhabitants that likely would not take kindly to you taking their stuff.

So really...can anyone come up with a good reason for aliens to invade?

I'd have to say Xenophobia. At one time in their past the aliens may have been attacked or exploited by another race, and it's remained a part of their psyche. Now when they come across a technologically developing civilization, they stamp it out in fear.

And while doing so, exploit the resources of the planet. Thus they have become what they fear.
 
I think we need to better define the term "invasion". An alien preemptive attack on Earth, or a desire for our resources does not really need to be an invasion in the classic sense. You drop a few kinetic strikes on Earth(think asteroids of a decent size) wait a few years for the dust to settle, and come down and collect whatever resources you want.

There is no invasion, no ships or troops occupying a human population, nothing like we see in movies or TV.

No, the only reason to justify an alien military style invasion would be to collect the one thing found on Earth which is presumably unique, namely human beings.

The idea of collecting organs or slaves or whatever is sort of silly though. I think by far the best and least used motivation(in science fiction) for an alien invasion would be religious in nature. Something along the lines of our fictional aliens feeling that all sentient beings in the universe must acknowledge their deities.
 
C.E. Evans said:
Humans are incredibly tasty.
^Indeed. However, it takes less effort to send one small ship to acquire some DNA and clone/breed/blend what you want, like livestock.
Nah, it's less than five minutes from Theta Centauri IV at hyperlight. Not much effort at all as Earth is mostly harmless.
 
A few weeks ago I saw this National Geographic special called When Aliens Attack which shows how an actual alien invasion would occur according to experts.

During the program they dispelled the common reasons for invasion (like water since it's so plentiful in the universe) and the one reason they came up with is that aliens would only be interested in stripping Earth of two things scientists here haven't found outside of our world: protein and chlorophyl.

And as the show went on they further speculated that the aliens instead had sent an automated invasion force that was converted all the bio matter into a type of fuel for them. It was a pretty interesting show overall.
 
I think we need to better define the term "invasion". An alien preemptive attack on Earth, or a desire for our resources does not really need to be an invasion in the classic sense. You drop a few kinetic strikes on Earth(think asteroids of a decent size) wait a few years for the dust to settle, and come down and collect whatever resources you want.

There is no invasion, no ships or troops occupying a human population, nothing like we see in movies or TV.

No, the only reason to justify an alien military style invasion would be to collect the one thing found on Earth which is presumably unique, namely human beings.

The idea of collecting organs or slaves or whatever is sort of silly though. I think by far the best and least used motivation(in science fiction) for an alien invasion would be religious in nature. Something along the lines of our fictional aliens feeling that all sentient beings in the universe must acknowledge their deities.
Why human as opposed to squid? Maybe the aliens are looking for the perfect calimari recipe? For drama's sake humans need to be center stage, but in a real invasion it seems more probable that humans are completely incidental to the aliens plans. Apart from biological material what is on the planet that aliens can't get elsewhere in the solar system with less effort from having to deal with uppity alien inhabitants? Unless they simply want to move in and take up living on Earth? I have a hard time imagining a species capable of moving the whole kith and kaboodle between planets being unable to terraform a world to their needs and avoid the annoying natives though.
 
mnw.jpg

flamingjester4fj.gif
 


Hah!

Susan Wright did a series a few years ago in which it was stipulated that Earthlings were in big demand as sex slaves simply because, unlike every other sentient species, we were sexually active all year long and not just during our designated mating periods.

It all makes sense now . . .
 
I suppose the concept of an alien invasion works if Earth is one of the very few habitable planets in the universe. Maybe the only one the aliens know aside from their own homeworld or at least the closest one to the aliens' homeworld (see nuBSG as an example for an universe with very few habitable planets).

In that case, eliminating/subjugating mankind could be more cost-effective than actually Terraforming another world. As an additional incentive, let's say that the aliens' own homeworld is about to become inhabitable itself or something.

(Of course, the aliens would have to breath an oxygen-nitrogen atmosphere as well.)
 
They can always invade to force our leaders to sign a treaty that makes the invasion (somehow) legal, so invaders can accomplish...something...

What about a hyperspace bypass?

I always enjoy intentionally silly/comedic reasons for invasion.

How about for a reality TV show? "Invasion!, the top-rated show on planet Quparte'v! This week the hilarity comes to Earth!"
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top