I am not generally in favor of any sort of weapon, as they do tend to escalate already tense situations. The mere presence of a gun in nonviolent circumstances has been proven to cause people to behave more aggressively. When I first read about the anti-rape condom my initial concerns were whether or not it would indeed only exacerbate the violence of the crime, and ultimately be worse for the victim, a possibility others have pointed out. I simply do not know enough about the device, and its consequences in real life to make up my mind as yet as to whether or not I think it is a good thing. My protests earlier were not against people questioning the device from that standpoint, but the silly remarks about it potentially making little Lorena Bobbits out of bitter housewives throughout the Western world. That implies a severe lack of perspective, as I already stated.
My perspective is just fine. It's not a lack of perspective, it's a look at multiple perspectives. Personally, I don't care one jot for the rapist. He gets what he deserves with this device. I don't want you to doubt that for one second.
Then there was raised the issue of male rape, which, of course, does happen and is just as awful as the rape of a woman. It is also irrelevant to this issue. We are not talking about male rape, we are talking about female rape. But since you brought up the subject, let's again try to put things into perspective: How often do you men actually fear being raped? Does the thought, "I shouldn't go there/be here because I might be raped" occur to you once every few months? Once every few weeks? Every night?
How often are you sexually assaulted, verbally or physically? Once a month? Once a week? Several times a day? Because I am verbally sexually harassed every day, as are many if not most young women in NYC. Physical harassment, as in having any part of my body grabbed (including my hair, my neck, my breasts, my buttocks, and, less intrusively but just as unwanted, my arms and legs), it averages out to about once a year. This is typical.
No, I do not think that going into most situations. This is because I am not treated the same way. If I were in a situation where most of the people were women and they treated me as these men treat you, then
yes, I would be concerned, scared on a basic level, that I was not safe. I don't pretend for two seconds that all women are frail, funny little things, quite the contrary, women can be just like their male counterparts; smart, manipulative, cunniving and forceful when they want to be, and what some may lack in musculature is more than made up on the intellectual/emotional front.
It disgusts me that there are such men that treat you and nearly every other woman as they do, not because you are weak or because you're some kind of helpless animal, but because it is simply wrong to violate someone's personal space, their privacy, their personhood, in such a way.
Again, I do not intend to downplay the sexual assault of men and male rape. Men do get raped, and, rarely, they get raped by women. However, I think, again, some perspective is required. Let's return to the country where this device was developed -- the threat of rape to women there is constant. Almost half the male population are repeat rapists. I'm sorry, but one really cannot compare the necessity of protection against rape for a woman in that environment to that of a man anywhere in the world (except maybe prison). I hate to say it again, but to do so shows a severe lack of perspective or understanding of reality.
I understand your concern. I have taken into account the ghastly social environment the women of South Africa must endure because of this rampant and destructive violation of their human rights. My comments were not geared specifically toward those women (something I clarified much earlier in this thread). Neither are my comments snide, selfish or lacking in perspective. The idea that I don't really care for the horrific acts committed against women (in all nations) in this day and age is preposterous.
What I did was show unease at the nature of this device, something most males are likely to do. Granted, as
iguana points out most men aren't likely to voice it here, but I did, and I do. Not out of some sense of callous machismo. Believe me, machismo doesn't really describe my personality in any appreciable way.
I am concerned over the device itself and what it may create. While it may work, it also has so many flaws, and while it may be a last resort, it may make the situation even worse. I look out for the well-being of
all innocent people, men and women. This is a panic device. It is not a well thought out device, but one made in a frenzy of panic and chaos, and yes, these women need protected, god knows that, but it needs to be done in the best way possible.
Unfortunately, aside from being there to personally fend off every disgusting degenerate who would even dare to rape someone (and if I could, I would), I have no better ideas yet that would be as readily available.
Mace? Sometimes it just makes them angrier.
Gun? Sure, but how much time does a woman have to draw the gun, fire and run away before her assailant is on her?
Tazer? A tazer can work, but you have to be experienced in using one properly, and it wouldn't be as readily available for the women most affected in Africa.
I also wonder, if there was a mention in the overall statistical data, whether the rapists were alone or accompanied by others, as in a gang. Rape gangs are not uncommon, and in such a situation, this device would be nearly ineffective. Of course, in a situation like this, most defense tools would be ineffective.
There has to be a sociological change. Those who commit rape need to face severe penalties, and I don't just mean jail time. Anyone who would rape another person is sick, they're a danger to everyone around them.
tsq, I'm always going to be straightforward and level with you. If I'm raising these issues, it's because I do feel they're serious enough to discuss, and you're not going to get snide comments from me. This issue is deathly serious, for everyone involved. Thousands of women (and men) are raped every day, and it destroys lives, in some cases quite literally. I understand this. This is no laughing matter. It's not a joke. I am not making some kind of funny remark to elicit laughter from simpletons in an effort to score points of any kind. I am serious.