• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What are your controversial Star Trek opinions?

Didn't they invent the "Operations Manager" title for Data because they thought that an emotionless science officer was a bit on the nose?
Operations Officer is a real position in the US military, but we never see Data doing it. Perhaps he is managing the computer resources of the ship, which basically makes him an operating system kernel.
 
Operations Officer is a real position in the US military, but we never see Data doing it. Perhaps he is managing the computer resources of the ship, which basically makes him an operating system kernel.
I'd argue he's more like a Process/Thread Director than the OS Kernel.

That's more of a very specific task that the Ships Computer/OS already does.

Data doesn't need to waste CPU Cycles focusing on that grunt level OS work.
 
Leland T. Lynch should have been permanent Chief Engineer, just so he could have bizarrely stated his full name in communication more times in the series.

He’s hilarious. What’s with that?

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

He only appears in Skin of Evil and only gets a few scenes but for some bizarre reason responds to Picard over the comms by announcing his full name. He does it twice I think.

Who was the asshole from “Arsenal of Freedom” who tried to take command from LaForge? I always thought it was Lynch.
 
Isn’t average lifespan a little deceptive, because infant mortality was so much higher? If you made it to adulthood, you had a decent chance of living to old age.

IIRC life expectancy went down during the Industrial Revolution, as people had poorer diets and disease thrived in crammed urban conditions, until modern medicine and scientific understanding improved in the late-19th and into the 20th century.
Yes. Sewers started being put in to cities in the 19th century which helped a lot bringing down the rate of cholera and typhoid.
 
Leland T. Lynch should have been permanent Chief Engineer, just so he could have bizarrely stated his full name in communication more times in the series.

He’s hilarious. What’s with that?

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

He only appears in Skin of Evil and only gets a few scenes but for some bizarre reason responds to Picard over the comms by announcing his full name. He does it twice I think.
Total speculation, but maybe the actor really wanted to make an impression and get called back, so he ad libbed it? Or the writers likewise wanted to create a regular, but it didn’t pan out? It does otherwise seem an odd emphasis.
 
Total speculation, but maybe the actor really wanted to make an impression and get called back, so he ad libbed it? Or the writers likewise wanted to create a regular, but it didn’t pan out? It does otherwise seem an odd emphasis.
I doubt an ad-lib would have been tolerated, especially when it's his entire character.

They were just auditioning various engineers during that season, but no one stuck.

The old story (which is probably apocryphal) is that Biff Yeager tried to get a fan campaign to make Argyle the permanent engineer going at a convention. The producers did not appreciate an actor lobbying in that way, and he was never asked back as a result.
 
They didn't even have a chief engineer in the main cast in season 1. They clearly did not anticipate how important technobabble would become to the show in future years.
The early concept of TNG was "technology unchained": the ship would be so powerful and intelligent that it would run itself with minimal intervention from the crew.

The early bridge sketches are basically a conference lounge.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top