• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

What tropes in science fiction annoy you?

Yeah, that was at the end of one of the first episodes.
If only people in the era the show was made had that much forethought....

What was odd was the island had so many visitors, even I think astronauts that nobody ever told the authorities where they were.
I've been watching it on MeTV a lot lately and I do get a kick out of all of the different excuses that came up with for why the people who left the island were never able to get them rescued.
I also feel kind of bad for Gilligan, because he was constantly telling the others about stuff he saw or that happened to him, and the other never believe him, even though he was always right.
 
Projectrho is the best sf-oriented site on the Internet.

Things space isn’t: Space is not an ocean, is not two-dimensional, has no substance or friction, is nearly impossible to hide in, and is dead silent. Some shows or movies tend to try to make space seem like something more familiar, like the air planes fly in or the ocean boats and submarines travel through. This is done because the average person understands that easier without needed explanation. Thing is though, why bother setting a story in space if you aren’t going to even do space like it really is? I look at shows where space ships treat it like a large ocean and only movie forward, back, and left or right and am left thinking not only is that not how it is, but if that is what they wanted why not set the story on some ocean and use a fictional world if they didn’t want an Earth story? Also a lot of stories show space ships running their engines constantly, which is based on how aircraft need to do that to keep moving. In space it is really different due to the lack of friction, which comes from no atmosphere or any sort of medium. The same is why you can’t really hide in space, even if you can’t be visually seen, you give off heat, and in the cold black of space, any heat source sticks out if you look at it the right way (an if you were there, you would be looking that way). Also the biggest one is that there is no sound because of the lack of atmosphere or any other medium. Sound exists due to vibrations in matter like air or even water, but with nothing, you hear nothing.

Things space ships are not: They are not boats, nor fighter planes, and they can move in any orientation due to not needing to be aerodynamic or constantly running their engines. At its simplest and most realistic, what space ships are best described as are rockets. Today we think of rockets as long tall pointy things we shoot up into space but at some point we make a disconnection between that vehicle and what ends up there. As long as it has some sort of functioning engine that expels mass to accelerate though, it is always a rocket, it just doesn’t need to be straight and pointy in a vacuum anymore.

Things about space ships you might not know include: They can have wings, but they aren’t wings like airplanes which are useless in a vacuum. They are actually heat radiators which are needed since in a vacuum it is a lot harder to expel waste heat and any power source on a ship makes a lot of heat, even people. Radiators actually add fun drama to space battles since they are huge weak points too. Space ships shouldn’t have windows because windows are structurally unsafe and overall unnecessary. There isn’t really much to see, and a good camera and TV screen can give you all the visual data you need. Talk about transparent metals to use for this is just an excuse for having a nice visual (though not a horrible excuse really). Space battles between ships will also be nothing like ships battling on the ocean or submarines under the sea for the same reasons space itself is not an ocean as stated above. Realistic space combat is tricky and all hypothetical since it has never actually happened but with science we have a good idea of how it would likely go down. Atomic Rockets has a lot of pages covering that, once you get it, it is pretty entertaining to think about.
 
I may have already mentioned this during this 7-year thread, but I was talking to my wife about it recently: the gag of showing a character is an alien by having their eyes flash a glowing color on cue. It's gotten to be quite a tiresome cliche. It also seems biologically unlikely :).
 
What would be preferable? A reptilian tongue catching a bug in midair? Passing through a scanner which shows anatomy in the wrong place (not that there aren't Humans who have this problem)? Getting injured and bleeding the wrong color?
 
Here's another trope that annoys the :censored: out of me:

(some examples would be Independence Day, The Arrival, The 5th Wave, and their various ilk)

Aliens come to Earth, proceed to lay waste to the planet, then justify it by pointing out that humans are ruining the environment and that gives the aliens the right to destroy the planet.

Fuck you, you alien piece of shit! It's none of your fucking BUSINESS how we handle the environment! It's our planet and we can do whatever the hell we want!
 
Last edited:
You made me think of this.


yax9y2Vc6TGaX4znfgFu214ZeUnGGGltEGcmdgYuprs.jpg
 
Here's another trope that annoys the :censored: out of me:

(some examples would be Independence Day, The Arrival, The 5th Wave, and their various ilk)

Aliens come to Earth, proceed to lay waste to the planet, then justify it by pointing out that humans are ruining the environment and that gives the aliens the right to destroy the planet.

Fuck you, you alien piece of shit! It's none of your fucking BUSINESS how we handle the environment! :rolleyes:

Well in Independence Day the aliens wanted to invade just because they can. They wanted Earth
 
I may have already mentioned this during this 7-year thread, but I was talking to my wife about it recently: the gag of showing a character is an alien by having their eyes flash a glowing color on cue. It's gotten to be quite a tiresome cliche. It also seems biologically unlikely :).
Or showing they’ve been possessed by an aliens by having their eyes turn completely black, without any reason or mechanism given for that actually happening.
 
I don't know how long this trope has been going on, but I've felt like I've seen much more of it as of late, and it's the one where the sibling ends up being hooked up to a mainframe by either keeping the lights on, or becoming its brain, and trying to remove them most of the time ends up killing them. It's what happens in The Creator and in The Electric State.
 
I don't know how long this trope has been going on, but I've felt like I've seen much more of it as of late, and it's the one where the sibling ends up being hooked up to a mainframe by either keeping the lights on, or becoming its brain, and trying to remove them most of the time ends up killing them. It's what happens in The Creator and in The Electric State.
Brain and brain! What is brain? It is controller, is it not? :lol:
 
The trope I'm weary of most is "a long lost love of youth reappears as the cause of or solution to the A or B story". Ugh. Seeing that makes me change the channel.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top