The engine room was clearly defined..It was probably hard for Discovery to have a clearly defined chief engineer without having a clearly defined engine room.![]()
The engine room was clearly defined..It was probably hard for Discovery to have a clearly defined chief engineer without having a clearly defined engine room.![]()
To my memory, we never actually saw Main Engineering. What we saw throughout the series was an engineering lab, or something to that effect.The engine room was clearly defined..
Never. Culber definitively states he was not CMO in the first season, although the show always treated him like he was anyway. Wilson Cruz was asked about this in an interview done last year to promote the finale, but he just laughed and evaded the question.Did they ever actually say he was CMO?
He's their preferred medical provider.Never. Culber definitively states he was not CMO in the first season, although the show always treated him like he was anyway. Wilson Cruz was asked about this in an interview done last year to promote the finale, but he just laughed and evaded the question.
Beats a Holographic Maintenance Organization.
That's a great analogyI disagree.
And the reason why is because I think Picard season 3 is different in that the serialized Borg-Changeling stuff is not what that season is really about. The reunion of the old cast IS the point of season 3. The Borg-Changeling conspiracy is only the means to the end of forcing the cast back together. It's about them realizing what they've lost and the worth of their relationship together. Season 3 is composed of multiple character arcs for each of the TNG characters that's incidental to the main serialized story. (e.g., Riker realizing he's been hiding from his trauma, Riker and Troi realizing how their son's death has affected them, bringing back Data in a different way, etc.)
To me, Picard season 3 is thematically similar to Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home and all of the complaints about the Borg matter just as much as the gaps left in the movie. That movie is not about cylindrical alien probes or humpback whales. That's only the macguffin that allows the story to explores Spock's reacclimation with his friends and humanity, as well as showing how the crew of the original Enterprise are more than friends. They're a family that stands together, both in saving the world, and defending each other.
At the end of that movie, we don't know who sent the probe. We don't know why the probe wanted to talk with humpback whales. Hell, we don't even know what George and Gracie said to the probe to get it to stop. And it doesn't matter. Because that's not what the movie is about. It's about building towards the crew on the bridge of the Enterprise-A and feeling like all is right in the universe because these people deserve to be there together.
The Borg-Changeling plot serves the same purpose as the probe in Voyage Home. It's the event that spurs these characters to come together for a singular purpose, through which we see different ways in which they've changed, and it builds to them standing on the bridge of their old home realizing their old roles and what each of them mean to each other.
And the main difference between Picard season 3 and Discovery is that you can point to multiple character arcs that occur in that season beyond just Picard. Pick a season of Discovery where a character beyond Michael has a satisfying character arc, where you feel like they've grown and went to a recognizably different place than where they started and changed. There's not that much to choose from.
He's also in network.He's their preferred medical provider.
Was it? I recall Engineering Test Bay Alpha, which is where Stamets did his work.The engine room was clearly defined..
He's also in network.
The mycileal network.
Does nobody remember Dr Pollard? In 16 episodes, literally a third of the series run, beginning in the first season? She's never specifically called CMO, but Culber always deferred to her.He's their preferred medical provider.
Joke, I believe. The network is the medical professionals available through your insurance.I thought only staments used the network for the spore drive ?
Yet another sign of how wallpapery many of Discovery's recurring characters were.Does nobody remember Dr Pollard?
One, it's a joke.I thought only staments used the network for the spore drive ?
I didn't like the penchant in Picard for bringing back legacy characters just to kill them off. Often in unpleasant and horrific ways. Bruce Maddox, Icheb, Hugh, Q, Ro Laren, Shelby.Thanks for the honest response.
The thing that gets me is seeing folks label S3 as “it’s TNG S8”, which is absolutely bizarre. If that is ONLY because we go cast reunion and that the D appeared in two episodes, ok I guess? But S3 is very much in line with the first two seasons tonally, aesthetically, structurally. All the problems that plagued the first two seasons are still very present.
But just the fact that the show in its last two episodes bothered to feature a reunion of an old cast and the D, seemed to be enough for some to hand wave everything else that normally would have pissed them off.
I wasn’t really one of those fans that got upset over Icheb’s death because I never cared for him and frankly always resented his presence in VOY. However, I thought they did Shelby dirty in S3, but was surprised to not see much outrage over her treatment by those who screamed about the first two seasons. I guess the reunion was really enough!
Does nobody remember Dr Pollard? In 16 episodes, literally a third series run, beginning in the first season? She's never specifically called CMO, but Culber always deferred to her.
![]()
Tracy Pollard
Doctor Tracy Pollard was a female Human Starfleet officer in the 23rd century and later in the 32nd century. She was assigned to the USS Discovery in the 2250s as a physician. After Lieutenant Ash Tyler was revealed as the Klingon Voq, she was assigned his case. Pollard was present and...memory-alpha.fandom.com
I gotta movie for you. Muted color and "no lighting"
![]()
And crying
![]()
The SNW shuttlebay is massively oversized, as is engineering which they admit on their own internal layouts for the show.SNW has fixed this situation by bumping the size up to a respectable 442m. A size that solves most issues and even matches a MSD of a Constitution Class that was shown in "In A Mirror Darkly" that depicted a ship of over 400m in length.
The SNW shuttlebay is massively oversized, as is engineering which they admit on their own internal layouts for the show.
Gotta accept it's a fantasy ship, that no tv/film sets in any show really fit where they're supposed to and will sprout whatever sized rooms an episode needs![]()
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.