• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Star Trek enters the public domain in 2062. Will you be publishing your fanfic?

Extrocomp

Fleet Captain
Fleet Captain
Pride and Prejudice, Sherlock Holmes and Dracula are all in the public domain, so anyone can self-publish their fanfics on Amazon.com as ebooks or print-on-demand paperbacks. There are thousands of them.

When Star Trek enters the public domain in 2062, are you going to publish your fanfic to earn some money and give your story a more official status?

Obviously not all fanfics can be published in this year. Klingons will only become public domain in 2063 and TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT will take many more decades to enter the public domain. And you can't have the words "Star Trek" on the cover because that title is trademarked and trademarks never expire.
 
Last edited:
Obviously not all fanfics can be published in this year. Klingons will only become public domain in 2063 and TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT will take many more decades to enter the public domain. And you can't have the words "Star Trek" on the cover because that title is trademarked and trademarks never expire.
That's the rub, isn't it?

Assuming Star Trek is a going concern, it's likely that Paramount will be as vigorous as the Doyle estate was in asserting the broadest possible interpretation of which ideas and elements came from episodes, movies, and so on that are still under copyright. "Yes, while 'Errand of Mercy' is public domain, your smooth-headed Klingons behave in a way consistent with understanding the concept of 'honor,' something not established until 1984's Star Trek III: The Search for Spock, which will remain under copyright until 2080. Money, please." And "the concept of 'honor'" will be, like, your Klingons didn't lie or betray each other in every single line of every single scene.
 
My father and grandfather lived 80 years. Both were married (a life extender), and both took better care of themselves than me. I figure I'll last 75. To take advantage of that, I'd have to live for 92.
 
This idea was briefly discussed in another thread in February.

Copyright expiration for tv shows is something nobody's really worked out yet: If you have public domain calculated from publication date then it's as David cgc mentioned regarding Sherlock Holmes, but at least the dates are regular and predictable. If you tie it to the author's lifetime then you get the whole corpus at once, but in a franchise with multiple different authors both overall and for individual installments you end up needing to keep track of dozens of different death dates and then risk different parts of the series entering the public domain in a random order.
 
Last edited:
Forgive my ignorance of copyright and public domain, but couldn't the people who own the copyright in 2061 just renegotiate the copyright?
I'm sure Disney would've stopped Mickey Mouse from entering the public domain in 2024 if they could, but they weren't able to do so.
 
I doubt any Star Trek will enter public domain while CBS still owns copyright to it. As long as the network (or any successor) is a going concern, the copyright is still active. All writers, authors, etc worked under license and don't own any part of Star Trek. It's a cash cow and they won't let it lapse.

The only reason Mickey's copyright lapsed is solely because it's really Steamboat Willie, not Mickey Mouse as we know him. Walt Disney didn't understand copyright law and neither did his lawyers, or they'd have done better. CBS lawyers understand copyright much better, and the laws have changed over the years.

Keep writing your fanfic.
 
I doubt any Star Trek will enter public domain while CBS still owns copyright to it. As long as the network (or any successor) is a going concern, the copyright is still active. All writers, authors, etc worked under license and don't own any part of Star Trek. It's a cash cow and they won't let it lapse.

The only reason Mickey's copyright lapsed is solely because it's really Steamboat Willie, not Mickey Mouse as we know him. Walt Disney didn't understand copyright law and neither did his lawyers, or they'd have done better. CBS lawyers understand copyright much better, and the laws have changed over the years.

Keep writing your fanfic.

There is no way to “extend” a copyright” beyond the fixed number specified in the U.S. Copyright Act, regardless of how crafty the attorney is. No amount of savvy corporate maneuvering can get around that, as Disney found recently. The only way – the only way – to extend the duration of an existing copyright is for the U.S. Congress to amend the Copyright Act to change the duration set forth in the statute. This has actually been done several times in the past,(1976, 1998) – usually a result of Disney‘s extensive lobbying (this is why both the 1976 Copyright Act and the 1998 Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act are variously referred to as “the Disney laws” or “the Mickey Mouse Protection Act“ because both of them resulted largely from Disney's efforts to keep Steamboat Willie from going into the public domain, which was imminent in 1976 and 1998 under the then-current version of the statute). So, no, Steamboat Will went into the public domain despite Disney's best efforts over decades of lobbying, not because "Walt Disney didn't understand copyright law and neither did his lawyers,"

Are further revisions to the statute to extend the term of copyright possible between now and 2062? Anything is possible. But the problem we run against is that the US Copyright Act is subject to the Copyright Clause of the US Constitution (Article I, Section 8, Clause 8), which permits Congress to grant copyright only for a “limited time" (on the rationale that the copyright owner should not hold a monopoly forever, and the trade-off for giving the copyright owner a time-limited monopoly is that eventually he or she must relinquish it to the public domain). Given that until 1976, copyright duration was limited to 28 years (with one permitted 28 year extension) and now it is 95 years (in the case of corporations) and "lifetime of the author PLUS 70 more years" (for individuals), there has been a lot of resistance to further extending the duration of copyright because Congress has already stretched a "limited" time to its breaking point and further extensions may be unconstitutional. This is why we didn’t see Congressional movement to protect Steamboat Willie one last time in the 2020s before it went into the public domain.

Source – me, U.S. intellectual property lawyer practicing since 1998

Mike
 
Last edited:
When Star Trek enters the public domain in 2062, are going to publish your fanfic to earn some money and give your story a more official status?
I probably will, but I might wait till stuff like TNG becomes public domain.
Obviously not all fanfics can be published in this year. Klingons will only become public domain in 2063 and TNG, DS9, VOY and ENT will take many more decades to enter the public domain.
I’ll be in my 50’s in 2062, and in 2087 I’ll be approaching 80. So all I can do is wait and hope I’m still alive for that…
 
You can't extend a copyright, but Star Trek isn't a copyright, it's a trademark. And those don't expire.

In fact, family members of the famous child care specialist and psychologist, Dr. Spock, have run into trouble using their own family name because the name Spock is trademarked. Even though Dr. Spock published his famous book in the 50's, long before the vulcan character of the same name appeared on television.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top