• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Star Trek: Picard 3x03 - "Seventeen Seconds"

Engage!


  • Total voters
    264
Here’s a question: Where did Jack’s vision come from? Is he hallucinating because of the gas or because he inherited Picard’s brain abnormality or did he inherit something from Beverly that makes him as attractive to beings like the good Changelings in the Great Link as his half-brother Wesley was to the Traveler? My guess is that the good faction in the Great Link is trying to communicate and stop the terrorists, so Jack hears “Find me” and “Connect the branches.” They never did explain completely just why Wesley was supposedly so special but his mother and great grandmother and generations of Howards were all highly attractive to the shape changing entity who took up residence in that candle. It’s probably in the Howard genes and Jack inherited as much DNA from Beverly as he did from Jean-Luc.
 
So the Federation doesn't want to admit that Changelings are responsible for the attacks to avoid reigniting the Dominion conflict so are happy to blame T'Luco

The breakaway changelings do want to restart the war.

So why did Rikka pay Sneed to frame T'Luco?
Misdirection?
 
Why are the Titan’s shields the old 23rd design with them being close to the ship? It should be a bubble.
 
In the 24th century, you might trust a patient to self administer a drug, but for sure you are going to have a computerized way to monitor when and how much is injected. Your hypo is going to tell your doctor if you miss a dose or take too much, and a nurse is going to immediately follow up to tell you to take your injection. And if you still don't administer it, they'll bug you more. And that's assuming they wouldn't just implant a tiny slow-release dispenser in your abdomen to begin with. There should be no excuse for medication compliance falling through the cracks by this point in time.
Too Orwellian nanny state...and for birth control, no less, which by its nature is strictly optional.
 
Here’s a question: Where did Jack’s vision come from? Is he hallucinating because of the gas or because he inherited Picard’s brain abnormality or did he inherit something from Beverly that makes him as attractive to beings like the good Changelings in the Great Link as his half-brother Wesley was to the Traveler? My guess is that the good faction in the Great Link is trying to communicate and stop the terrorists, so Jack hears “Find me” and “Connect the branches.” They never did explain completely just why Wesley was supposedly so special but his mother and great grandmother and generations of Howards were all highly attractive to the shape changing entity who took up residence in that candle. It’s probably in the Howard genes and Jack inherited as much DNA from Beverly as he did from Jean-Luc.

The most common theory is it's the intelligence they are trapped in - see also the conversation with the science officer earlier in the episode.
 
Too Orwellian nanny state...and for birth control, no less, which by its nature is strictly optional.

I disagree. It's not as though the medical personnel are forcing the medications on a person. They are merely carefully monitoring the administration of medications that presumably were prescribed with the consent of the patient. That is a good thing. It means granny can't forget her heart medicine and die, and it should mean you can't forget your birth control and accidentally get pregnant. Presumably, if you want to go off a medication, you just chat with the doctor. But if you have an existing plan to take a medication and are not taking it as prescribed, they should intervene to determine if there is a problem and to come up with a better solution. That can only help patients.
 
So, does Beverly know it's Changelings who are after them? It would explain why she blew that one to ashes in the first episode.

And the powdery remains Riker was holding and studying do sort of resemble the remains of a dead Founder, just less charcoal in color.
 
I was thinking that if someone made a drama film set in the present day, where a healthy and intelligent mature woman who is a renowned professional in the field of medicine and has already had a child, is totally AMAZED and FLABBERGASTED that she got pregnant after consensual and unprotected sex, I think critics would say, "But whoever made the movie thinks women are stupid?".

And really, I can't even remember a recent movie with a similar plot which isn't a comedy (like Knocked Up)
 
I find it highly amusing about the whinging of Speelers age as if it matters, or hasn't been done many many times in other shows.

Including Star Trek: Voyager where Kate Mulgrew actually played an older woman. Mulgrew was 39 when she started playing as Janeway. When Janeway's casting notes put her in her mid 40s. I beleive Janeway is 5 years older than Mulgrew is in real life.

Or Aaron Eisenberg. He was 26 when he was cast to play someone ten/eleven years younger than him in Nog for Deep Space 9. Where were your screams then? Your chagrins and wailing "HES TOO OLD"?

So, what? it's fine when it's a woman? Is that what we're going with here? It's fine when it's someone with only one functional kidney limiting their height?

Just so I know the criteria.
 
Including Star Trek: Voyager where Kate Mulgrew actually played an older woman. Mulgrew was 39 when she started playing as Janeway. When Janeway's casting notes put her in her mid 40s. I beleive Janeway is 5 years older than Mulgrew is in real life.
.
Actually, Janeway's age has never been locked down in on-screen canon other than a birth year of 2344 (in 'Killing Game'), which would've made her an absurdly young 27 as of her assuming command of Voyager and all of 12 years old when Tuvok criticized her in front of 3 starfleet admirals in 2356 (even Kelvin Chekov, assuming he had a 4 year Academy education, would've been 13 when he became a cadet).

Needless to say this year has basically been ignored but it hasn't been contradicted on screen either as far as I know...
 
Thomas Dekker looks great as a heroin addict..

That was because of

Rikka suffering from 'Great Link withdrawal', wasn't it?

Speaking of which, the rogue Changeling faction must have a Link of its own, otherwise they'd all be suffering from withdrawal.

And assuming Vadic's crew are also Changelings, why do they have to wear masks like that? Why don't they just use their shapechanging abilities?

Ask your doctor if it's right for you.

"For Moderate to Severe shield impacts..." :lol:
 
So, what? it's fine when it's a woman?
It's only fine if the woman in question is playing a character older than her. Case in point: the person I'm using as my profile pic right now. People have been already complaining that Wiseman was visibly too old for them to play a cadet in her twenties back in season 1 of Discovery, and some didn't stop at saying she looked her age of 32 but actually went as far as declaring she looked at least five older than that.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top