• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Spoilers Andor season one

Ultimately the best place to put money in a multiplanetary society after transforming it into a despotic empire (be it in the real world, or Star Wars' world), is not decided by in a room meeting by bureaucrats who have only flown first class in space, but by experimenting what works well and what doesn't. I'm sure half of the armchair suggestions that got adopted as the most logical and reasonable choices didn't pan out well.

That's without the incompetence and carefree attitude shown in some circles.
 
By this point, the Empire has been around for 14 years. Aside from the remains of Jedi sympathizers, local worlds that needed invading to bring them into the Empire, and Separatist holdouts, there has not been any real rebellion against the Empire that has been a threat. Most of those have been crushed in the first ten years of the Empire, with the holdouts having been pretty much wiped out by the Andor present day. The Jedi problem has been all but eliminated according to Darth Vader. Sometimes Force sensitive children start showing and give them issues, or a rogue padawan shows up, but they usually aren't too much for the Inquisitors to handle. Until this theft, the rebels haven't been all that much of an issue. Local issues at most, handled by the local Moff, or ISB in the sector. But he Rebellion has been growing and coordinating. We see bits of it here, but the other bits from Rebels with what Bail Organa's elements are doing are also causing the Empire to take notice. By year's end there will be a burning Star Destroyer over Mustafar, and a very upset Grand Moff Tarkin calling in a certain Sith Lord to take care of the local Lothal problem.
 
The pacification of Mimban seen in Solo circa 10 BBY shows that the first decade of Imperial rule was indeed preoccupied with putting down resistance movements on occupied planets and flying the flag of the Empire to remind local natives who's now the boss.
 
It is a big half Galaxy or so the Empire holds claim over. The other half is the Unknown Regions, which are difficult to navigate. Ten years plus the Clone Wars for the Republic/Empire to pacify most of known civilization? If you are basically sending in a Star Destroyer or three with a legion of Stormtroopers to cow the locals most of the time...sure, doable. Leave a skeleton of a base with a handful of TIE Fighters, a squad to platoon of troopers, maybe a single smaller warship in system, and move on. All while building thousands of Imperial Star Destroyers, and a secret project that can blow up planets on the side. Under the more or less uncaring Senate's nose. Why would anyone in the Core Worlds care about anything beyond the Colonies or Inner Rim? They probably don't care much for the Mid-Rim. The Outer Rim? Not a care in the world. Ghoman is in the Colonies, which may be the reason anyone in the Senate would even notice what goes on there.
 
I wonder what makes credits so valuable though to the Empire. They can always make more. Does Inflation work in a galaxy like Star Wars?
 
Clearly the Republic had trouble getting people to even use their own credits.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Clearly the Republic had trouble getting people to even use their own credits.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
Tatooine wasn't a part of the Republic so the currency had nothing to back it up.
It seems strange to say it, but you have to remember the purchasing power of a dollar in 1977. a brand new Corvette stingray was about $8000 US. I doubt today's writers equate the value of an Imperial credit with what they imagined in was in '77. Although no direct comparison between real and imaginary currency is given anywhere, the lack of it probably makes people mentally assign a 1:1 value, dollars/pounds/euros to Imperial Credits.
I think Generation Tech has some of the better break downs on the Star Wars world building and this one, among others, discuss the credit situation.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I wonder what makes credits so valuable though to the Empire. They can always make more. Does Inflation work in a galaxy like Star Wars?

Why on earth would you think the basics of their economy would be different from our own? You can't just print money in our world to solve your financial problems, why would the Empire be any different?

It's also possible (though never stated anywhere) that Imperial/republic credits could be made of a precious metal or other substance, thus making them inherently valuable regardless of the status of the government. (Perhaps this is why Imperial credits "still spend" after the fall of the Empire.)
 
Another quirk of this kind of massive inefficient bureaucracy that was briefly touched on earlier in the show is that some facilities (namely the shipyards in that instance) would never admit to a theft if one even occurred for fear of exactly the kind of Imperial crackdown and takeover Preox-Morlana suffered because of Ferrix. Those few still operating under Imperial contract rather than being fully nationalised would rather eat the cost of a robbery than admit one ever took place.
How is this relevant to Aldhani given that it's a military installation? Simple: security arrangements are usually determined by assessments based on precedent. If there's a systemic unwillingness to admit failure and thus communicate inherent weaknesses to the wider organisation, then operational security will be habitually overestimated, while external threats will be habitually underestimated. The result is cluelessly lax security...until something that can't be ignored gets nicked then everyone runs around like headless chickens, which is what we're seeing now.

As for the money; let's keep things in perspective. 80 million may sound a lot, but it's not enough to fully finance the wider rebellion. It's a massive boost to be sure, but it will only go so far.
Yeah, you can buy a ship for around 10-20k. But in Star Wars "buying a ship" is like buying a car. The rebellion doesn't just need any old ships, it need military grade ships. Fighters. Frigates. Fleet tenders. Corvettes. You can bet those go for a LOT more than just 10-20k on the black market. Like if a second-hand civvy R-22 goes for anything less than half a million a-piece, I'd be very surprised. And that's before they could even get into building their own X-Wings & B-Wings. One can only get so far stealing from breakers yards after all.

They also need weapons. That means everything from proton bombs, to heavy blaster cannons, to small-arms. On top of that you have consumables like food, ammo, all environment combat clothing, battlefield comm-gear, replacement parts, tools, droids, bacta, and a million other logistical needs. And all of that would just be for just a relatively small group about the size of the Phoenix cell.

All of that is just to supply a fighting force; What about the intelligence network? They need money for much more specialized covert equipment. Concealed weapons. Forged documents. Surveillance gear. Underworld slicers. And probably most expensive of all: bribes. You think a frustrated mid-level Imperial bureaucrat is going to hand over classified intel, or look the other way on suspicious shipment manifests for anything less than five figures? Multiply that across the whole theatre of operation and suddenly that 80 million looks like it would struggle to even get Base One up and running for more than 6 months.

It wasn't about the money.

The Rebellion wanted the Emperor to freak out and hurt a few billion people.
 
I don't think it's a good place at all. Who is going to help them in case of invasion? Jam the comms, bombard from orbit or land crafts nearby to deploy troops. With amout of money there are, it's worth it. This is why banks are located in the cities so local security can respond with in minutes. And did anyone noticed how they stored them? Behind a thin tiny grid. It's ridiculous to even call this a vault.
They gave way way way to many handicaps to Empire to move this plot, to a point that it's simply no longer believable that such outpost can exists.

Actually everything about it makes complete sense.
 
I don't think it's a good place at all. Who is going to help them in case of invasion? Jam the comms, bombard from orbit or land crafts nearby to deploy troops. With amout of money there are, it's worth it.
Genius plan. Except nobody in the known galaxy has access to that kind of hardware and numbers besides the Empire (and maybe the Hutt Cartel?) Even if someone did; if they want half the mid-rim fleet shoved all the way up their arse in no time flat, launching a frontal assault would be a spectacular way to get exactly that outcome. Also I can't see a mere 80 million being worth mounting a planetary invasion. That the kind of thing that costs almost as much if not more than the potential take, so why bother?

The whole point of this plan is that it could only be pulled off by a small commando raid. Anything larger and the meteor shower that's keeping the Imperials grounded and acting as cover, would be an equal impediment for a larger attacking force. It's a quick smash and grab. Hell they didn't even get close to emptying the vault (barely managed half) and even that took them so long they were not only made, but lost half their crew getting away.

This is how insurgency works; by asymmetrical warfare. The rebellion is YEARS away from even attempting anything like a head-on confrontation with the Empire, and when they finally do; they get their arses kicked more often than not: Attilon, Hoth, the entire damn Mid-Rim Offensive. Hell even Endor wasn't won by sheer strength of arms, it was won by Imperial overconfidence and an inability to adapt.
It wasn't about the money.

The Rebellion wanted the Emperor to freak out and hurt a few billion people.
It was still mostly about the money. We see even Luthen pressuring Mothma to move the finances she has access to. Stirring up the hornets nest wasn't an end unto itself; they still needed to come out of it with the resources to actually capitalise on the inevitable Imperial reprisals.
 
Genius plan. Except nobody in the known galaxy has access to that kind of hardware and numbers besides the Empire (and maybe the Hutt Cartel?) Even if someone did; if they want half the mid-rim fleet shoved all the way up their arse in no time flat, launching a frontal assault would be a spectacular way to get exactly that outcome. Also I can't see a mere 80 million being worth mounting a planetary invasion. That the kind of thing that costs almost as much if not more than the potential take, so why bother?

The whole point of this plan is that it could only be pulled off by a small commando raid. Anything larger and the meteor shower that's keeping the Imperials grounded and acting as cover, would be an equal impediment for a larger attacking force. It's a quick smash and grab. Hell they didn't even get close to emptying the vault (barely managed half) and even that took them so long they were not only made, but lost half their crew getting away.

This is how insurgency works; by asymmetrical warfare. The rebellion is YEARS away from even attempting anything like a head-on confrontation with the Empire, and when they finally do; they get their arses kicked more often than not: Attilon, Hoth, the entire damn Mid-Rim Offensive. Hell even Endor wasn't won by sheer strength of arms, it was won by Imperial overconfidence and an inability to adapt.

It was still mostly about the money. We see even Luthen pressuring Mothma to move the finances she has access to. Stirring up the hornets nest wasn't an end unto itself; they still needed to come out of it with the resources to actually capitalise on the inevitable Imperial reprisals.

Droids making droids.

Droid foundries.

Planet sized Droid foundries.

Droids making droids making droids making star cruisers.

Money is not as important as you think.

Besides, the assumption is that most of their ships are donated pre empire junk.

The first star destroyers were built/bought by the Genosians, and handed over to the "Republic" as hard ware to accompany the first 2 million clones.

It wasn't gradual.

Member worlds of the Republic patrolled their own sectors, and then over night that responsibility was taken away from them, and they were told to park some where or disarm and become a freighter, since alternate peacekeeping fleets challenging Imperial control is unacceptable.
 
Droids making droids.

Droid foundries.

Planet sized Droid foundries.

Droids making droids making droids making star cruisers.

Money is not as important as you think.

Besides, the assumption is that most of their ships are donated pre empire junk.

The first star destroyers were built/bought by the Genosians, and handed over to the "Republic" as hard ware to accompany the first 2 million clones.

It wasn't gradual.

Member worlds of the Republic patrolled their own sectors, and then over night that responsibility was taken away from them, and they were told to park some where or disarm and become a freighter, since alternate peacekeeping fleets challenging Imperial control is unacceptable.

If all that were true, slavery wouldn't be a thing and everyone in the galaxy would be living an easy life free of poverty and material wants (and possibly murdered at age 30 by some twat in a tracksuit.)

It is and they're not; ergo money still matters. QED

Besides, a planet spanning droid foundry would still need a GARGANTUAN influx of resources daily. That means mining operations. Refineries. Trade-routes. Logistics. I think it's safe to say that nobody in the galaxy wants droids running around with the capability to dismantle whole star-systems en masse like swarms of von neumann probes, especially with their propensity to developing character quirks when left to their own devises for two long. So most of the resource control and management has to be done with organics at least supervising. That means a hierarchy and an economy and money.
 
And probably business connections between the Empire and the corporate and criminal syndicates of that era such as the Pykes. I imagine even a totalitarian government benefits from having close ties to organizations with lots of pocket cash and access to natural resources such as the Hutts and those others who survived the end of the Clone Wars.
 
The EU describes how the various criminal cartels and gangs were tolerated by the Empire so long as they didn't piss off the Empire. Black Sun thought it could go toe to toe with Vader himself.
Regardless of what changes were made in the new legendarium, I can't see them tossing out the concept wholesale.
 
It says a lot that Crimson Dawn managed to be led for a time by Maul without the Empire knowing he was at the head or just not caring, with the Emperor content to let his former apprentice wallow in the criminal underworld as a form of punishment for having fled from his Sith allegiance and code.
 
At least there were some droids in this episode. Correct me if I'm wrong but I didn't see a single droid in episode 6.
 
There was some kind of droid in the apartment of Syril's mother, a small, almost astromech-like droid on what look like four pads or feet. It's near the doorway? It's not rolling or moving around the apartment but it's there.
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top