• Welcome! The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans.
    If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Series 11 News & Spoilers

I was thinking more of the 2012-2013 period, where we had one hardcover Eleven novel in early 2012 (Jenny Colgan's Dark Horizons) and three Eleven/Clara novels in late 2013. Moffat didn't view the novels as important and BBC Books found him very difficult to deal with. I'm curious if Chibnall views the Doctor Who novels differently than Moffat did and if his relationship with BBC Books is better than their relationship with Moffat.
Weren't there rumours some months back that Chibnall was going to try to get a more regular novel line-up going again? At the very least, it would definitely be a wasted opportunity if they didn't have any novels this year. A year without new Who on TV and we know that when the show does return it will have the same cast as season 11. They can go to town with novels without worrying where to fit them in with the show. Actually, even fitting them in among season 11 isn't too problematic, they just have to take place after The Ghost Monument, and if Ryan still won't call Graham Grandpa, it's obviously before It Takes You Away.
 
^ Heck Graham flat out says they've made between 9 and 14 stops before Rosa.

Well, you have the Titan Comics Thirteenth Doctor comic which seems to be written some more approval from the series then the previous iterations. It also does seem like Moffat was more interested in helping out Big Finish (from the tighter relationship from the 50th on, to even producing far wider endings for the companions that could make easy spin-offs) during the "decline" at BBC Books.
 
Curious idea but what if people end up liking the novels better than the show or at least the most recent season of the show? Also this made me think of another question. Should or will they ever do a "Doctor Who" cartoon? I mean Trek has done it before and is soon to do it again. Seems like a great idea to explore some of the weird stuff in the Who universe.


Jason
 
Curious idea but what if people end up liking the novels better than the show or at least the most recent season of the show? Also this made me think of another question. Should or will they ever do a "Doctor Who" cartoon? I mean Trek has done it before and is soon to do it again. Seems like a great idea to explore some of the weird stuff in the Who universe.

They've been producing the books for 14 years and I can't think of too many that are as much loved as some of the Virgin New Adventures or Eighth Doctor Adventures. So I'm not too worried about the books supplanting the love for the series. And the books being very good can only mean good things. (Hell, I've owned a copy of Gallifrey Chronicles since before I technically knew what Doctor Who was.)

There have been a few animated stories under 10 but it seems like they were never that well received.
 
Curious idea but what if people end up liking the novels better than the show or at least the most recent season of the show? Also this made me think of another question. Should or will they ever do a "Doctor Who" cartoon? I mean Trek has done it before and is soon to do it again. Seems like a great idea to explore some of the weird stuff in the Who universe.


Jason

They did. Ten got the animated story Dreamland, set in Roswell.
 
IMO, Panini's DWM comics did a better job with their stories for Matt Smith and Peter Capaldi's Doctors than the show did.

Twenty-five years ago, I enjoyed Malibu's [b[Star Trek: Deep Space Nine[/b] comics more than the first season of the television series. I also found some of the Smith and Capaldi comics, whether from Panini, IDW, or Titan, more enjoyable than what was happening on television at the same time. The reason for feeling this way, five years ago and twenty-five years ago, is simple -- the comics were just trying to tell stories about the characters (in some cases, characters still being defined on screen) without having to do a lot of mythology building or deal with the Big Idea on screen.
 
Speaking of animated tropes, why can't we have some animated episodes again? It'd really help if they produced those during that god-awful gap, as it would fill a need and show some further adventures of the Doctor, as well as cement her further as an incarnation of the Doctor (even though, misogynists will likely never like her, any way anyway).
 
Speaking of animated tropes, why can't we have some animated episodes again? It'd really help if they produced those during that god-awful gap, as it would fill a need and show some further adventures of the Doctor, as well as cement her further as an incarnation of the Doctor (even though, misogynists will likely never like her, any way anyway).

Seems like a good idea but also something hard to pull off during the gap year. They would almost have to start working on it right this minute I suspect just to get it done in time to broadcast.


Jason
 
Oh, we're getting animated episodes aplenty - of the classic series, to fill in the gaps of the missing episodes. (The Macra Terror being next on the list, with Fury from the Deep heavily rumored to follow.) They recently said "We're not leaving Seasons 1-6 to the end" when it comes to Blu-Ray, so they've got a lot of work to do these next few years.

As far as Jodie and company, I do wonder if it wouldn't behoove Chibnall and the BBC to allow a Big Finish boxset with the current cast, maybe covering some of those pre-Rosa stops. There is classic series precedent (Slipback!) and would be far easier and quicker to slap together than anything animated.
 
I don't know if animated episodes is the answer. The one with the 10th Doctor wasn't well received from what I remember, and while I'm fine with the animated episode recreations on DVD, generally the BBC is extremely cheap so a cartoon based on a new story at this point would probably be so low in animation quality that it definitely wouldn't be helping the show.

Still, as long as Chibnail wasn't writing or producing it, I would check out a 13th Doctor animated story regardless of animation quality. An animated story would be the perfect place to go behind Chibnail's back and have a real Doctor Who story featuring the 13th Doctor. Bring a real Doctor Who enemy into the story, have real stakes that effect more then 1 or 2 people (and no, the episode about evil Space Amazon doesn't really count, especially because it was mediocre), and have the villains plan actually be a threat to a large group of people/the world, instead of shit like "stopping woman from getting on bus, which even if it succeeds would literally change nothing in the grand scheme of things because some person would have done something similar at some point during that time period anyway".

I just really want to see Whittaker actually play The Doctor at some point, and not just play a moronic pacifist who never does anything and travels with three cardboard boxes in human form. An animated story, even one that is done cheaply, probably has a better chance of doing that at this rate, especially during a gap year where Chibnail is probably to distracted to screw something like that up.
 
I do wonder if it wouldn't behoove Chibnall and the BBC to allow a Big Finish boxset with the current cast,
IIRC, Big Finish doesn't currently have the license to cover Whittaker's Doctor or any characters introduced during her run, and won't until after she leaves.
 
IIRC, Big Finish doesn't currently have the license to cover Whittaker's Doctor or any characters introduced during her run, and won't until after she leaves.
Yup, I believe that's the current agreement. We haven't seen anything with Matt Smith or Peter Capaldi yet because it's been too recent for them. I'm pretty sure they've already asked Smith and he turned it down for that reason.
 
We haven't seen anything with Matt Smith or Peter Capaldi yet because it's been too recent for them. I'm pretty sure they've already asked Smith and he turned it down for that reason.
Although they have covered stuff from the Smith and Capaldi eras. Didn't Michelle Gomez recently do Missy audios?
 
If you are not already a member then please register an account and join in the discussion!

Sign up / Register


Back
Top